Michael Madary and Thomas Metzinger summarize problems and offer recommendations for the future of VR
Researchers from Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz (JGU) in Germany have prepared a list of ethical concerns that might arise with the use of virtual reality (VR) by researchers and the general public. Along with this list, Dr. Michael Madary and Professor Thomas Metzinger have produced concrete recommendations for minimizing the risks. According to Madary and Metzinger in their article in Frontiers in Robotics and AI, additional focused research is urgently needed.
They are especially concerned about the possibility of unanticipated consequences for the psychological states and self-images of users who are able to inhabit a virtual environment almost as if it is the real world.
The technological capacity for generating virtual worlds from home computers will soon be widely available to the general public, as special head-mounted displays are brought to market that create the illusion of being immersed in virtual three-dimensional worlds. The opportunities for research, education, and entertainment using VR have been much discussed in the media, but Madary and Metzinger seek to raise awareness about the risks that accompany these opportunities – risks that have received far less attention so far.
Both philosophers have participated over the last several years in an EU project on “Virtual Embodiment and Robotic Re-Embodiment” (VERE) with a focus on illusions of embodiment, in which one has the feeling of owning and controlling a body that is not one’s own, such as an avatar in VR.
The fact that VR can create these strong illusions serves as a main reason why VR brings new risks. Madary and Metzinger refer to recent studies showing that immersion in VR can cause behavioral changes that last after subjects leave the virtual environment.
Importantly, VR creates a situation in which the user’s bodily appearance and visual environment is determined by the host of the virtual world. Such considerations raise the possibility that VR will create vast opportunities for psychological manipulation. “These studies suggest that VR poses risks that are novel, that go beyond the risks of traditional psychological experiments in isolated environments, and that go beyond the risks of existing media technology for the general public,” the authors write.
Participants in VR experiments showed strong emotional reactions in addition to behavioral changes, all of which could have an impact on their real lives.
Code of conduct for the ethical use of VR
Based on their analysis of the risks, both researchers from the Department of Philosophy at Mainz University offer concrete recommendations for the use of VR. For example, in experimental work developing new clinical applications, researchers should be careful not to create false hopes in patients. They should repeatedly remind them of the merely experimental nature of the research.
Madary and Metzinger also note that a code of ethical conduct, however important it may be, can never function as a substitute for ethical reasoning itself on the part of researchers. Out of concern for consumers of VR, they call for long-term studies into the psychological effects of immersion.
They see a special danger with particular content such as violence and pornography, where the advanced technology increases the risk of psychological trauma. Users should be clearly informed of these dangers, as well as risks of hallucinations, personality changes, and the powerful unconscious influence of advertising in VR.
Finally, Madary and Metzinger draw attention to the need for regulations regarding ownership and individuation of avatars, regulations that should also address concerns about surveillance and data protection.
The Latest on: Virtual reality issues
via Google News
The Latest on: Virtual reality issues
- Mixed Reality Deployments Can Have Mixed Results -- Here's How To Stay On Trackon January 24, 2020 at 4:13 am
MR can be extremely tricky to implement in business, as it requires making the right investments in a new hardware category, creating new types of digital content and deciding what business practices ...
- The 5 Biggest Virtual And Augmented Reality Trends In 2020 Everyone Should Know Abouton January 23, 2020 at 9:42 pm
2019 was a growth year for virtual and augmented reality (VR/AR)– known collectively as extended reality (XR). The presence of these breakthrough technologies began to be felt far away from the fields ...
- Chef explores Asian-American identity with virtual reality dinner for Lunar New Yearon January 23, 2020 at 5:46 pm
Dorsey, a chef, uses food to address the identity issues that Asian-Americans face by staging dinner events under the title “Asian in America”. The events use virtual reality (VR) and poetry to ...
- How virtual reality may dramatically change eye tests, researchon January 22, 2020 at 4:59 pm
A team at the IWK Health Centre in Halifax is looking at eye testing in a new way thanks to an experiment with virtual reality. The eye clinic works with patients ranging ... tests for six decades to ...
- At 42.62% CAGR, Virtual Retinal Display Market Size Poised to Touch USD 33.12 Billion by 2023on January 21, 2020 at 11:22 pm
Virtual retinal display systems are a type of screenless displays, in which images are projected directly onto the retina. The differentiating factor between retina direct and visual image systems is ...
- Virtual Reality in Gaming and Entertainment Market 2019: Insights By Revenue, Upcoming Trends And Worldwide Players Forecast Till 2026on January 20, 2020 at 12:53 am
Top Players in Virtual Reality in Gaming and Entertainment Market are Electronic Arts Inc., Google, HTC Corporation, Oculus VR, LLC, SAMSUNG Group, Sony Corporation, ZEISS International, LEAP MOTION, ...
- Skydiving, kayaking, fly fishing: Virtual reality therapy is taking paralyzed veterans to new placeson January 17, 2020 at 12:00 pm
Using virtual reality has played a role in his recovery ... Some veterans can be in the hospital recovering from issues such as major pressure sores for as long as a year, the therapists said. “It can ...
- Virtual Reality Can Bring Real-Life Painon January 16, 2020 at 8:09 am
THURSDAY, Jan. 16, 2020 (HealthDay News) -- From carpal tunnel to a stiff neck, too much time on the computer can cause a slew of health problems. But what if you ditch the keyboard and mouse for ...
- Is Virtual Reality (VR) Training Baseball's Next Performance Edge?on January 15, 2020 at 4:12 pm
No one would argue that training and practicing in real and actual space and reality is the best environment to prepare. When 90 mph sinkers and unhittable splitters aren’t available before a game or ...
- Virtual Reality in Gaming Market to Grow Based on Increasing Demand for Novel Gaming Technologies & Platforms Till 2025 | Million Insightson January 14, 2020 at 2:53 am
With reference to the report published the experts the global Virtual Reality in Gaming Market estimated to grow at a higher CAGR by the completion of the prediction period. The issues like increasing ...
via Bing News