A recent study revealed students at an international school in Finland significantly outperformed U.S. students on tasks which measure digital literacy in social media and online news.
The researchers suggest this may be due to the Finnish and International Baccalaureate curricula’s different way of facilitating students’ critical thinking skills compared to the U.S. system and curriculum. The results of this study were published in the Journal of Research in International Education in April.
Critical thinking is a 21st century skill considered essential for today’s students to navigate the Information Age and for their future work life.
But how well does the education system encourage the development of these skills?
In a recent study tasks measuring digital media literacy were administered at an international school in Finland to consider the efficacy and transfer of critical thinking skills. The task instruments utilised in the study were earlier developed by the Stanford History Education Group to determine the extent to which young people ask ‘Who is behind the information?’ and ‘What is the evidence?’ in scenarios taken from real world online situations.
The executive summary published by the Stanford researchers in winter of 2016 received widespread coverage from major news outlets around the world due to its corresponding with the advent of the ‘fake news’ phenomenon, as well as for the Stanford researchers describing U.S. student performance as ‘dismaying’ and ‘bleak’.
– Many of the international outlets generalised the results of the U.S. students to their own socio-educational environments, which our more recent study cautions against, comment Shane Horn and Koen Veermans, who conducted the Finnish study at the University of Turku.
In this recent study two cohorts were measured: a pre-IB cohort preparing to enter the International Baccalaureate Diploma Programme, and a separate cohort preparing to graduate from the programme.
While the graduating IB2 cohort only slightly outperformed the entry level pre-IB cohort, both outperformed the compared Stanford’s U.S. cohorts to a statistically significant degree.
– This study was largely to see if progress in the IB programme correlated with better performance on the tasks, as would be expected, and which to some extent indeed occurred. What became more interesting was how drastic the differentials were between both the cohorts tested in Finland when compared to student performance by the U.S. cohorts, says Shane Horn.
– The results on several tasks were like negative mirror images of one another, with the students in Finland performing at the mastery level to the extent the students in the U.S. performed at beginning levels, Horn explains.
When considering possible reasons for the outcome differentials, the ways in which both the Finnish education system and the IB programme explicitly facilitate critical thinking skills in their respective curricula became forefront.
– The curriculum in the U.S. embeds critical thinking only implicitly into subject coursework whereas the Finnish and IB curricula facilitate critical thinking skills both explicitly in courses and embeds critical thinking also into coursework in the more traditional subjects, explains University Research Fellow Koen Veermans, another researcher of the study conducted in Finland.
For example the IB programme has a separate, distinct course called Theory of Knowledge specifically designed for critical thinking skills development, which is explicitly embedded into the course subject areas. Finland also has distinct coursework in critical thinking through their courses that address ethics, with teachers retaining autonomy regarding the extent to which they make critical thinking skills explicit in the subject areas.
Based on this and other studies the researchers recommend for educational curricula to design the facilitation of critical thinking skills explicitly in courses and across other subjects in the curricula.
The Latest on: Digital literacy
via Google News
The Latest on: Digital literacy
- 10 steps to achieving insurance data literacyon December 1, 2020 at 2:10 am
The terms 'digital' and 'data' are often conflated or are used interchangeably, but they represent very different facets in the journey companies are taking.
- Digital literacy a key component to new ecommerce strategyon November 30, 2020 at 5:21 pm
One of the main focuses of the strategy is how to improve digital literacy in order to close any skill gaps that would hinder Cambodia’s ecommerce ecosystem from flourishing in the future. Cambodia’s ...
- How digital healthcare tools are changing medicine in Europe since COVID-19on November 30, 2020 at 12:05 pm
In Europe, three major categories of care currently being aided by digital tools: distance diagnoses, internal communications, and external collaborations.
- Why digital literacy is essential for 21st-century universitieson November 28, 2020 at 1:43 am
Higher education leaders explain how knowledge of digital technologies is crucial for students and staff to thrive in the modern world ...
- Vice President Naidu calls for mass movement to promote digital literacyon November 27, 2020 at 4:36 am
Vice President M Venkaiah Naidu on Friday called for a mass movement to promote digital literacy and urged all stakeholders, including tech.
- Vice President Venkaiah Naidu Calls For Mass Movement To Promote Digital Literacyon November 27, 2020 at 3:49 am
Vice President Venkaiah Naidu on Friday called for a mass movement to promote digital literacy and urged all stakeholders, including technological and educational institutions, to play a leading role ...
- VP Naidu Calls For Mass Movement To Promote Digital Literacyon November 27, 2020 at 3:12 am
Vice President M Venkaiah Naidu called for a mass movement to promote digital literacy and urged all stakeholders to play a leading role in achieving the desired results.
- Vice President M Venkaiah Naidu calls for mass movement to promote digital literacyon November 27, 2020 at 3:00 am
Virtually launching the Adi Shankara Digital Academy, the vice president said information was the main commodity in the present-day knowledge society, and added that whoever has quick access to ...
- It's time to secure our digital sidewalkson November 25, 2020 at 12:00 pm
When we invest in crossing the digital divide, why not also talk about how cyber threats can impact our most at-risk populations?
- ‘Financial digital literacy can aid poverty alleviation among low-income women’on November 22, 2020 at 7:25 pm
Adequate financial and digital literacy among women can help bridge the gender gap in Nigeria and alleviate poverty among women ...
via Bing News