Jonathan Boreyko and Brook Kennedy inspect a fog harp at Kentland Farm. Photo by Peter Means for Virginia Tech.
What do you get when you cross a novel approach to water harvesting with a light fog? The answer: a lot more water than you expected.
The development of the fog harp, a Virginia Tech interdisciplinary pairing of engineering with biomimetic design, was first reported in 2018. The hope behind the fog harp’s development was simple: in areas of the world where water is scarce but fog is present, pulling usable water from fog could become a sustainable option. While fog nets are already in use, the superior efficiency of the fog harp could dramatically increase the number of regions worldwide where fog harvesting is viable. The difference comes in the fog harp’s uncanny ability to derive water from less dense fog than its predecessors.
The partnered approach has been a combination of new design with existing science. The science initiated with Assistant Professor Jonathan Boreyko from the Department of Mechanical Engineering within the College of Engineering. His group hypothesized the harp approach and characterized the performance of the harp prototypes. Design development has been led by Associate Professor Brook Kennedy from the Department of Industrial Design in the College of Architecture and Urban Studies. Kennedy’s product development and materials knowledge brought the project to the point where it could be prototyped and tested in real-world environments. Early funding came from the Institute for Creativity, Arts, and Technology.
“Billions of people face water scarcity worldwide,” Kennedy said. “We feel that the fog harp is a great example of a relatively simple, low-tech invention that leverages insight from nature to help communities meet their most basic needs.”
The “harp” design uses parallel wires to collect ambient water from fog, whereas current technology in use around the globe relies primarily on a screen mesh. The lab-proven theory for the new device was that parallel wires are more efficient at gathering water, avoiding clogs and enhancing drainage into the collector. The researchers’ small-scale early tests showed that in high-fog conditions, their harps outpaced those with meshes by a factor of two to one.
Testing then literally moved to the field. In the open fields of Virginia Tech’s Kentland Farm, then-undergraduate Brandon Hart built roofed structures to prevent rainfall from impacting findings. Under these coverings, fog harps were placed side-by-side with three different mesh harvesters: one with wire diameters equivalent to the harp, one with a wire size more optimal to harvesting, and one using Raschel mesh — a mesh made of flat-panel ribbons in v-shaped arrays between horizontal supports. This v-shaped mesh is currently the most popular among fog harvesting sites around the world.
Whereas heavy fog conditions were used in the lab, the actual fog conditions surrounding Virginia Tech are generally much lighter. As field tests began, Boreyko and Kennedy were skeptical that the available fog would provide the feedback they needed to do adequate testing. They were pleasantly surprised.
As fog began rolling over the hills of the New River Valley, the fog harps always showed results. In thin fog, the collection pipes of the mesh collectors were completely devoid of drips. Even as fog density increased, the harps continued outperforming their companions. Depending on the density of the fog, this ranged from twice as much output to almost 20 times.
Bringing together lab studies and field data, researchers determined that collection potential is the result of multiple factors. Greatest among these is the size of collectable water droplets between mesh and harp. To be harvested in both cases, water must be caught on the mesh or harp as air passes through, traveling downward into collection points by gravity. Fog harps use only vertical wires, creating an unimpeded path for mobile drops. Mesh collectors, by contrast, have both horizontal and vertical construction, and water droplets must be significantly larger to cross the horizontal pieces. In field tests, mesh collectors routinely required droplets reaching a size roughly 100 times larger than those on harps before descending. Water that never drops will simply evaporate and cannot be collected.
“We already knew that in heavy fog, we can get at least two times as much water,” said Boreyko. “But realizing in our field tests that we can get up to 20 times more water on average in a moderate fog gives us hope we can dramatically enhance the breadth of regions where fog harvesting is a viable tool for getting decentralized, fresh water.”
The Latest Updates from Bing News & Google News
Go deeper with Bing News on:
- Told Slant Embraces the Perils of Intimacy and Devotion on 'Point the Flashlight and Walk'on November 12, 2020 at 12:40 pm
For Brooklyn singer-songwriter, Felix Walworth, a.k.a. Told Slant, the gravity of devotion is a risk that has never weighed heavier. So ...
- Jill Burcum: When will I be over COVID-19? I may never knowon November 8, 2020 at 8:00 pm
There's a misperception out there that if you get COVID and don't need hospitalization, you'll just feel like you have a bad cold. Our experience suggests that there's a lot ...
- Commentary by COVID-19 survivor: Dealing with the uncertainty of long-term effectson November 7, 2020 at 8:02 am
Still, we’re well aware that many who become ill report lingering effects for months. Nerve pain, extreme fatigue, swollen toes, racing heart rates and memory lapses dubbed “brain fog” are among the ...
- COVID survivors face a long, uncertain journey back to health | Opinionon November 5, 2020 at 11:36 am
It helped, and I feel relatively normal now, though I’m wondering about COVID “brain fog.” I play the harp, and things feel glitchy in translating musical notes to the strings. It could also ...
- Mobile food tracking app may offer farm-to-table transparencyon November 2, 2020 at 9:46 am
RELATED Fog harp can harvest water from even the lightest of fogs The merchant can then use the QR code to provide buyers information about the soybeans' origin and journey. "My mission is to make ...
Go deeper with Google Headlines on:
Go deeper with Bing News on:
- Emergency order closes part of James River for shellfish harvesting due to heavy rainon November 12, 2020 at 4:08 pm
The Virginia Department of Health announced today that a portion of the James River is closed to shellfish harvesting due to significant river flooding. The temporary ...
- Vaishno Devi board bags top prize for water conservation and managementon November 12, 2020 at 3:05 pm
Jammu, Nov 12 (PTI) The Shri Mata Vaishno Devi Shrine Board (SMVDSB) has bagged the first prize in the 'National Water Awards-2019' for promotion of water conservation and proper management of water, ...
- Shrine Board bags 1st prize for water conservation & managementon November 12, 2020 at 12:32 pm
Shri Mata Vaishno Devi Shrine Board has bagged the first prize of the ‘National Water Awards-2019’. The Award has ...
- Focus on projects related to 24x7 water supply, says Delhi CM Arvind Kejriwalon November 11, 2020 at 7:21 pm
A meeting held with Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal, DJB chairperson Satyendar Jain and vice-chairperson Raghav Chadha in attendance, reviewed the issue of 24x7 water supply.
- Will adopt cost-effective Dungarpur model of rainwater harvesting: Satyendar Jainon November 9, 2020 at 8:27 pm
Water Minister Satyendar Jain said the Dungarpur model was an innovative idea that was cenetred on routing the rainwater to a bore well, instead of a regular rainwater-harvesting pit.