Though algorithms are increasingly being deployed in all facets of life, a new USC study has found that they fail basic tests as truth detectors.
Most algorithms have probably never heard the Eagles’ song, “Lyin’ Eyes.” Otherwise, they’d do a better job of recognizing duplicity.
Computers aren’t very good at discerning misrepresentation, and that’s a problem as the technologies are increasingly deployed in society to render decisions that shape public policy, business and people’s lives.
Turns out that algorithms fail basic tests as truth detectors, according to researchers who study theoretical factors of expression and the complexities of reading emotions at the USC Institute for Creative Technologies. The research team completed a pair of studies using science that undermines popular psychology and AI expression understanding techniques, both of which assume facial expressions reveal what people are thinking.
“Both people and so-called ‘emotion reading’ algorithms rely on a folk wisdom that our emotions are written on our face,” said Jonathan Gratch, director for virtual human research at ICT and a professor of computer science at the USC Viterbi School of Engineering. “This is far from the truth. People smile when they are angry or upset, they mask their true feelings, and many expressions have nothing to do with inner feelings, but reflect conversational or cultural conventions.”
Gratch and colleagues presented the findings today at the 8th International Conference on Affective Computing and Intelligent Interaction in Cambridge, England.
New study analyzes facial expressions in social situations
Of course, people know that people can lie with a straight face. Poker players bluff. Job applicants fake interviews. Unfaithful spouses cheat. And politicians can cheerfully utter false statements.
Yet, algorithms aren’t so good at catching duplicity, even as machines are increasingly deployed to read human emotions and inform life-changing decisions. For example, the Department of Homeland Security invests in such algorithms to predict potential threats. Some nations use mass surveillance to monitor communications data. Algorithms are used in focus groups, marketing campaigns, to screen loan applicants or hire people for jobs.
“We’re trying to undermine the folk psychology view that people have that if we could recognize people’s facial expressions, we could tell what they’re thinking,” said Gratch, who is also a professor of psychology. “Think about how people used polygraphs back in the day to see if people were lying. There were misuses of the technology then, just like misuses of facial expression technology today. We’re using naïve assumptions about these techniques because there’s no association between expressions and what people are really feeling based on these tests.”
We’re trying to undermine the folk psychology view that people have that if we could recognize people’s facial expressions, we could tell what they’re thinking.
To prove it, Gratch and fellow researchers Su Lei and Rens Hoegen at ICT, along with Brian Parkinson and Danielle Shore at the University of Oxford, examined spontaneous facial expressions in social situations. In one study, they developed a game that 700 people played for money and then captured how people’s expressions impacted their decisions and how much they earned. Next, they allowed subjects to review their behavior and provide insights into how they were using expressions to gain advantage and if their expressions matched their feelings.
Using several novel approaches, the team examined the relationships between spontaneous facial expressions and key events during the game. They adopted a technique from psychophysiology called “event-related potentials” to address the extreme variability in facial expressions and used computer vision techniques to analyze those expressions. To represent facial movements, they used a recently proposed method called facial factors, which captures many nuances of facial expressions without the difficulties modern analysis techniques provide.
The scientists found that smiles were the only expressions consistently provoked, regardless of the reward or fairness of outcomes. Additionally, participants were fairly inaccurate in perceiving facial emotion and particularly poor at recognizing when expressions were regulated. The findings show people smile for lots of reasons, not just happiness, a context important in the evaluation of facial expressions.
“These discoveries emphasize the limits of technology use to predict feelings and intentions,” Gratch said. “When companies and governments claim these capabilities, the buyer should beware because often these techniques have simplistic assumptions built into them that have not been tested scientifically.”
When attempting to read emotions, context is king
Prior research shows that people will make conclusions about other’s intentions and likely actions simply based off of the other’s expressions. While past studies exist using automatic expression analysis to make inferences, such as boredom, depression and rapport, less is known about the extent to which perceptions of expression are accurate. These recent findings highlight the importance of contextual information when reading other’s emotions and support the view that facial expressions communicate more than we might believe.
The Latest on: Truth detectors
via Google News
The Latest on: Truth detectors
- Conspiracy theorists, hoaxers and Trump have twisted Facebook, YouTube and the news to toxic levels — and it’s only getting worseon October 14, 2019 at 4:11 am
Truth is hazy. Reality itself becomes irrelevant ... Last month, Facebook, Microsoft and a slew of research institutions announced they were joining forces for the “Deepfake Detection Challenge,” a ...
- Magalong willing to be jailed ‘for telling the truth’on October 12, 2019 at 9:21 am
Magalong, however, said he was just telling the truth. “Hypothetical na kami ang makulong ... a former chief of the PNP Criminal Investigation and Detection Group (CIDG) who investigated the ninja ...
- Finding a Single Source of Truth for BIM Dataon October 10, 2019 at 6:13 am
Other actions that can be performed via Connect apps include modifying the color and visibility of models, running clash detection, creating and managing releases ... The answer was the creation of a ...
- Bride and Prejudice's Laurelle subjects Codie Lea to a LIE DETECTOR teston October 7, 2019 at 11:41 pm
Bride and Prejudice's Codie Lea was subjected to a lie detector test from her 'mother-in-law from hell ... Codie Lea said she hadn't - and the results proved she was telling the truth. 'Codie has ...
- ‘The truth shall set you free’: Aaron Carter grapples with his difficult paston October 7, 2019 at 6:46 pm
He said he would buy items from office supply companies, paying with cash to avoid detection. “I was huffing because I’m a drug addict,” he said. “I’m a drug addict in recovery. That’s my truth. “The ...
- The false promise of the lie detectoron October 5, 2019 at 4:03 am
Liars can spin yarns packed with color and detail, and truth-tellers can seem vague and evasive. Humans have been trying to overcome this problem for millennia. The search for a perfect lie detector ...
- An inconvenient truth: Your employees are a primary threat to data securityon October 4, 2019 at 3:30 am
As businesses struggle to fend off malware, ransomware, cryptojacking, and other external threats, they often ignore a simple—yet inconvenient—truth: the threat from the inside poses a significant ...
- MAFS' Jessika Power's crush on Cyrell Paule's boyfriend Eden Dally in a lie detector teston October 3, 2019 at 4:42 pm
After being asked if she 'could see herself with Eden', Jessika replied: 'I mean, if Eden's not with that Cyclone Cyrell either... no!' But the lie detector indicated she wasn't telling the truth, ...
- Magalong says cops sending him messages, thanking him for ‘standing for the truth’on October 3, 2019 at 7:38 am
MANILA, Philippines – After hurling accusations against no less than the top police official of the land, former Criminal Investigation and Detection ... for the truth.” Shortly after the ...
- PDEA chief got kids’ blessings: Go ahead daddy, tell the truthon October 3, 2019 at 7:10 am
“I want to finally say the truth. And sabi nila [they said ... former Criminal Investigation and Detection Group chief, who disclosed that Albayalde asked Aquino not to implement the ...
via Bing News