MANY FORENSIC METHODS HAVE NEVER BEEN SCIENTIFICALLY VALIDATED, SCIENTISTS NOTE IN EDITORIAL
Many of the “forensic science” methods commonly used in criminal cases and portrayed in popular police TV dramas have never been scientifically validated and may lead to unjust verdicts, according to an editorial in this week’s Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.
The authors were the six independent scientists who served on the National Commission for Forensic Science (NCFS), a panel set up in 2013 by the U.S. Department of Justice and the National Institute of Standards and Technology. The NCFS was terminated early last year when the DOJ did not renewed its charter.
The scientists wrote their editorial as an appeal to the scientific community to help maintain the momentum in putting forensic science on a firmer scientific basis. The co-authors include colleagues from West Virginia University, Cornell University, the Salk Institute for Biological Studies, Brown University and the University of Arizona.
“We wanted to alert people that this is a continuing and a major issue: that many of the forensic techniques used today to put people in jail have no scientific backing,” says senior author Arturo Casadevall, MD, Bloomberg Distinguished Professor and the Alfred & Jill Sommer Professor and Chair of Molecular Microbiology and Immunology at Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health.
Casadevall and colleagues argue in their essay that the problems with forensic science are rooted in the discipline’s traditional close association with prosecutors and law enforcement. “Almost all publicly funded [forensic] laboratories, whether federal, state, or local, are associated with law enforcement. At the very least, this creates a potential conflict-of-interest,” they note.
Traditional forensic methods aimed at linking suspects to patterns found at the crime scene—fingerprints, bite-marks, footprints, tire-marks—were developed by law-enforcement laboratories and matured largely outside of mainstream scientific culture. Once these methods became admissible in criminal cases they continued to be used in court by the principle of judicial precedent. Yet while fingerprint analysis recently has been reformed into a more quantified, objective, empirically based method, most other traditional pattern-matching methods continue to be used despite insufficient understanding of their accuracy and reliability.
“The forensic experts might claim, for example, that the fibers isolated from a body ‘match’ the fibers in a rug that was in the back of the suspect’s truck, but generally they won’t be able to say what the error rate in their conclusion is” Casadevall says. “In other words, they haven’t properly characterized the uncertainties involved in concluding that it is a match.”
A major catalyst for a re-think of forensic methods was DNA analysis, which entered widespread use in forensics in the 1990s and had an unprecedentedly high accuracy and reliability. DNA analysis overturned many convictions that had been based on traditional, less precise methods, and forced the recognition that these traditional methods were overdue for scientific scrutiny.
At the behest of Congress, the National Academy of Sciences (NAS) convened a panel to study the problem, and in 2009 the NAS panel issued a report that was sharply critical of contemporary forensic science. The authors concluded that “with the exception of nuclear DNA analysis … no forensic method has been rigorously shown to have the capacity to consistently, and with a high degree of certainty, demonstrate a connection between evidence and a specific individual or source.”
The NAS report also recommended the establishment of a research organization that would be dedicated to reforming forensic science and bringing it into mainstream scientific culture. The report urged that this entity be independent of the Department of Justice (DOJ), which understandably has little institutional interest in questioning older methods, since that could lead to the overturning of old verdicts.
In the end, though, DOJ prevailed. The NCFS was established to increase communication among academic scientists, judges, prosecutors, lawyers, and the forensic science community, but it was placed under the joint administration of the DOJ and the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST). Following the 2016 presidential election, the winds shifted and DOJ declined to renew the commission.
“It’s a shame—we had been making a lot of progress,” Casadevall says. “Commissioners were realizing that in addressing these questions they might be able to improve their methods and the justice system.”
Casadevall sees little chance that the NCFS will be resurrected by the current administration, but he and his colleagues hope that by drawing attention to the problem, they can inspire the scientific and forensic communities to keep pushing for reforms, for example, mandatory empirical testing of all methods that are currently admissible in court.
“We’re hoping to keep the issue alive,” he says, “and we can see that a lot of otherwise educated and well-informed people still don’t understand the extent of the problem.”
The Latest on: Forensic methods
via Google News
The Latest on: Forensic methods
Foregenix launches Digital Forensics and Incident Response services in Australia and APAC
on July 11, 2018 at 5:32 am
Founded in 2009 as a digital forensics specialist and now covering 15 countries ... signature-based detection methods. "Managed Detection and Response (MDR) services hunt for suspicious behaviour and ... […]
Public service center operators trained to detect fake documents by forensic methods
on July 10, 2018 at 10:51 pm
AKIPRESS.COM - The State Registration Service said operators of the Public Service Centers (PSC) receive training to be able to identify passport applicants and to detect fake and forged documents wit... […]
Growing Security Concerns And Lack Of Security Infrastructure Among Enterprises Is Projected To Drive Network Forensics Market
on July 9, 2018 at 4:39 pm
The global network forensics market was valued at US$ 1,324.8 Mn in 2016 ... who us e proprietary data sources and various tools and techniques to gather, and analyze information. Our business offerin... […]
Vienna Detective Gregory Hylinski Graduates from Forensic Science Academy
on July 9, 2018 at 2:20 pm
The nine-week course of study also provides officers with the necessary background information and practical application techniques which, coupled with the student’s previous experience, permits maxim... […]
Senate Passes Bills On Forensic Accounting
on July 7, 2018 at 2:18 am
“Forensic accounting is the unique blend of education and experience in applying accounting, auditing skills and investigative techniques to uncover truth, form legal opinions in order to assist in li... […]
How Simple Forensic Fingerprinting Could Help the World's Most Trafficked Mammal
on July 6, 2018 at 9:24 am
But beyond the investigative and prosecution potential of this technique is the proof of concept that there are forensic techniques that already exist that can applied to wildlife crime. We’ve got to ... […]
Forensic Scrutiny Of Firearms: A Way Forward
on July 5, 2018 at 7:29 pm
Forensic examination of the murder weapon is common during investigations into crime and criminality in developed societies. The success of this method of investigation in advanced societies is due, m... […]
Digital Forensics Industry is Analyzed into Regions Like North America, Europe, Asia- Pacific, Middle East & Africa and South America to 2025
on July 4, 2018 at 5:20 pm
As new technologies evolve, lawbreakers find distinct methods to use these technologies to obligate ... These files may be undeleted or deleted. The Digital forensics market segmentation is done on th... […]
Genetic polymorphisms and forensic efficiency of 19 X-chromosomal STR loci for Xinjiang Mongolian population
on July 3, 2018 at 12:55 am
Genomic DNA was extracted using the Chelex-100 method (Walsh, Metzger & Higuchi ... and analyzed by GeneMapper ID-X (Thermo Fisher Scientific, Waltham, MA, USA). Forensic statistical parameters of the ... […]
via Bing News