UC Riverside study shows that, while people can come to appreciate recycled water’s benefits, they still don’t want to use it
If people are educated on recycled water, they may come to agree it’s perfectly safe and tastes as good — or better — than their drinking water. They may even agree it’s an answer to the critical water imbalance in California, where the northern third of the state holds 75% of the water despite 80% of the demand coming from the southern two-thirds. But that doesn’t mean they’re going to use recycled water — and it sure doesn’t mean they’ll drink it. And the reason lies in the word “disgust.”
That’s the result of a series of studies by UC Riverside psychology researchers Mary Gauvain and Daniel Harmon published recently in the journal Basic and Applied Social Psychology.
Past research by Harmon and Gauvain explored whether people sense a difference in taste among recycled water, conventional tap water, and commercially bottled water. That study, released in spring 2018, was based on a blind taste test and found people actually preferred the taste of recycled water over conventional tap water.
However, “The idea of recycled wastewater in general evokes disgust reactions,” Harmon said at the time.
This idea was addressed in the psychologists’ latest research. If people disgusted by the notion of recycled wastewater are educated on its safety and benefits, will their attitudes change? And, will they change their behaviors?
In the research paper, “disgust” is defined as “a strong repulsion to a potentially harmful substance.” In addition to disgust, the research considered other factors that dissuade people from using recycled water. Those included misinformation, ignorance, and peoples’ desire to conform to social norms.
The research involved three separate studies and a total of 886 participants.
In study one, half of the subjects viewed a brief, pro-conservation internet video. The other group watched a short video about water, but not conservation, about the urban myth that crocodiles live in the sewer system of New York City.
Researchers found both groups failed to budge in their willingness to endorse sustainable water. Ninety-six percent of participants cited disgust as the reason. Distilling the reasoning even more, the researchers asked if participants were motivated by cleanliness or fear of illness. Sixty-five percent said cleanliness.
In study two, the videos were used again. But this time, an educational video demonstrating recycled wastewater is contaminant-free was also shown to address the disgust reaction. The pro-conservation and disgust videos had a “small but unsubstantial effect on peoples’ willingness to use recycled wastewater” the research found.
In the last study, participants viewed all three videos. But this time, after completing a post-video survey, they were offered a bottle of water labeled “SMARTdrop—Pure Recycled Water” and asked to sign a conservation petition.
Researchers hypothesized participants who watched the video addressing disgust would be more likely to accept the water and sign the petition. In fact, a similar number across all three groups — about two-thirds — took the water bottle and signed the petition.
The results of the three studies run counter to previous findings that assert media information can influence peoples’ water conservation attitudes. Instead, they show internet messages may encourage people to view water sustainability more positively, but they do not encourage more sustainable water behaviors.
The article drawn from the research, “Influence of Internet-Based Messages and Personal Motivations on Water-Use Decisions,” discourages using pro-recycled wastewater internet videos about water scarcity and conservation alone. Instead, researchers urge a focus on the more visceral roadblock of disgust. As an example, the researchers suggest a video stressing the extent of water purification in recycling plants as part of larger campaigns to change behaviors.
“Disgust is an exceptionally robust motivation that may require stronger intervention to overcome,” Harmon said.
The Latest on: Recycled water
- TN CM inaugurates water-recycling plant in Chennaion November 29, 2019 at 4:16 pm
Chennai, Nov 29 (PTI): A water-recycling plant to meet the needs of the industries and domestic consumers was inaugurated by Tamil Nadu Chief Minister K Palaniswami here on Friday. The plant would ...
- Tamil Nadu CM K Palaniswami inaugurates water-recycling plant in Chennaion November 29, 2019 at 8:19 am
CHENNAI: A water-recycling plant to meet the needs of the industries and domestic consumers was inaugurated by Tamil Nadu Chief Minister K Palaniswami here on Friday. The plant would ensure water ...
- In the face of severe drought recycled TOILET WATER is on the cards for Sydneyon November 26, 2019 at 5:35 pm
A state minister has asked the NSW government to investigate the potential of expanding water recycling by adding toilet water for use in public spaces and outdoors. Water Minister Melinda Pavey ...
- Minister flags water recycling expansion for Sydney as drought intensifieson November 26, 2019 at 6:01 am
Water recycling could be expanded in Sydney as the NSW government orders an urgent report into all options to boost the city’s supply amid the worsening drought. Water Minister Melinda Pavey has asked ...
