Bringing back extinct species could lead to biodiversity loss rather than gain, according to work featuring University of Queensland researchers.
UQ scientist Professor Hugh Possingham said the research suggested further stretching already-strained conservation budgets to cover the costs of de-extinction could endanger extant species (species still in existence).
“If the risk of failure and the costs associated with establishing viable populations could also be calculated, estimates of potential net losses or missed opportunities would probably be considerably higher,” Professor Possingham said.
“De-extinction could be useful for inspiring new science and could be beneficial for conservation if we ensure it doesn’t reduce existing conservation resources.
“However, in general it is best if we focus on the many species that need our help now.”
“Given the considerable potential for missed opportunity, and risks inherent in assuming a resurrected species would fulfil its role as an ecosystem engineer or flagship species, it is unlikely that de-extinction could be justified on grounds of biodiversity conservation.”
The study was led by Dr Joseph Bennett, formerly of the ARC Centre for Environmental Decisions at UQ and now of Carleton University, Canada.
It analysed the number of species governments in New Zealand and New South Wales could afford to conserve.
“We based cost estimates on recently extinct species and similar extant species,” Dr Bennett said.
The Lord Howe pigeon, eastern bettong, bush moa and Waitomo frog were among the extinct species included in calculations.
The researchers found reintroducing some recently extinct species to their old habitats might improve biodiversity locally, but government-funded conservation for 11 focal extinct species in New Zealand would sacrifice conservation for nearly three times as many (31) extant species.
External funding for conservation of the five focal extinct NSW species could instead be used to conserve more than eight times as many (42) extant species.
Although the technology for de-extinction is still some way off, the research found that careful thought would be required about what species to reintroduce, and where.
Receive an email update when we add a new EXTINCT SPECIES article.
The Latest on: De-extinction
via Google News
The Latest on: De-extinction
- Earth Day: Can Genetic Technology Help Resurrect Extinct Species?on April 21, 2019 at 8:49 pm
De-extinction, the proposed reversal of the loss of species that once called Earth home, is one such approach. Imagine ambitious scientists extracting damaged dinosaur DNA from the blood of ancient ...
- Seven reasons we shouldn’t bring extinct animals back to lifeon March 15, 2019 at 5:06 am
What if we could undo hitting that delete button and bring back extinct creatures? This technological process—so-called “de-extinction”—is nearly there, and discussions are therefore shifting from ...
- The Woolly Mammoth Lumbers Back into Viewon December 27, 2018 at 2:02 am
Church’s woolly mammoth research is just one of several de-extinction projects—there are about ten underway now—that aim to use genetics to restore lost species. In her book “The Re-Origin of Species, ...
- De-Extinction Is Now a Thing—Starting With Passenger Pigeonson October 23, 2018 at 8:53 am
Novak is among a small group of “de-extinction” engineers, a relatively fringe group of scientists that hope to use genetic engineering to protect or revive iconic animal species ravaged by human ...
- Inching Toward De-Extinction: Can CRISPR Resurrect Passenger Pigeons?on September 10, 2018 at 3:35 pm
The group is part of the so-called de-extinction movement trying bring back extinct creatures and reintroduce them to their previous habitat. Much of the hype has been about wooly mammoths, but Novak ...
- De-extinction: An Incredible Conservation Tool or Just a Pipe Dream?on March 4, 2018 at 4:00 pm
Bennet and his colleagues performed a cost-benefit analysis for biodiversity and found that de-extinction almost never results in a net-positive change for biodiversity. The researchers found that for ...
- These four animals could be brought back from extinctionon November 14, 2017 at 9:40 am
De-extinction, which is the process of creating an organism that is a member of or closely resembles an extinct species, is a scientific process made possible through the use of gene-editing ...
- How to bring extinct species back to life (and why we may not want to)on November 5, 2017 at 4:44 pm
Britt Wray, a science writer and PhD candidate in science communications, has spend years studying the thorny issue of de-extinction, and its myriad social, ethical and biological implications. Wray ...
- The Rise of Necrofauna and the Ethical Dilemma of De-Extinctionon October 4, 2017 at 5:00 pm
Although the existence of necrofauna is still hypothetical, one animal has already undergone the de-extinction process: the Pyrenean ibex. It is hard to call that a success story just yet, however, as ...
via Bing News