Self-driving cars are coming. But for all their fancy sensors and intricate data-crunching abilities, even the most cutting-edge cars lack something that (almost) every 16-year-old with a learner’s permit has: social awareness.
While autonomous technologies have improved substantially, they still ultimately view the drivers around them as obstacles made up of ones and zeros, rather than human beings with specific intentions, motivations and personalities.
But recently a team led by researchers at MIT’s Computer Science and Artificial Intelligence Laboratory (CSAIL) has been exploring whether self-driving cars can be programmed to classify the social personalities of other drivers, so that they can better predict what different cars will do – and, therefore, be able to drive more safely among them.
In a new paper, the scientists integrated tools from social psychology to classify driving behavior with respect to how selfish or selfless a particular driver is.
Specifically, they used something called Social Value Orientation (SVO), which represents the degree to which someone is selfish (“egoistic”) versus altruistic or cooperative (“prosocial”). The system then estimates drivers’ SVOs to create real-time driving trajectories for self-driving cars.
Testing their algorithm on the tasks of merging lanes and making unprotected left turns, the team showed that they could better predict the behavior of other cars by a factor of 25 percent. For example, in the left-turn simulations their car knew to wait when the approaching car had a more egoistic driver, and to then make the turn when the other car was more prosocial.
While not yet robust enough to be implemented on real roads, the system could have some intriguing use cases, and not just for the cars that drive themselves. Say you’re a human driving along and a car suddenly enters your blind spot – the system could give you a warning in the rear-view mirror that the car has an aggressive driver, allowing you to adjust accordingly. It could also allow self-driving cars to actually learn to exhibit more human-like behavior that will be easier for human drivers to understand.
“Working with and around humans means figuring out their intentions to better understand their behavior,” says graduate student Wilko Schwarting, who was lead author on the new paper that will be published this week in the latest issue of the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS). “People’s tendencies to be collaborative or competitive often spills over into how they behave as drivers. In this paper we sought to understand if this was something we could actually quantify.”
Schwarting’s co-authors include MIT professors Sertac Karaman and Daniela Rus, as well as research scientist Alyssa Pierson and former CSAIL postdoctoral associate Javier Alonso-Mora.
Trafficking in human emotion
A central issue with today’s self-driving cars is that they’re programmed to assume that all humans act the same way. This means that, among other things, they’re quite conservative in their decision-making at four-way stops and other intersections.
While this caution reduces the chance of fatal accidents, it also creates bottlenecks that can be frustrating for other drivers, not to mention hard for them to understand. (This may be why the majority of traffic incidents have involved getting rear-ended by impatient drivers.)
“Creating more human-like behavior in autonomous vehicles (AVs) is fundamental for the safety of passengers and surrounding vehicles, since behaving in a predictable manner enables humans to understand and appropriately respond to the AV’s actions,” says Schwarting.
To try to expand the car’s social awareness, the CSAIL team combined methods from social psychology with game theory, a theoretical framework for conceiving social situations among competing players.
The team modeled road scenarios where each driver tried to maximize their own utility and analyzed their “best responses” given the decisions of all other agents. Based on that small snippet of motion from other cars, the team’s algorithm could then predict the surrounding cars’ behavior as cooperative, altruistic, or egoistic — grouping the first two as “prosocial.” People’s scores for these qualities rest on a continuum with respect to how much a person demonstrates care for themselves versus care for others.
In the merging and left-turn scenarios, the two outcome options were to either let somebody merge into your lane (“prosocial”) or not (“egoistic”). The team’s results showed that, not surprisingly, merging cars are deemed more competitive than non-merging cars.
The system was trained to try to better understand when it’s appropriate to exhibit different behaviors. For example, even the most deferential of human drivers knows that certain types of actions – like making a lane change in heavy traffic – require a moment of being more assertive and decisive.
For the next phase of the research, the team plans to work to apply their model to pedestrians, bicycles and other agents in driving environments. In addition, they will be investigating other robotic systems acting among humans, such as household robots, and integrating SVO into their prediction and decision-making algorithms. Pierson says that the ability to estimate SVO distributions directly from observed motion instead of in laboratory conditions will be important for fields far beyond autonomous driving.
“By modeling driving personalities and incorporating the models mathematically using the SVO in the decision-making module of a robot car, this work opens the door to safer and more seamless road-sharing between human-driven and robot-driven cars,” says Rus.
Learn more: Predicting people’s driving personalities
The Latest on: Social Value Orientation
- Utah’s governor proposes revised rule to ban conversion therapy on LGBTQ childrenon November 26, 2019 at 6:24 pm
It follows a highly politicized and emotional fight over efforts to ban the practice in Utah, with the state's dominant religion weighing in alongside those who have been harmed by abusive practices ...
- MIT system helps predict people's driving personalitieson November 26, 2019 at 10:31 am
The researchers employed an existing framework used for personalities known as "social value orientation," which represents the degree to which someone is selfish ("egoistic") as opposed to altruistic ...
