Why you might trust a quantum computer with secrets – even over the internet
Here’s the scenario: you have sensitive data and a problem that only a quantum computer can solve. You have no quantum devices yourself. You could buy time on a quantum computer, but you don’t want to give away your secrets. What can you do?
Writing in Physical Review X on 11 July, researchers in Singapore and Australia propose a way you could use a quantum computer securely, even over the internet. The technique could hide both your data and program from the computer itself. Their work counters earlier hints that such a feat is impossible.
The scenario is not far-fetched. Quantum computers promise new routes to solving problems in cryptography, modelling and machine learning, exciting government and industry. Such problems may involve confidential data or be commercially sensitive.
Technology giants are already investing in building such computers – and making them available to users. For example, IBM announced on 17 May this year that it is making a quantum computer with 16 quantum bits accessible to the public for free on the cloud, as well as a 17-qubit prototype commercial processor.
Seventeen qubits are not enough to outperform the world’s current supercomputers, but as quantum computers gain qubits, they are expected to exceed the capabilities of any machine we have today. That should drive demand for access.
“We’re looking at what’s possible if you’re someone just interacting with a quantum computer across the internet from your laptop. We find that it’s possible to hide some interesting computations,” says Joseph Fitzsimons, a Principal Investigator at the Centre for Quantum Technologies (CQT) at the National University of Singapore and Associate Professor at Singapore University of Technology and Design (SUTD), who led the work.
Quantum computers work by processing bits of information stored in quantum states. Unlike the binary bits found in our regular (i.e., classical) computers, each a 0 or 1, qubits can be in superpositions of 0 and 1. The qubits can also be entangled, which is believed to be crucial to a quantum computer’s power.
The scheme designed by Joseph and his colleagues brings secrecy to a form of quantum computing driven by measurements.
In this scheme, the quantum computer is prepared by putting all its qubits into a special type of entangled state. Then the computation is carried out by measuring the qubits one by one. The user provides step-wise instructions for each measurement: the steps encode both the input data and the program.
Researchers have shown previously that users who can make or measure qubits to convey instructions to the quantum computer could disguise their computation. The new paper extends that power to users who can only send classical bits – i.e. most of us, for now.
This is surprising because some computer science theorems imply that encrypted quantum computation is impossible when only classical communication is available.
The hope for security comes from the quantum computer not knowing which steps of the measurement sequence do what. The quantum computer can’t tell which qubits were used for inputs, which for operations and which for outputs.
“It’s extremely exciting. You can use this unique feature of the measurement-based model of quantum computing – the way information flows through the state – as a crypto tool to hide information from the server,” says team member Tommaso Demarie of CQT and SUTD.
Although the owner of the quantum computer could try to reverse engineer the sequence of measurements performed, ambiguity about the role of each step leads to many possible interpretations of what calculation was done. The true calculation is hidden among the many, like a needle in a haystack.
The set of interpretations grows rapidly with the number of qubits. “The set of all possible computations is exponentially large – that’s one of the things we prove in the paper – and therefore the chance of guessing the real computation is exponentially small,” says Joseph. One question remains: could meaningful computations be so rare among all the possible ones that the guessing gets easier? That’s what the researchers need to check next.
Nicolas Menicucci at the Centre for Quantum Computation and Communication Technology at RMIT University in Melbourne, Australia, and Atul Mantri at SUTD, are coauthors on the work.
“Quantum computers became famous in the ’90s with the discovery that they could break some classical cryptography schemes – but maybe quantum computing will instead be known for making the future of cloud computing secure,” says Atul.
The Latest on: Quantum computing
- Lightning fast quantum computers mean that we are in a new race to strengthen cybersecurity defenceson November 19, 2019 at 8:11 pm
A new type of computer, based on quantum theory, is going to change the way that organisations deal with data in the future because it will allow them to solve some problems at an exponentially faster ...
- Quantum Computing: Challenges, Trends and the Road Aheadon November 19, 2019 at 10:15 am
Recently, Google announced another major milestone in the development of Quantum Computing. According to Google, and despite skepticism from some of its competitors, the Mountain View, Calif.-based ...
- Quantum's Road To Commercializationon November 19, 2019 at 8:46 am
Share to facebook Share to twitter Share to linkedin Over the past two decades, quantum computing has undergone a transformation from a largely scientific and theoretical field to an increasingly ...
- Quantum computers learn to mark their own workon November 18, 2019 at 6:05 am
A new test to check if a quantum computer is giving correct answers to questions beyond the scope of traditional computing could help the first quantum computer that can outperform a classical ...
- Here’s How Quantum Computer Supremacy Will Impact Self-Driving Carson November 16, 2019 at 10:01 am
That’s not to say that the use of their 54-qubit Sycamore processor wasn’t notable, and in fact, does provide another handy stride toward achieving viable quantum computing, but whether it was the ...
- D-Wave sticks with its approach to quantum computingon November 15, 2019 at 1:04 pm
While D-Wave’s 2000Q only played a small part in this process, it’s nevertheless a sign that quantum computing is slowly getting ready for production use and that D-Wave’s approach, somewhat ...
- Quantum Leap for Computing Is a Small Step for Computerson November 15, 2019 at 7:00 am
Ariel Procaccia is an associate professor in the computer science department at Carnegie Mellon University. His areas of expertise include artificial intelligence, theoretical computer science and ...
- Dell Technologies on democratising 5G and the future of quantum computingon November 14, 2019 at 2:27 pm
"And this next cycle, trust me, we have no other goal, than broad adoption of these technologies." Quantum computing, it could go either way When asked during a media session what Dell Technologies ...
- Can Google's New Quantum Computer Hack Bitcoin?on November 14, 2019 at 9:15 am
Nearly everyone agreed that was an extremely remote possibility. But now, some folks fear that day may be closer than expected. The reason: Google claims to have built a quantum computer. It’s a ...
- Hewlett Packard Enterprise explains why it gave up on quantum computing right as it was splitting off from HP Incon November 8, 2019 at 6:06 am
Hewlett Packard Enterprise explains why it stopped its quantum computing efforts five years ago while IBM, Google, Microsoft, and Intel continue.
via Google News and Bing News