Software that purports to read emotions in faces is being deployed or tested for a variety of purposes, including surveillance, hiring, clinical diagnosis, and market research. But a new scientific report finds that facial movements are an inexact gauge of a person’s feelings, behaviors, and intentions.
“It is not possible to confidently infer happiness from a smile, anger from a scowl or sadness from a frown, as much of current technology tries to do when applying what are mistakenly believed to be the scientific facts,” a group of leading experts in psychological science, neuroscience and computer science write in their comprehensive research review.
The report appears in Psychological Science in the Public Interest, and is authored by APS President Lisa Feldman Barrett of Northeastern University, Ralph Adolphs of the California Institute of Technology, Stacy Marsella of Northeastern University and the University of Glasgow, Aleix M. Martinez of The Ohio State University and Seth D. Pollak of the University of Wisconsin-Madison.
The authors note that the general public and some scientists believe that there are unique facial expressions that reliably indicate six emotion categories: anger, sadness, happiness, disgust, fear, and surprise. But in reviewing more than 1,000 published findings about facial movements and emotions, they found that typical study designs don’t capture the real-life differences in the way people convey and interpret emotions on faces. A scowl or a smile can express more than one emotion depending on the situation, the individual, or the culture, they say.
“People scowl when angry, on average, approximately 25% of the time, but they move their faces in other meaningful ways when angry,” Barrett explains. “They might cry, or smile, or widen their eyes and gasp. And they also scowl when not angry, such as when they are concentrating or when they have a stomach ache. Similarly, most smiles don’t imply that a person is happy, and most of the time people who are happy do something other than smile.”
In a separate article in the journal, Alan Cowen and Dacher Keltner of the University of California, Berkeley; Disa Sauter of the University of Amsterdam; and Jessica L. Tracy of the University of British Columbia note that most scientists agree that facial expressions are meaningful, even if they don’t follow a one-to-one match with six basic emotion categories. They propose a new model for studying emotion-related responses in all their complexity and variations. This approach would measure not only facial cues, but also body movements, voice fluctuations, head movements and other indicators to capture such nuanced responses as smiles of embarrassment or sympathetic vocalizations, they say.
“We thought this was an especially important issue to address because of the way so-called ‘facial expressions’ are being used in industry, educational and medical settings, and in national security,” say Barrett and her co-authors.
The Latest on: Facial expressions
via Google News
The Latest on: Facial expressions
- Amazon's Facial Recognition Tech Adds "Fear" To Emotion Liston August 16, 2019 at 7:03 am
compare a given configuration to what it knows of how a certain emotion may affect facial expression, and work backwards from there via validation to see if the emotion it guessed jives with a subject ...
- Telpo targets biometric access control market with facial recognition terminalon August 15, 2019 at 10:01 am
The processing capabilities of the TPS980 limit the effect facial expression, lighting, and input equipment on the matching process, and the system also stores access records for convenient query and ...
- Amazon's facial recognition tech can spot when you're crapping your pantson August 15, 2019 at 8:58 am
But it looks like it used the same process of creating meta data from facial expressions and training the smart tech to figure out what expression then indicate feelings of fear; think actual fear ...
- 20 Times Kate Middleton's Facial Expressions Made Us LOLon August 15, 2019 at 8:00 am
As we all know, all of the members of the royal family are expected to act in a certain way. There always seems to be an air of elegance and class when people are in the presence of a royal, but ...
- Amazon's 'dystopian' facial recognition technology can now detect fearon August 15, 2019 at 6:28 am
Meanwhile, a recent study reviewing over 1,000 academic papers on emotion recognition found that emotion recognition techniques based on facial expressions are deeply flawed.
- Amazon says its facial recognition can now identify fearon August 14, 2019 at 6:55 am
It can be used for facial analysis or sentiment analysis, which identifies different expressions and predicts emotions from images of people’s faces. The service uses artificial intelligence to “learn ...
- We'll Never Tire of Princess Charlotte's Many Adorable Facial Expressionson August 13, 2019 at 11:00 am
Just like her big brother Prince George, Princess Charlotte's personality shines through every time she makes a new appearance. The young princess and professional bridesmaid has definitely mastered ...
- This Lady's Facial Expression Parade After Tasting Kombucha Is the Self-Discovery Meme We Needon August 13, 2019 at 10:04 am
Kombucha isn’t for everyone, but this kombucha meme definitely is. Recently, TikTok user @BrittanyT445, who also tweets @Brittany_broski, posted a video to the site evidently showing her ...
- The effects of Botulinum toxin on the detection of gradual changes in facial emotionon August 13, 2019 at 2:23 am
Hence, we predicted that such participants would require more time to detect changes in a slowly and gradually evolving facial expression of anger after treatment (RT post-test > RT pre-test). Twelve ...
- People recovering from alcohol use disorder struggle to recognize angry facial expressionson August 12, 2019 at 11:22 pm
People in early-stage recovery from alcohol use disorder can struggle to recognize facial expressions of emotion ─particularly anger ─according to a study published in the journal Alcoholism: Clinical ...
via Bing News