via Oregon State University
Telepresence robots help university students learning remotely to feel more a part of the class, new research by Oregon State University suggests.
The findings are particularly important given the nationwide shift to online instruction caused by the COVID-19 pandemic, forcing many students who otherwise would be in classrooms and labs to pursue their education from a distance.
The National Science Foundation study led by Naomi Fitter of the OSU College of Engineering examined the experiences of university students attending classes in three formats: in person; through a telepresence robot; and via distance learning tools such as livestreaming, recorded lectures and calling into class with questions.
Findings were published in Robotics and Automation Letters.
The preferences of the 18 engineering students who were studied were split between distance learning tools, or DLTs, and attending in person. Instructors of the four courses in the study uniformly preferred teaching students in person.
But the instructors felt telepresence robots were preferable to distance learning tools for remote learning, and the students noted the robots’ ability to keep them more engaged, expressive and self-aware.
Even before the pandemic, Fitter notes, 14% of university students in the United States were pursuing degrees exclusively online, and another 15% were using distance learning technologies at least some of the time.
“Students engage in distance learning for many reasons,” she said. “There are fundamental challenges in distance learning, such as the need to find a way to train students in the time management and active listening skills typically developed during higher education. Distance learners are also susceptible to missing out on benefiting from their peers – effective social interaction while learning leads to better critical thinking and longer-term information retention.”
The user interface for the robots in the study included forward- and downward-facing camera views, zooming options, mouse- and keyboard-based robot driving, and menus for adjusting audiovisual elements.
“Past research has explored the use of telepresence robots in a wide variety of contexts including hospitals, offices, museums and professional conferences,” Fitter said.
Participants in the study, which also included researchers Nisha Raghunath and Christopher Sanchez of the OSU College of Liberal Arts, attended class via each assigned method for a two-week period. The courses were four medium-sized, upper-level engineering classes – machine learning, software architectures, analysis of algorithms, and computer systems organization – consisting mainly of traditional lectures in a classroom, with student participation encouraged.
The OSU researchers and collaborators at the University of Southern California and the University of California, Santa Cruz, entered the study with three hypotheses:
- Attending class in person will lead to better self-reported learning outcomes for students.
- Using the telepresence robot will lead to greater feelings of presence and self-expression than the distance learning technologies – the feelings of presence when using a robot will be closer to the feelings of presence when attending class in person than through distance learning methods.
- When students are unable to attend class in person, they and their instructors will prefer telepresence robots as a remote learning solution over distance learning methods.
“Participants generally used the robots to view the lecture, ask questions during the lecture, and move around during breaks to talk to friends or instructors,” Fitter said. “When asked to choose a single favorite method for attending class, nine participants chose in-person attendance, eight chose the DLT resources, and one chose the telepresence robot.”
In-person learning ranked higher than the other attendance methods in every aspect of a daily survey completed by participants except for ease of learning, in which it tied with distance learning technologies. In-person learning was described as more social and individually expressive compared to other learning methods, and feelings of presence and interaction abilities were also better in person.
“Not all students had realized the value of in-person learning before the study,” Fitter said. “Instructors uniformly preferred in-person attendance by students. But there were drawbacks to in-person learning too, such as ‘a person sits beside me and is always talking.’”
In their post-study interviews, student participants generally offered positive comments about the robots but noted imperfections like “there were times when I was not able to read from the screen properly” and “I wasn’t sure about my speaking volume.”
“If a telepresence robot doesn’t have sufficient camera quality, investing in other new features for it may be futile,” Fitter said.
Instructors for the most part appreciated being able to see students’ faces and nonverbal expressions while expressing a preference for remote students attending class using a telepresence robot.
“Despite reporting certain challenges, participants seemed to have overall positive experiences using the telepresence robots,” Fitter said. “Understanding how to use technologies to keep people connected will increase in importance in this world of increasingly spread-out families, teams and classes.”
The Latest Updates from Bing News & Google News
Go deeper with Bing News on:
- ‘Telepresence’ robots are making virtual school feel a little more like real schoolon November 10, 2020 at 1:17 pm
It has been a year full of the unexpected for families who have had to quickly adjust to masks, quarantines and virtual and hybrid learning, all thanks to the coronavirus pandemic. For Eliza Engel and ...
- Telepresence Robot With Skype Connectivityon November 9, 2020 at 4:00 pm
It’s called Botiful and aims to turn any Android phone into a mobile telepresence robot. Botiful is built around the IOIO Android to Arduino dev board and provides a very clean way to ...
- The next big thing in classrooms: 'Zoom on wheels' robots are seeing a surge in demandon November 7, 2020 at 5:06 am
Telepresence robots still lack crucial capabilities, but students and teachers young and old credit their mobility to helping them stay engaged.
- Robots get private view of major pop art showon November 4, 2020 at 4:09 am
Telepresence robots - remote-controlled robots on wheels with cameras and a tablet screen are on offer for those who don’t attend in person. “I wanted to stage my exhibition opening using ...
- telepresence roboton November 2, 2020 at 4:00 pm
[Erik Knutsson] is stuck inside with a bunch of robot parts, and we know what lies down that path. His Open Personal Assistant Robotic Platform aims to help out around the house with things like ...
Go deeper with Google Headlines on:
Go deeper with Bing News on:
- Regional UW campuses to shift online following Thanksgivingon November 12, 2020 at 3:56 pm
Campuses will remain open during remote instruction. Students will be allowed to live in dorms, use dining services, libraries, study spaces and wifi.
- 5 more high schools pivot to online learning due to COVID-19 caseson November 12, 2020 at 3:54 pm
Five high schools from across northern Utah are transitioning into online learning due to an increasing number COVID-19 cases, various school officials announced Thursday.
- Here's where area school districts stand on virtual instructionon November 12, 2020 at 3:37 pm
Several Eastern Iowa school districts are adjusting in-person learning as cases of coronavirus soar in Iowa: • The Cedar Rapids Community School District is online now until Nov. 30. The Iowa ...
- Wyoming latest school district to announce move to online learning in coronavirus surgeon November 12, 2020 at 3:35 pm
Wyoming Public Schools is the latest district in Kent and Ottawa counties to announce it is closing buildings and moving temporarily to remote learning as coronavirus cases surge across the region.
- More Indiana schools move online as COVID-19 spread spikeson November 12, 2020 at 2:42 pm
Dozens of Indiana school districts are changing in-person learning schedules or sending students home as the state continues to report record increases in new coronavirus infections and ...