Researchers explore an alternative pathway to fast-tracking the global recovery of fisheries
Short-term pain for long-term gain. When applied to the reform of global fisheries, this strategy could yield enormous benefits.
If only it were that easy.
For many countries — especially those in the developing tropics where fishery reform is needed most — the required costly short-run reductions in fish catch would be difficult to implement because of dependency on fisheries for food and livelihoods.
There is another way, according to UC Santa Barbara researchers and colleagues. In a paper published in Nature Ecology and Evolution, they demonstrate that for countries where illegal, unreported and unregulated (IUU) fishing is prevalent, addressing such activity could kick-start fishery recovery without reducing local fishing effort, catch and profit. Indonesia has proved this to be true, and this new work is the first to show that the country’s policies are effective.
“Indonesia’s anti-IUU fishing policies draw a lot of media attention and speculation about their effect, but no one has demonstrated or evaluated the efficacy of the policies,” said lead author Reniel Cabral, a postdoctoral scholar at UCSB’s Bren School of Environmental Science & Management. “Indonesia did a fantastic job of controlling illegal fishing in their waters. But for them to continually capture benefits from their anti-IUU fishing policies, they need to ensure that domestic fishing efforts are also well-managed.”
Historically, Indonesia has experienced high levels of IUU fishing from foreign fleets. In late 2014, seeking to curtail those activities, the country implemented tough and controversial policies that resulted in the sinking of 318 illegal fishing boats (296 foreign-flagged), the banning of all foreign-owned and foreign-made boats from fishing in Indonesia and the restriction of transfers of fish at sea. As a result, foreign fishing in the country dropped by more than 90 percent and total fishing dropped by 25 percent.
“Indonesia’s tough stance on illegal fishing not only jump-started recovery in their waters but also provided a viable example for countries all over the world that are plagued by overfishing driven by illegal behavior,” said co-author and Bren School professor Christopher Costello.
Using skipjack tuna as a model case study, the authors showed that curtailing IUU fishing combined with capping harvest at its maximum sustainable level could by 2035 generate a 14 percent increase in catch and a 15 percent increase in profit compared to current levels. The benefits of this management scenario become even clearer when compared to business as usual, which is projected to reduce catch and profit by 59 percent and 64 percent, respectively, over the same time frame.
The researchers used cutting-edge technologies to achieve an unprecedented view of IUU fishing. They analyzed publicly accessible automatic identification system data processed through Global Fishing Watch, vessel monitoring system data provided by the Indonesian government and nightlight satellite images to provide a complete picture of the impact of Indonesia’s policies. These technologies tracked the behavior of individual fishing vessels globally and in near real-time.
“Satellite technologies are starting to revolutionize fisheries research and management in many ways,” said co-author Juan Mayorga, a marine data scientist with UCSB’s Sustainable Fisheries Group and the National Geographic Society’s Pristine Seas project. “A promising application is the evaluation of fisheries and conservation policies such as fishing moratoria or marine reserves. We can now directly assess — like in the case of Indonesia’s IUU policies — whether policies are achieving their intended effect, as well as observe any resulting changes in fishing behavior.”
The investigators’ efforts also resulted in a database and a visualization of the global network of transnational fisheries, which summarizes the extent of fishing in foreign exclusive economic zones. According to Mayorga, this makes basic but important information — on who fishes where and how much — easily accessible. As examples, he cites data showing that China fishes in more than 70 distinct countries and that Mauritania’s waters are being fished by 25 different nations.
“Increased transparency, along with effective regulation and enforcement, can lead to better outcomes for fish stocks and local livelihoods,” said David Kroodsma, Global Fishing Watch’s director of research and development.
This work also revealed hotspots of foreign fishing activity in western Africa and the central Pacific, regions where more than 30 percent of fish catch is illegally obtained and where addressing illegal fishing could see benefits similar to Indonesia’s. In addition, the analysis demonstrated that in Gambia — a country that experienced high levels of illegal fishing from foreign fleets — a policy that banned all forms of industrial fishing in 2015 is working and has the potential to help local fisheries.
“With the rapid expansion of distant-water fishing, satellite technologies will provide tools for countries to monitor their waters,” Cabral said. “Solving IUU fishing globally will be sufficient to catalyze fishery recovery in many regions of the world or at least narrow the gap to global fishery recovery.”
Learn more: Fighting Illegal Fishing
The Latest on: Illegal fishing
via Google News
The Latest on: Illegal fishing
- Council cracking down on illegal activity at Cattana Wetlandson October 14, 2019 at 12:04 pm
VOLUNTEERS at Cattana Wetlands are asking the public to dob in people carrying out illegal activity in the conservation park, such as fishing and horseriding. Cairns Regional Council recently spent $1 ...
- Susi Pudjiastuti Hopes Drownings of Illegal Fishing Boats Persiston October 14, 2019 at 2:19 am
TEMPO.CO, Jakarta - Nearing her last days in office, Maritime Affairs and Fisheries Minister Susi Pudjiastuti called on the ministry to preserve its program of legally-drowning illegal foreign fishing ...
- 2 Chinese boats seized for alleged illegal fishingon October 12, 2019 at 8:02 am
The Coast Guard seized two Chinese fishing boats in the West Sea for illegal fishing in South Korea's exclusive economic zone, officials said Saturday. The 30-ton fishing boats captains are also ...
- Illegal Chinese fishing vessel fined over $1mon October 10, 2019 at 8:50 pm
A Ghanaian registered fishing vessel operated by Chinese has been fined $1 million for illegal fishing and GHc124,000 for having fish onboard. The vessel had also failed to log the fishing activity in ...
- A Fishy Crisis: Russia Has Arrested North Koreans for Illegal Fishingon October 9, 2019 at 4:07 pm
It was first reported by RIA state news agency earlier this week that Russian border patrol confronted two North Korean schooners and eleven motorboats allegedly conducting illegal fishing activities ...
- Sea of Japan Collision Incident Highlights North Korean Illegal Fishing Activitieson October 8, 2019 at 6:20 am
In September, more than one hundred North Korean sailors had been arrested by Russian authorities for illegal fishing operations in Russian waters. During one incident, a North Korean fishing crew ...
- Japan lodges protest with North Korea over boat collision as Abe vows to prevent illegal fishing in EEZon October 8, 2019 at 2:52 am
“We have protested to North Korea” via the embassy in Beijing, Abe said at a Diet session, adding Japan will take “resolute” action to prevent illegal fishing by foreign ships in its EEZ. The protest ...
- Indonesia sinks 40 foreign boats in illegal fishing crackdownon October 7, 2019 at 6:44 am
Indonesia has sunk 40 foreign boats in the past two days as part of a crackdown on illegal fishing, the country’s fisheries ministry said on Monday. Sinking unauthorised boats by Indonesian ...
- North Koreans Thrown Overboard as Fishing Ship Hits Japanese Patrol Boaton October 7, 2019 at 5:16 am
TOKYO — A large North Korean fishing trawler collided with a Japanese patrol ship within Japan’s exclusive economic zone on Monday, throwing dozens of North Korean crew members overboard and drawing ...
via Bing News