- 20 Things to Know Before You Come Out and How to Go About Iton November 25, 2019 at 2:58 pm
If you’ve recently figured out your orientation, you might want to come out ... It doesn’t make you a fake or a liar. Perhaps you have an anonymous social media account and you decide to tell your ...
- MIT Develops System to Determine People’s Driving Personalitieson November 25, 2019 at 11:26 am
The goal is to enable self-driving cars to better handle situations like merging and taking left-hand turns. https://t.co/i6tIgWF3FX The team used social value orientation (SVO) to create an algorithm ...
- Researchers teach autonomous car how to safely avoid 'selfish' motorists by using social psychologyon November 18, 2019 at 3:48 pm
In this paper, we sought to understand if this was something we could actually quantify.' Specifically, the system - which was trained by observing human driving behavior - uses social value ...
- The new impact modeling approach that will change the way you think about social impacton October 30, 2019 at 10:02 am
Social Impact lacks economic orientation. It is commonly known to refer to entities that benefit the world — i.e., people and planet — in a way that is not purely financial. The thing is, we live in a ...
- Ford Foundation's Darren Walker on saving capitalism from itselfon October 17, 2019 at 4:02 am
Worse, extreme levels of economic inequity are only one of the many forms of inequality that plague our nation: We also face rampant discrimination based on race, gender, sexual orientation ...
- How Companies, Governments, and Nonprofits Can Create Social Change Togetheron May 31, 2018 at 9:44 am
Taken together, Social Value Investing is a blueprint for aligning the interests and goals of partnering organizations, and demonstrating how business efficiency and customer orientation can benefit ...
- GOP tax bill: Social Darwinism makes a big comebackon December 5, 2017 at 2:11 am
It has no redeeming social value. It takes money and resources from those who ... free trade, and an export orientation. Neoliberalism is consistent with Malthusian thinking in that both prefer little ...
- Researchers use facial recognition tools to predict sexual orientation. LGBT groups aren’t happy.on September 12, 2017 at 2:05 am
With that in mind, two researchers from Stanford University decided to study how well artificial intelligence could identify people’s sexual orientation based on ... that their study had an important ...
via Bing News
The Latest on: Road-sharing between human-driven and robot-driven cars
- MIT Develops System to Determine People’s Driving Personalitieson November 25, 2019 at 11:26 am
MIT professor Daniela Rus articulated the experiment’s contribution to the industry. “By modeling driving personalities and incorporating the models mathematically using the SVO in the decision-making ...
- Predicting people’s driving personalitieson November 20, 2019 at 5:59 pm
“By modeling driving personalities and incorporating the models mathematically using the SVO in the decision-making module of a robot car, this work opens the door to safer and more seamless ...
- Getting some SVO for your (auto) SUVon November 18, 2019 at 12:22 pm
“By modelling driving personalities and incorporating the models mathematically using the SVO in the decision-making module of a robot car, this work opens the door to safer and more seamless ...
- Road upgrades to help humans drive alongside automated carson March 7, 2019 at 12:10 pm
At first, and for some years to come, self-driving cars, vans and lorries will have to share the roads with their human-driven counterparts ... And it's not only road sharing that could cause problems ...
- Autonomous cars still face challenges, despite billions of dollars investedon December 30, 2018 at 2:01 pm
In a similar vein, the U.S. House of Representatives passed the Self Drive Act that provides some exemption from safety standards for each car maker’s first 100,000 driverless cars. The future of ...
- Uber signs deal to buy 24,000 autonomous vehicles from Volvo in the USon November 20, 2017 at 8:53 pm
Uber has swung one of the largest deals for autonomous vehicles, ordering 24,000 cars from Volvo - a ... "There will always be a role for human-driven vehicles. You're going to see a hybrid fleet of ...
- Uber signs deal to buy up to 24,000 autonomous vehicles from Volvoon November 19, 2017 at 4:00 pm
Uber swung one of the largest deals for autonomous vehicles Monday, ordering 24,000 vehicles from Volvo — a move that is expected to advance the case for self-driving cars ... human-driven vehicles.
- Autonomous Cars vs Human Driverson August 11, 2017 at 5:00 pm
We already know the what: Coming in the near future are driverless, fully autonomous automobiles. We know the where and the when, too: not on Mars or Krypton but right here on Mother Earth, possibly ...
- Uber has grounded its self-driving cars in Arizona after one was involved in an accidenton March 25, 2017 at 1:19 pm
On Friday night, a self-driving Uber vehicle was involved in a collision with a human-driven car in Tempe, Arizona that caused the ... back as consumers grow increasingly wary of trusting robot-driven ...
- As driverless cars win human rights, we risk losing our innate human fighton February 11, 2016 at 9:53 am
I’ll even jump inside your robot-driven ... human-driven, high-performance vehicles. There won’t be a 2036 version of the Ford GT350R. There won’t be a 2046 version of the BMW M2. And there definitely ...
via Bing News