Stung by revelations of ubiquitous surveillance and compromised software, the internet’s engineers and programmers ponder how to fight back
SECURITY guards (at least the good ones) are paid to be paranoid. Computer-security researchers are the same. Many had long suspected that governments use the internet not only to keep tabs on particular targets, but also to snoop on entire populations. But suspicions are not facts. So when newspapers began publishing documents leaked by Edward Snowden, once employed as a contractor by America’s National Security Agency (NSA), the world’s most munificently funded electronic spy agency, those researchers sat up.
They were especially incensed by leaks published in September by the Guardian and the New York Times, which suggested that American spooks (with help from their British counterparts) had been working quietly for years to subvert and undermine the cryptographic software and standards which make secure communication over the internet possible. “At that point”, says Matthew Green, a cryptographer at Johns Hopkins University, “people started to get really upset.”
On November 6th a meeting in Vancouver of the Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF), an organisation which brings together the scientists, technicians and programmers who built the internet in the first place and whose behind-the-scenes efforts keep it running, debated what to do about all this. A strong streak of West Coast libertarianism still runs through the IETF, and the tone was mostly hostile to the idea of omnipresent surveillance. Some of its members were involved in creating the parts of the internet that spooks are now exploiting. “I think we should treat this as an attack,” said Stephen Farrell, a computer scientist from Trinity College, Dublin, in his presentation to the delegates. Discussion then moved on to what should be done to thwart it.
We have the technology
As a sort of council of elders for the internet, the IETF has plenty of soft power. But it has no formal authority. Because its standards must be acceptable to users and engineers all over the world, it works through a slow process of consensus-building. New standards, guidelines and advice take months or years to produce.
Others, equally offended by the intelligence agencies’ activities, prefer not to wait, and are simply getting on with the job of trying to restore confidence in online security. As Bruce Schneier, a leading cryptographer, told the conference, it seems spies cannot actually break most cryptographic codes. Instead they try to work around them. One way is to subvert the standards and software which implement cryptography. That is possible because, besides trying to defeat the cryptographic efforts of others, the NSA also helps produce ciphers for Americans to use. Those same cryptographic standards are then employed all over the internet.
Researchers have therefore been warning users against employing anything that might have been tampered with. RSA Security, a big maker of encryption software, has advised its customers to stop using a random-number generator widely believed to have been fiddled with by the spooks to make its output predictable (random numbers are a crucial component of any cryptographic scheme, but are notoriously hard to produce on a deterministic machine such as a computer). And a group of Brazilian mathematicians has published a new set of codes for use with elliptic-curve cryptography, a novel scrambling technique that has been championed by the NSA. Anyone worried by the provenance of NSA-supplied curves is free to use these new ones instead.
Even America’s government is getting in on the act. The credibility of its National Institute of Standards and Technology, which sets American cryptographic standards with the help of the NSA, has been dented by Mr Snowden’s revelations.
Go deeper with Bing News on:
Internet security
- Opinion | The Biden FCC Brakes the Internet
The Biden Administration notes in an FCC filing that U.S. security agencies already have and “exercise substantial authorities with respect to the information and communications sectors.” The FCC ...
- The Biden FCC Brakes the Internet
The agency revives net neutrality to reassert political control.
- Why is so much of the internet’s infrastructure run by volunteers?
But last month another hole in the internet’s infrastructure was discovered: a volunteer who for two years had helped run XZ Utils, a piece of software used to compress and decompress data on Linux, ...
- A National Security Insider Does the Math on the Dangers of AI
Jason Matheny, CEO of the influential think tank Rand Corporation, says advances in AI are making it easier to learn how to build biological weapons and other tools of destruction.
- Best Wired Security Cameras
Our Top PicksBest Outdoor Wired Security CameraLorexLorex makes high quality security cameras and security camera systems — that’s it. So if you aren’t looking to outfit a smart home and don’t need a ...
Go deeper with Google Headlines on:
Internet security
[google_news title=”” keyword=”Internet security” num_posts=”5″ blurb_length=”0″ show_thumb=”left”]
Go deeper with Bing News on:
Computer security
- Consumer group names TSB, Co-op Bank and Monzo as worst major banks for mobile app security
The group reviewed the apps and websites of Britain's 13 largest current account providers between January and February, with assistance from computer security experts.
- Which? urges banks to address online security ‘loopholes’
Which? urges banks to address online security ‘loopholes’ - With many people increasingly banking online or on their phones, it is crucial that security protections are up to scratch, Which? said.
- COMP.2300 Introduction to Computer Security (Formerly COMP.3611)
For topics in computer security, this course will cover an overview of operation systems security (particularly Linux), password security, access control mechanisms, patching, vulnerability analysis, ...
- Computer chips are a national security issue, but the solution isn’t just more chips
US investment in semiconductors is important, but it also opens new vulnerabilities like RISC-V architecture which China has exploited. The US, ...
- A hack nearly gained access to millions of computers. Here’s what we should learn from this.
Finding the best ways to do good. One of the most fascinating and frightening incidents in computer security history started in 2022 with a few pushy emails to the mailing list for a small ...
Go deeper with Google Headlines on:
Computer security
[google_news title=”” keyword=”computer security” num_posts=”5″ blurb_length=”0″ show_thumb=”left”]