It may surprise many, especially those susceptible to the CSI effect, but fingerprint evidence is not conclusive beyond a reasonable doubt.
A new American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) working group report on the quality of latent fingerprint analysis says that courtroom testimony and reports stating or even implying that fingerprints collected from a crime scene belong to a single person are indefensible and lack scientific foundation.
“Fingerprinting is one of the most heavily used forensic methods. Routinely, fingerprint analysts report and testify to ‘identification,’ that is, that the person who left the mark at the crime scene is the same person whose fingerprint is in the database, said Joseph B. (Jay) Kadane, Carnegie Mellon University’s Leonard J. Savage University Professor of Statistics and Social Sciences, Emeritus. “Our review of the scientific literature found that there is no scientific way to estimate the number of people in some community—a city, a state, the country, the world—who share the characteristics found, and hence no scientific basis for identification.”
Kadane, William Thompson, of the University of California, Irvine, Black & White Forensics, LLC’s John Blackand Michigan State University’s Anil Jain illustrate in “Forensic Science Assessments: A Quality and Gap Analysis of Latent Fingerprint Analysis” that while latent fingerprint examiners can successfully rule out most of the population from being the source of a latent fingerprint based on observed features, insufficient data exist to determine how fingerprint features really are unique. This makes it scientifically baseless to claim that an analysis has enabled examiners to narrow the pool of sources to a single person.
Forensic science is an important tool for investigating crime and helping to determine guilt or innocence at trial, but questions have been raised about the validity and reliability of many forensic disciplines. A crucial National Research Council report issued in 2009 noted that most forensic disciplines have not been subjected to rigorous scientific study. And there is no way to know which aspects of these disciplines were based on a solid scientific footing and which were not.
This new report examines the bases for latent fingerprint examination, and sets forth what is known, what is not known and where there are gaps. The 14 recommendations in the report constitute a roadmap for further research. The report should also help key actors in the criminal justice system–law enforcement, lawyers and judges–make more informed decisions.
The Latest on: Fingerprint evidence
- Kadane & Koehler on Reporting Fingerprint Evidence on April 16, 2019 at 11:13 am
Everyone knows that fingerprint evidence can be extremely incriminating. What is less clear is whether the way that a fingerprint examiner describes that evidence influences the weight lay jurors ... […]
- Prosecutors: new evidence in 1993 cold case murder on April 12, 2019 at 1:48 pm
However, Westrom's attorney Steve Meshbesher said footprint and fingerprint evidence is not reliable. And he reiterated that his client is not the person who stabbed Childs to death in her apartment ... […]
- “There’s no physical evidence matching Kirk Zimmerman” – crime scene investigator at Pam Zimmerman’s office on April 11, 2019 at 4:05 pm
Key evidence that was extracted from the scene were a single fingerprint taken from near the mouse pad on Zimmerman’s personal desk, her purse sitting close by. The purse was missing her white ... […]
- Pink pyjamas, blood stains and fingerprints: The latest in Mohamed Noor’s trial on April 10, 2019 at 6:46 pm
Also shown were photos of fingerprints and hand prints in various spots on the police car. The jury hasn’t heard any evidence as to who those prints belong to. The question of whether Justine slapped ... […]
- Damond family endures graphic evidence on April 10, 2019 at 5:37 pm
Prosecutors said in their opening statements there was no fingerprint evidence that Ms Damond had slapped the car. Joseph Cooksley, a forensic scientist for Minnesota's Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ... […]
- Fingerprints of Venus Transformation May Be Hidden in Plain Sight on April 10, 2019 at 9:00 am
But it didn't become a nightmarish planet overnight. The fingerprints of its gradual shift may be present in some of the oldest surface features, hidden in plain sight. To understand what happened on ... […]
- 3D print fools Samsung Galaxy S10 in-display fingerprint sensor on April 8, 2019 at 1:30 am
Unfortunately though, the fingerprint sensor is not as secure as one may have ... which is also said to be more secure and harder to fool. Based on the evidence below, that is simply not the case. To ... […]
- Why this CSI fingerprint expert gave up working with the dead on April 5, 2019 at 11:31 pm
Pic: Victoria Pertusa, Archant. Now many crimes are solved using DNA evidence but when Diane started it was often by fingerprints matched against a database of those taken every time someone had been ... […]
- Beer bottle fingerprints lead to burglary arrest on April 5, 2019 at 12:00 pm
HAMPTON — A Vermont man was jailed Friday for a 2016 burglary on Granville Street thanks to forensic evidence recovered ... and DNA from fingerprints recovered from Corona beer bottles that ... […]
- How fingerprints on cooker and blood in taxi left murderer who knifed his Stoke-on-Trent wife 50 times bang to rights on April 4, 2019 at 9:00 pm
Investigators have revealed how fingerprints on a cooker and blood in a taxi left a failed asylum-seeker with nowhere to turn after he was arrested on suspicion of murdering a Stoke-on-Trent mother-of ... […]
via Google News and Bing News