Dartmouth engineering researchers have developed a new approach for detecting a speaker’s intent to mislead.
The method’s framework, which could be applied toward evaluating “fake news,” among other uses, was recently published as part of a paper in Journal of Experimental & Theoretical Artificial Intelligence.
Although previous studies have examined deception, this is one of the first to look at a speaker’s intent. The researchers posit that while a true story can be manipulated into various deceiving forms, the intent, rather than the content of the communication, determines whether the communication is deceptive or not. For example, the speaker could be misinformed or make a wrong assumption, meaning the speaker made an unintentional error but did not attempt to deceive.
“Deceptive intent to mislead listeners on purpose poses a much larger threat than unintentional mistakes,” said Eugene Santos Jr., co-author and professor of engineering at Dartmouth. “To the best of our knowledge, our algorithm is the only method that detects deception and at the same time discriminates malicious acts from benign acts.”
The researchers developed a unique approach and resulting algorithm that can tell deception apart from all benign communications by retrieving the universal features of deceptive reasoning. However, the framework is currently limited by the amount of data needed to measure a speaker’s deviation from their past arguments; the study used data from a 2009 survey of 100 participants on their opinions on controversial topics, as well as a 2011 dataset of 800 real and 400 fictitious reviews of the same 20 hotels.
Santos believes the framework could be further developed to help readers distinguish and closely examine the intent of “fake news,” allowing the reader to determine if a reasonable, logical argument is used or if opinion plays a strong role. In further studies, Santos hopes to examine the ripple effect of misinformation, including its impacts.
In the study, the researchers use the popular 2001 film Ocean’s Eleven to illustrate how the framework can be used to examine a deceiver’s arguments, which in reality may go against his true beliefs, resulting in a falsified final expectation. For example, in the movie, a group of thieves break into a bank vault while simultaneously revealing to the owner that he is being robbed in order to negotiate. The thieves supply the owner with false information, namely that they will only take half the money if the owner doesn’t call police. However, the thieves expect the owner to call police, which he does, so the thieves then disguise themselves as police to steal the entirety of the vault contents.
Because Ocean’s Eleven is a scripted film, viewers can be sure of the thieves’ intent—to steal all of the money—and how it conflicts with what they tell the owner—that they will only take half. This illustrates how the thieves were able to deceive the owner and anticipate his actions due to the fact that the thieves and owner had different information and therefore perceived the scene differently.
“People expect things to work in a certain way,” said Santos, “just like the thieves knew that the owner would call police when he found out he was being robbed. So, in this scenario, the thieves used that knowledge to convince the owner to come to a certain conclusion and follow the standard path of expectations. They forced their deception intent so the owner would reach the conclusions the thieves desired.”
In popular culture, verbal and non-verbal behaviors such as facial expressions are often used to determine if someone is lying, but the co-authors note that those cues are not always reliable.
“We have found that models based on reasoning intent are more reliable than verbal changes and personal differences, and thus are better at distinguishing intentional lies from other types of information distortion,” said co-author Deqing Li Th’13, who worked on the paper as part of her engineering PhD thesis at Dartmouth.
The Latest on: Deceptive intent
via Google News
The Latest on: Deceptive intent
- Coronavirus: misinformation and false claims in Donald Trump’s responses to pandemicon March 21, 2020 at 4:10 pm
The debate over intent has done little to assuage the fears of those who say they face the potentially ... we had no idea this could come,’ well that’s just false,” she said. Trump this week awarded ...
- Man makes false claim of infection in Punjab, heldon March 21, 2020 at 9:48 am
A 32-year-old man was arrested on Saturday for claiming to have Covid-19 infection in a Tik Tok video and causing fear among people. The accused has been identified as Prabhjot Singh of Manki village ...
- Utah governor tries to swat down coronavirus rumors about arrests, curfewson March 20, 2020 at 1:50 pm
Gary Herbert assured Friday. Rumors about coming curfews or a complete state shutdown are also false. “There is no intent at the present time for any kind of curfew or quarantine or to lock up people.
- Not Even the Head of a National Asian American GOP Group Is Okay With Trump Saying “Chinese Virus”on March 20, 2020 at 12:42 pm
That was obviously false. Many Asian Americans are among the chorus of critics who have noted that ... Li was careful to note that he does not think Trump is racist and believes Trump’s intent is to ...
- STRATCOM warns against false Covid-19 informationon March 20, 2020 at 10:28 am
The Electronics Crimes (Amendment) Act of 2018 makes it an offence to “publish any false document on any website with the intent that it be acted upon as if it were the real document”. A person who ...
- False claim: Coronavirus vaccine approved in Israel, set for mass production and distributionon March 18, 2020 at 3:18 pm
has been approved in Israel ( here) The image, posted on Facebook on March 14, 2020, makes the further claim that the vaccine is already being mass produced and should soon be available in the U.S.
- Immigration Consequences for Convictions for Making False Statementson March 18, 2020 at 9:03 am
Relying on Kawashima, the First Circuit held that the petitioner’s conviction for filing a false health care claim constituted a crime of fraud or deceit ... U.S.C. §2024(b)) does not involve fraud or ...
- 'It was a foolish thing to do' – Student gave police false name after being caught with drugs (plus 8 other court cases)on March 13, 2020 at 10:00 pm
Student Dante Omfroy gave a false name to police when they caught him with cannabis ... The 21-year-old, of Craigside, Biddulph, has also admitted possession of cannabis with intent to supply on April ...
- Criminal Law: Jury Instructions-Intent and Scheme Evidenceon March 13, 2020 at 2:07 pm
Where a defendant appealed her convictions for making a false statement to receive a health care payment and for financial exploitation of the elderly, the trial court used a definitional instruction ...
- Wrong license plate, false name leads Ansonia man’s drug buston March 11, 2020 at 1:42 am
Police then learned the Alexander Feliciano, 28, was also found to have three active warrants for probation violations.
via Bing News