Biodiversity losses from deep-sea mining are unavoidable and possibly irrevocable, an international team of 15 marine scientists, resource economists and legal scholars argue in a letter published today in the journal Nature Geoscience.
The experts say the International Seabed Authority (ISA), which is responsible under the UN Law of the Sea for regulating undersea mining in areas outside national jurisdictions, must recognize this risk. They say it must also communicate the risk clearly to its member states and the public to inform discussions about whether deep-seabed mining should proceed, and if so, what standards and safeguards need to be put into place to minimize biodiversity loss.
“There is tremendous uncertainty about ecological responses to deep-sea mining,” said Cindy L. Van Dover, Harvey W. Smith Professor of Biological Oceanography at Duke University’s Nicholas School of the Environment. “Responsible mining needs to rely on environmental management actions that will protect deep-sea biodiversity and not on actions that are unproven or unreasonable.”
“The extraction of non-renewable resources always includes tradeoffs,” said Linwood Pendleton, International Chair in Marine Ecosystem Services at the European Institute of Marine Studies and an adjunct professor at Duke’s Nicholas School. “A serious trade-off for deep-sea mining will be an unavoidable loss of biodiversity, including many species that have yet to be discovered.”
Faced with this inevitable outcome, it’s important that we understand deep-sea ecosystems and have a good idea of what we stand to lose before mining alters the seafloor forever, said Pendleton, who also serves as a senior scholar in the Oceans and Coastal Policy Program at Duke’s Nicholas Institute for Environmental Policy Solutions.
Time is of the essence, the experts stress.
“Undersea deposits of metals and rare earth elements are not yet being mined, but there has been an increase in the number of applications for mining contracts,” said Elva Escobar of the National Autonomous University of Mexico’s Institute of Marine Sciences and Limnology. “In 2001, there were just six deep-sea mineral exploration contracts; by the end of 2017, there will be a total of 27 projects.”
These projects include 18 contracts for polymetallic nodules, six for polymetallic sulfides and four for ferromanganese crusts, Escobar said. Of these, 17 would take place in the Clarion-Clipperton Zone in the Pacific Ocean between Hawai’i and Central America.
Industry estimates that billions of tons of manganese, copper, nickel and cobalt lie on or beneath the seafloor. These metals are used in electrical generators and motors, metal alloys, batteries, paints, and many other products.
Some mining proponents have argued that companies could offset the inevitable damage their activities will cause by restoring coastal ecosystems or creating new artificial offshore reefs. “But this is like saving apple orchards to protect orange groves,” Van Dover said.
“The argument that you can compensate for the loss of biological diversity in the deep sea with gains in diversity elsewhere is so ambiguous as to be scientifically meaningless,” said Craig Smith, professor of oceanography at the University of Hawai’i at Manoa.
Deep-sea ecosystems and species can take decades or even centuries to recover from a disturbance, if they recover at all, Van Dover noted.
The scale of some proposed mining operations — the largest of which will cover more than 83,000 square kilometers, an area larger than Maine — and the depths at which some mining is to be conducted (three miles or more below the sea surface) will make reclamation of the affected sites so cost-prohibitive as to be unrealistic, the authors argue. And the approaches needed to perform restorative action are still largely untested.
The Latest on: Deep-sea mining biodiversity loss
- Scientists claim deep-sea mining could forever harm 'pristine' ocean ecosystemson June 25, 2020 at 8:00 pm
Mining the deep seabed could cause irreversible damage to ocean ecosystems, a group of international scientists say, raising questions as to whether the seafloor’s wealth of critical minerals is worth ...
- The Centre must listen to all stakeholders on coal mining | HT Editorialon June 24, 2020 at 7:48 am
Mineral resources are key to India’s development, and auctions generate huge funds. At the same time, it causes displacement; disturbs forests and wildlife; dries up or contaminates water sources; ...
- Deep-sea mining: An environmental solution or impending catastrophe?on June 16, 2020 at 2:14 pm
In 2007, a submersible with a large drill descended 1,600 meters (5,250 feet) into the sea off the coast of Papua New Guinea (PNG), landing near a network of hydrothermal vents that host an array of ...
- Academic warns deep sea mining activity could affect CO2 absorption rates in ocean ecosystemson June 16, 2020 at 6:28 am
Using the deep-sea submarine named ... surveyed for its deep-sea mining potential and teams of researchers are now conducting surveys to assess the biodiversity of the CCFZ to understand what ...
- ‘We Need to Protect the Ocean Before it’s Too Late’on June 7, 2020 at 5:03 pm
to biodiversity loss, to the increasing likelihood of more pandemics occurring in the future, the current coronavirus crisis has put a spotlight on how far humans are harming the environment. We have ...
- Mining the Deep Sea Could Mean Unique Ecosystems Are ‘Lost Forever’on May 21, 2020 at 6:03 am
It Could Take Decades for the Ocean Floor to Recover From Deep Sea Mining Dredging up the seafloor for minerals could seriously threaten biodiversity ... what their loss would mean for climate ...
- New Report Highlights Deep Sea Nodule Mining Danger to Pacific Ocean and Island Nationson May 21, 2020 at 1:18 am
OTTAWA and MELBOURNE, Australia, May 21, 2020 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) -- A new report analysing over 250 peer reviewed scientific articles finds that the impacts of mining deep sea polymetallic nodules ...
- Fresh study calls for moratorium on deep-sea miningon May 20, 2020 at 10:44 am
A coalition of non-profit organizations is pushing for an international moratorium on deep-sea mining following ... protect biodiversity from deep-sea mining activities. So far, it has granted ...
- The Impacts of Deep Ocean Mining Will 'Last Forever,' Scientists Warnon June 26, 2017 at 11:09 pm
“It is naive to think anything otherwise,” Amon told Gizmodo.“Biodiversity loss in unavoidable once deep-sea mining begins and deep-sea mining will have large-scale and long-lasting effects ...
via Google News and Bing News