A recent study revealed students at an international school in Finland significantly outperformed U.S. students on tasks which measure digital literacy in social media and online news.
The researchers suggest this may be due to the Finnish and International Baccalaureate curricula’s different way of facilitating students’ critical thinking skills compared to the U.S. system and curriculum. The results of this study were published in the Journal of Research in International Education in April.
Critical thinking is a 21st century skill considered essential for today’s students to navigate the Information Age and for their future work life.
But how well does the education system encourage the development of these skills?
In a recent study tasks measuring digital media literacy were administered at an international school in Finland to consider the efficacy and transfer of critical thinking skills. The task instruments utilised in the study were earlier developed by the Stanford History Education Group to determine the extent to which young people ask ‘Who is behind the information?’ and ‘What is the evidence?’ in scenarios taken from real world online situations.
The executive summary published by the Stanford researchers in winter of 2016 received widespread coverage from major news outlets around the world due to its corresponding with the advent of the ‘fake news’ phenomenon, as well as for the Stanford researchers describing U.S. student performance as ‘dismaying’ and ‘bleak’.
– Many of the international outlets generalised the results of the U.S. students to their own socio-educational environments, which our more recent study cautions against, comment Shane Horn and Koen Veermans, who conducted the Finnish study at the University of Turku.
In this recent study two cohorts were measured: a pre-IB cohort preparing to enter the International Baccalaureate Diploma Programme, and a separate cohort preparing to graduate from the programme.
While the graduating IB2 cohort only slightly outperformed the entry level pre-IB cohort, both outperformed the compared Stanford’s U.S. cohorts to a statistically significant degree.
– This study was largely to see if progress in the IB programme correlated with better performance on the tasks, as would be expected, and which to some extent indeed occurred. What became more interesting was how drastic the differentials were between both the cohorts tested in Finland when compared to student performance by the U.S. cohorts, says Shane Horn.
– The results on several tasks were like negative mirror images of one another, with the students in Finland performing at the mastery level to the extent the students in the U.S. performed at beginning levels, Horn explains.
When considering possible reasons for the outcome differentials, the ways in which both the Finnish education system and the IB programme explicitly facilitate critical thinking skills in their respective curricula became forefront.
– The curriculum in the U.S. embeds critical thinking only implicitly into subject coursework whereas the Finnish and IB curricula facilitate critical thinking skills both explicitly in courses and embeds critical thinking also into coursework in the more traditional subjects, explains University Research Fellow Koen Veermans, another researcher of the study conducted in Finland.
For example the IB programme has a separate, distinct course called Theory of Knowledge specifically designed for critical thinking skills development, which is explicitly embedded into the course subject areas. Finland also has distinct coursework in critical thinking through their courses that address ethics, with teachers retaining autonomy regarding the extent to which they make critical thinking skills explicit in the subject areas.
Based on this and other studies the researchers recommend for educational curricula to design the facilitation of critical thinking skills explicitly in courses and across other subjects in the curricula.
The Latest on: Digital literacy
via Google News
The Latest on: Digital literacy
- Short-staffing leads to fall in Dundee literacy sessions for vulnerable peopleon November 19, 2019 at 12:03 am
Meanwhile the city has seen a 40% jump in uptake of digital literacy sessions. Labour councillor Richard McCready said: “Libraries do a great job in very trying circumstances. “Dundee City Council has ...
- Silicon Harlem aims to improve digital literacy and broadband access in NYCon November 18, 2019 at 1:19 pm
Through their digital literacy programs, broadband design and deployment, and cutting-edge research projects along with scholarly conferences, educational workshops and community outreach initiatives, ...
- New West Coast library to offer digital literacy programmes | Videoon November 17, 2019 at 6:54 am
A new library in West Coast will offer digital literacy programmes and workshops as part of efforts to prepare people for a future economy where digital technologies are integral. Brandon Tanoto has ...
- Today’s kids might be digital natives — but a new study shows they aren’t close to being computer literateon November 16, 2019 at 6:00 am
Results were recently released from the International Computer and Information Literacy 2018 study, and they were sobering: Only 2 percent of students scored at the highest levels implied by digital ...
- AfricaCom: Cheap data key for enhancing productivity, digital skills in Africaon November 14, 2019 at 4:37 am
Aubrey Hruby, the co-founder of Africa Expert Network, and her panel of guests discussed the importance of digital literacy, and how vital it was for people across Africa, and more especially South ...
- Digital literacy helps improve access to healthcareon November 13, 2019 at 2:32 am
An asset-based approach to understanding digital health literacy views digital tools as a means of empowerment for the patient and the public, she said. Professor Kristine Sørensen from Global Health ...
- Lehrer-Small ’20: Promoting digital literacy through a first-year computing requirementon November 12, 2019 at 9:22 pm
Such a change would ensure that all students attain sufficient digital literacy and would promote an informed university-wide discourse on ethical technology. You might say: “What? Requirements? At ...
- Facebook to launch digital literacy programmes in Pakistan next yearon November 7, 2019 at 10:32 pm
ISLAMABAD: While Pakistan tops the list of countries for making requests to block contents, Facebook has decided to launch digital literacy programme next year 2020 in order to create awareness among ...
- Aim to make digital literacy accessible to every Indian: Adobe CEOon November 7, 2019 at 3:34 am
Shantanu Narayen, the Indian-origin president and CEO of Adobe, said the biggest opportunity for the software major in India lies in unlocking the true potential of a billion-plus people and make ...
- Ooredoo Myanmar, govt launch digital literacy training project with Googleon November 7, 2019 at 12:23 am
Ooredoo Myanmar, in partnership with Google and supported by the Ministry of Education, have launched a digital literacy and digital citizenship training programme nationwide. This private-public ...
via Bing News