- Swedish Experts Use Recycled Sewage Water To Brew Beeron November 26, 2019 at 3:54 am
Swedish experts have used recycled sewage water, passed it through delicate membranes and cleaning processes including reverse osmosis and turned it into the country's first hot-selling beer. The ...
- Queensland still ‘well away’ from tapping recycled wateron November 26, 2019 at 2:31 am
Queenslanders are “well away” from having recycled wastewater added to their drinking supplies as the government continues to deal with the implications of severe drought, a minister has claimed.
- Can you drink beer brewed from recycled sewage water? Swedish brand sells 6000 litreson November 25, 2019 at 11:00 pm
STOCKHOLM: Having reservations about drinking recycled sewage water? Have a beer! Swedish experts have used recycled sewage water, passed it through delicate membranes and cleaning processes including ...
- Water Recycling System Market To Witness Huge Growth By 2025 | 3M, Honeywell, Panasonic, Unileveron November 25, 2019 at 5:00 am
Nov 25, 2019 (HTF Market Intelligence via COMTEX) -- HTF MI recently introduced Global Water Recycling System Market study with in-depth overview, describing about the Product / Industry Scope and ...
- Ick Factor Is High Hurdle for Recycled Drinking Wateron November 24, 2019 at 5:18 pm
Recycled wastewater can be cleaner than bottled water, but people still avoid drinking it because of their disgust over its past condition. Would you drink water that had once been flushed down a ...
- San Francisco Recycled Water Program Pushing Wastewater Towards Drinkabilityon November 20, 2019 at 6:51 pm
SAN FRANCISCO (KPIX 5) — The city of San Francisco could be drawing on a new source of drinking water that is a recycled version of what’s being flushed down toilets. On Wednesday, KPIX 5 learned ...
via Bing News
The Latest on: Sustainable water
- Stuart moves forward on long-term plan for more sustainable water sourceon November 25, 2019 at 4:55 pm
Stuart moves forward on long-term plan for more sustainable water source The city plans to change its source of water to a more sustainable well that is less likely to be contaminated. Check out this ...
- Why You're Smart to Buy This Sustainable Water Stockon November 16, 2019 at 9:19 am
It's been a slightly disappointing year for sustainable water company Xylem (NYSE:XYL). While the stock is still up 16% on a year-to-date basis, it's underperformed the S&P 500 by slightly more than 7 ...
- Investing in sustainable water solutions for the futureon November 15, 2019 at 7:06 am
A water-focused investment strategy provides exposure to environmental and social factors, enhancing the appeal of the investment proposition. Alignment with selected Sustainable Development Goals, ...
- World Bank and Swedbank Partner to Raise Awareness for Sustainable Water and Ocean Resourceson November 14, 2019 at 4:00 pm
WASHINGTON, DC, November 15, 2019 –The World Bank (International Bank for Reconstruction and Development or IBRD, Aaa/AAA) launched a 7-year SEK 2 billion Sustainable Development Bond as it continues ...
- Multipartner SICAV RobecoSAM Sustainable Water N EURon November 13, 2019 at 4:00 pm
It is suitable for long-term-oriented equity investors who are convinced of the sustainable potential of the water market, and for inclusion in a globally diversified portfolio.
- Multipartner SICAV - RobecoSAM Sustainable Water Fund D EURon November 13, 2019 at 4:00 pm
products or services that are related to the water value chain and which show an elevated degree of sustainability. The performance data shown in tables and graphs on this page is calculated in USD of ...
- FF Sustainable Water & Waste E Acc EURon November 10, 2019 at 4:00 pm
"The fund aims to provide investors with long-term capital growth, primarily through investment in the equity securities of companies throughout the world, including emerging markets, which maintain ...
- Multipartner SICAV - RobecoSAM Sustainable Water Fund B CHFon October 30, 2019 at 5:00 pm
products or services that are related to the water value chain and which show an elevated degree of sustainability.
- Fidelity Funds - Sustainable Water & Waste Fund I Acc EURon October 30, 2019 at 5:00 pm
The fund aims to provide investors with long-term capital growth, primarily through investment in the equity securities of companies throughout the world, which maintain sustainable characteristics.
- 'Chennai’s journey towards sustainable water supply alternative has begun'on October 16, 2019 at 6:09 pm
Chennai’s journey towards sustainable water supply alternative has just begun. It is moving in the right direction to bring in wastewater reuse under the network. Community outreach must become a ...
via Bing News