Researchers analysing recent BBC and Netflix nature documentaries found that although they increasingly mention threats to nature, visual depictions of these threats remain scarce, potentially misleading audiences on the state of the natural world.
The findings are discussed in a Perspective published in the British Ecological Society journal People and Nature
Researchers from Bangor University, University of Kent, Newcastle University and University of Oxford coded the scripts from the four most recent David Attenborough narrated series. They found the Netflix series Our Planet dedicated 15% of the script to environmental threats and conservation, far exceeding the BBC series Planet Earth II and Dynasties, with only Blue Planet II coming close to this figure.
The researchers also highlighted the uniqueness of Our Planet in weaving the topic of human impacts on nature throughout each episode rather than being the subject of a dedicated final episode, which was done in Blue Planet II.
Despite the more frequent mentions of threats to nature, the researchers noted how visually similar Our Planet was to the other series they analysed. It had few visual depictions of the threats and largely showed the natural world as pristine and separate from humans, something nature documentaries have often been criticised for in the past.
Professor Julia Jones, lead author, said: “One could argue that by using camera angles to avoid showing any sign of people, nature film makers are being disingenuous, and even actively misleading audiences. The viewer may be led to believe that things cannot be that bad for biodiversity as what they are seeing on the screen shows nature, for the most part, doing fine.
“The inextricable link between threats to the natural world and the high consumption of western lifestyles would be more difficult to ignore if the presence, or even dominance, of commercial agriculture, mining and transport infrastructure were more visible in the landscapes, reducing the space for the awe-inspiring wild spectacles shown.”
Nature documentaries have the potential to elicit behavioural change and increase support for conservation but to what extent is not well understood. “Previous studies have shown that documentaries can increase willingness amongst viewers to make personal lifestyle changes, increase support for conservation organisations, and generate positivity towards an issue, making policy change more likely. However, we still don’t understand the mechanisms by which these changes take place. Considerable research is needed to investigate how viewing nature, portrayed as threatened or pristine, in a documentary affects people in ways which might, ultimately, contribute to saving it.” Said Laura Thomas-Walters, co-author.
The researchers suggest collaboration between filmmakers and researchers could help us understand the impacts of these documentaries. Dr Diogo Vesrissimo, co-author, said: “there is limited evidence on the causal relationships between viewing a documentary and subsequent behaviour change. Nature documentary producers should work with researchers to better understand these positive and negative impacts”.
“Empirical data needs to be collected to examine whether showing anthropogenic impacts is actually more effective at spurring behaviour change amongst audiences.” Added Laura Thomas-Walters.
Read the full paper :
Jones JPG, Thomas?Walters L, Rust NA, Veríssimo D. Nature documentaries and saving nature: Reflections on the new Netflix series Our Planet. People Nat. 2019;00:1–6. https://doi.org/10.1002/pan3.10052
The Latest on: Nature documentaries
via Google News
The Latest on: Nature documentaries
- Justice League Was a Mess, but Its Failure Helped Usher Better DC Filmson November 29, 2019 at 8:03 am
It existed in clear contrast to more traditional portrayals of the Man of Tomorrow – much more introspective and existential in nature. For a generation raised on the Richard Donner films, this ...
- Expert wildlife tracker featured in documentary seeks aidon November 29, 2019 at 2:49 am
An expert wildlife tracker, noted for being a significant part of the award-winning Krupakar-Senani wildlife documentary on the elusive dhole, is struggling to make a living and has appealed to the ...
- Better Angels Documentary Sparks Interest in SB Red/Blue Workshopon November 28, 2019 at 11:00 pm
The organization’s name comes from Lincoln’s Inaugural call to a divided nation to be touched by the “better angels of our nature.” What the citizens organization advocates is a better way of talking ...
- Sealant Web Films Market is estimated to expand at a CAGR of 4.1% during 2018-2028on November 28, 2019 at 3:33 am
Sealant web films are used for both, to laminate a packaged product and to make bags & pouches ... We deliver syndicated research reports, custom research reports and consulting services which are ...
- What Makes a Murderer – the documentary series trying to figure out why some people killon November 27, 2019 at 4:40 pm
Often the debate centres around the question of nature vs nurture. What Makes a Murderer posits that it’s both ... that can create a mix for somebody to have an increased propensity for offending.” ...
- Wildlife films to animate the 'biodiversity super year'on November 26, 2019 at 9:04 am
Winners and finalist films entered into the competition will be shown throughout 2020, known as “biodiversity super year” around the world and at various major events. CITES Secretary-General Ivonne ...
- Poignant ’63 Up’ documentary follows subjects from childhood into old ageon November 25, 2019 at 4:30 pm
The latest installment of the “Up” documentary series, which has followed the lives of a group of English ... “On the whole, we come to an understanding.” He said the nature versus nurture question is ...
- PBS Picks Up Euro Shows; Disney+ Hires International Exec; Aquarius Films Develop Oz Feature – Global Briefson November 25, 2019 at 3:24 pm
The show, which has been sold into over 140 territories around the world, was originally commissioned by the BBC and UKTV and is produced by True to Nature. Vienna Blood is a six-part crime series ...
- Who Is Liz Bonnin? The TV Presenter's Love For Nature Shaped Her Career Pathon November 25, 2019 at 7:32 am
With countless wildlife and natural history documentaries under her belt, presenter Liz Bonnin is a familiar face to many BBC viewers. Her most recent venture was for Blue Planet Live last year, and ...
- Emmy Award-Winning Netflix Documentary OUR PLANET Will Become Live Concerton November 25, 2019 at 4:33 am
Alastair Fothergill of Silverback Films is a pioneer in creating concerts around landmark wildlife series with his previous projects Blue Planet, Planet Earth and Frozen Planet. He says, "Our Planet ...
via Bing News