Image: Stock photo
Overall, adding robots to manufacturing reduces jobs — by more than three per robot, in fact. But a new study co-authored by an MIT professor reveals an important pattern: Firms that move quickly to use robots tend to add workers to their payroll, while industry job losses are more concentrated in firms that make this change more slowly.
The study, by MIT economist Daron Acemoglu, examines the introduction of robots to French manufacturing in recent decades, illuminating the business dynamics and labor implications in granular detail.
“When you look at use of robots at the firm level, it is really interesting because there is an additional dimension,” says Acemoglu. “We know firms are adopting robots in order to reduce their costs, so it is quite plausible that firms adopting robots early are going to expand at the expense of their competitors whose costs are not going down. And that’s exactly what we find.”
Indeed, as the study shows, a 20 percentage point increase in robot use in manufacturing from 2010 to 2015 led to a 3.2 percent decline in industry-wide employment. And yet, for firms adopting robots during that timespan, employee hours worked rose by 10.9 percent, and wages rose modestly as well.
A new paper detailing the study, “Competing with Robots: Firm-Level Evidence from France,” will appear in the May issue of the American Economic Association: Papers and Proceedings. The authors are Acemoglu, who is an Institute Professor at MIT; Clair Lelarge, a senior research economist at the Banque de France and the Center for Economic Policy Research; and Pascual Restrepo Phd ’16, an assistant professor of economics at Boston University.
A French robot census
To conduct the study, the scholars examined 55,390 French manufacturing firms, of which 598 purchased robots during the period from 2010 to 2015. The study uses data provided by France’s Ministry of Industry, client data from French robot suppliers, customs data about imported robots, and firm-level financial data concerning sales, employment, and wages, among other things.
The 598 firms that did purchase robots, while comprising just 1 percent of manufacturing firms, accounted for about 20 percent of manufacturing production during that five-year period.
“Our paper is unique in that we have an almost comprehensive [view] of robot adoption,” Acemoglu says.
The manufacturing industries most heavily adding robots to their production lines in France were pharmaceutical companies, chemicals and plastic manufacturers, food and beverage producers, metal and machinery manufacturers, and automakers.
The industries investing least in robots from 2010 to 2015 included paper and printing, textiles and apparel manufacturing, appliance manufacturers, furniture makers, and minerals companies.
The firms that did add robots to their manufacturing processes became more productive and profitable, and the use of automation lowered their labor share — the part of their income going to workers — between roughly 4 and 6 percentage points. However, because their investments in technology fueled more growth and more market share, they added more workers overall.
By contrast, the firms that did not add robots saw no change in the labor share, and for every 10 percentage point increase in robot adoption by their competitors, these firms saw their own employment drop 2.5 percent. Essentially, the firms not investing in technology were losing ground to their competitors.
This dynamic — job growth at robot-adopting firms, but job losses overall — fits with another finding Acemoglu and Restrepo made in a separate paper about the effects of robots on employment in the U.S. There, the economists found that each robot added to the work force essentially eliminated 3.3 jobs nationally.
“Looking at the result, you might think [at first] it’s the opposite of the U.S. result, where the robot adoption goes hand in hand with destruction of jobs, whereas in France, robot-adopting firms are expanding their employment,” Acemoglu says. “But that’s only because they’re expanding at the expense of their competitors. What we show is that when we add the indirect effect on those competitors, the overall effect is negative and comparable to what we find the in the U.S.”
Superstar firms and the labor share issue
The competitive dynamics the researchers found in France resemble those in another high-profile piece of economics research recently published by MIT professors. In a recent paper, MIT economists David Autor and John Van Reenen, along with three co-authors, published evidence indicating the decline in the labor share in the U.S. as a whole was driven by gains made by “superstar firms,” which find ways to lower their labor share and gain market power.
While those elite firms may hire more workers and even pay relatively well as they grow, labor share declines in their industries, overall.
“It’s very complementary,” Acemoglu observes about the work of Autor and Van Reenen. However, he notes, “A slight difference is that superstar firms [in the work of Autor and Van Reenen, in the U.S.] could come from many different sources. By having this individual firm-level technology data, we are able to show that a lot of this is about automation.”
So, while economists have offered many possible explanations for the decline of the labor share generally — including technology, tax policy, changes in labor market institutions, and more — Acemoglu suspects technology, and automation specifically, is the prime candidate, certainly in France.
“A big part of the [economic] literature now on technology, globalization, labor market institutions, is turning to the question of what explains the decline in the labor share,” Acemoglu says. “Many of those are reasonably interesting hypotheses, but in France it’s only the firms that adopt robots — and they are very large firms — that are reducing their labor share, and that’s what accounts for the entirety of the decline in the labor share in French manufacturing. This really emphasizes that automation, and in particular robots, is a critical part in understanding what’s going on.”
The Latest Updates from Bing News & Google News
Go deeper with Bing News on:
- Robots running the industrial world are open to cyber attackson August 9, 2020 at 6:31 am
Hackers could steal data or alter a robot's movements remotely, like a scene out of science fiction, a report says.
- Cloud Robotics Market Research Report by Connectivity Technology, by Type, by Deployment - Global Forecast to 2025 - Cumulative Impact of COVID-19on August 7, 2020 at 9:51 pm
Reportlinker.com announces the release of the report "Cloud Robotics Market Research Report by Connectivity Technology, by Type, by Deployment - Global Forecast to 2025 - Cumulative Impact of COVID-19 ...
- Pacesetters: East West Manufacturing maintains corporate culture through growthon August 7, 2020 at 4:06 am
East West Manufacturing is the top fastest-growing company on the Pacesetter list in the manufacturing/supply and distribution category and also the No. 11 fastest-growing company on the overall ...
- Service Robotics Market Expected to Grow at CAGR 15.25% and Forecast to 2025on August 6, 2020 at 4:19 pm
Service Robotics Market delivers a succinct analysis of industry size, regional growth and revenue forecasts for ...
- Increasingly Popular Industrial Robots Are Vulnerable to Cyber Attacks, Report Warnson August 6, 2020 at 7:07 am
Industrial robots are now being used to assemble everything from airplanes to smartphones, using human-like arms to mechanically repeat the same processes ...
Go deeper with Google Headlines on:
Go deeper with Bing News on:
- RPA competitors battle for a bigger prize: automation everywhereon August 8, 2020 at 6:09 pm
Relative to previous surveys, we do see some softness in traditional RPA strongholds such as large financials, insurance and giant public and privates. But RPA relative to other technology investments ...
- Bugs in HDL Automation expose IoT devices to remote hijackingon August 8, 2020 at 10:03 am
A security researcher discovered vulnerabilities in an automation system for smart homes and buildings that allowed taking over accounts belonging to other users and control associated devices.
- Quantzig: Unleash the Power of AI and Intelligent Automation to Make-headway in the New Normalon August 7, 2020 at 10:05 am
Quantzig recently surveyed business leaders from various industries to analyze the global impact of intelligent automation.
- AP Automation Is Ready For WFH Accountingon August 7, 2020 at 9:11 am
PYMNTS' Reinventing B2B Payments Report done with American Express looks at the AR and AP automation space from the perspective of businesses in recovery mode.
- Global Industrial Automation Control Industry Outlook, 2024 - Increasing Focus on Smart Factories and Changing Market Dynamicson August 7, 2020 at 8:05 am
The "Global Industrial Automation Control Market 2020-2024" report has been added to ResearchAndMarkets.com's offering. The global industrial automation control market is poised to grow by $25.18 ...