Researcher David Silver and colleagues designed a computer program capable of beating a top-level Go player — a marvelous technological feat and important threshold in the development of artificial intelligence, or AI. It stresses once more that humans aren’t at the center of the universe, and that human cognition isn’t the pinnacle of intelligence.
I remember well when IBM’s computer Deep Blue beat chess master Garry Kasparov. Where I’d played — and lost to — chess-playing computers myself, the Kasparov defeat solidified my personal belief that artificial intelligence will become reality, probably even in my lifetime. I might one day be able to talk to things similar to my childhood heroes C-3PO and R2-D2. My future house could be controlled by a program like HAL from Kubrick’s “2001” movie.
As a researcher in artificial intelligence, I realize how impressive it is to have a computer beat a top Go player, a much tougher technical challenge than winning at chess. Yet it’s still not a big step toward the type of artificial intelligence used by the thinking machines we see in the movies. For that, we need new approaches to developing AI.
Intelligence is evolved, not engineered
To understand the limitations of the Go milestone, we need to think about what artificial intelligence is — and how the research community makes progress in the field.
Typically, AI is part of the domain of engineering and computer science, a field in which progress is measured not by how much we learned about nature or humans, but by achieving a well-defined goal: if the bridge can carry a 120-ton truck, it succeeds. Beating a human at Go falls into exactly that category.
I take a different approach. When I talk about AI, I typically don’t talk about a well-defined matter. Rather, I describe the AI that I would like to have as “a machine that has cognitive abilities comparable to that of a human.”
Admittedly, that is a very fuzzy goal, but that is the whole point. We can’t engineer what we can’t define, which is why I think the engineering approach to “human level cognition” — that is, writing smart algorithms to solve a particularly well-defined problem — isn’t going to get us where we want to go. But then what is?
We can’t wait for cognitive- and neuroscience, behavior biology or psychology to figure out what the brain does and how it works. Even if we wait, these sciences will not come up with a simple algorithm explaining the human brain.
What we do know is that the brain wasn’t engineered with a simple modular building plan in mind. It was cobbled together by Darwinian evolution — an opportunistic mechanism governed by the simple rule that whoever makes more viable offspring wins the race.
Algorithms vs. improvisation
To return to the Go algorithm: in the context of computer games, improving skill is possible only by playing against a better competitor.
The Go victory shows that we can make better algorithms for more complex problems than before. That, in turn, suggests that, in the future, we could see more computer games with complex rules providing better opponent AI against human players. Chess computers have changed how modern chess is played, and we can expect a similar effect for Go and its players.
This new algorithm provides a way to define optimal play, which is probably good if you want to learn Go or improve your skills. However, since this new algorithm is pretty much the best possible Go player on Earth, playing against it nearly guarantees you’ll lose. That’s no fun.
Fortunately, continuous loss doesn’t have to happen. The computer’s controllers can make the algorithm play less well by either reducing the number of moves it thinks ahead, or — and this is really new — using a less-developed deep neural net to evaluate the Go board.
But does this make the algorithm play more like a human, and is that what we want in a Go player? Let us turn to other games that have fewer fixed rules and instead require the player to improvise more.
Imagine a first person shooter, or a multiplayer battle game, or a typical role-playing adventure game. These games became popular not because people could play them against better AI, but because they can be played against, or together with, other human beings.
It seems as if we are not necessarily looking for strength and skill in opponents we play, but for human characteristics like being able to surprise us, to see the same humor and maybe to even empathize with us.
Learn more: Evolving our Way to Artificial Intelligence
The Latest on: Evolving artificial intelligence
via Google News
The Latest on: Evolving artificial intelligence
- Artificial Intelligence (AI) Market Size, Share 2020 Global Growth Insight, Trends, Industry Key Players, Regional Forecast To 2023on June 26, 2020 at 3:16 am
Global "Artificial Intelligence (AI) Market" report 2020 has brief analysis and full-scale proposition of market ...
- Can We Have Conscious Artificial Intelligence And Other Mind-Blowing Things Science Can’t Answeron June 25, 2020 at 9:22 pm
In a recent conversation with Professor of Public Understanding of Science at Oxford University, mathematician, broadcaster and author Marcus du Sautoy we explored some questions that he pondered in ...
- Artificial Intelligence Can Serve Democracyon June 25, 2020 at 5:00 pm
nations face a stark choice about what vision of artificial intelligence will prevail. As Group of Seven nations meet this year under the organization’s U.S. presidency, there is a critical ...
- Artificial Intelligence in Procurement is Focus of CVMSDC ProForum on June 25on June 24, 2020 at 12:06 am
CVMSDC will host its virtual ProForum event on June 25, focusing on the evolution of Artificial Intelligence in supplier development.
- VirusTotal Adds Cynet's Artificial Intelligence-Based Malware Detectionon June 23, 2020 at 4:14 am
Google's multi-antivirus scanning service VirusTotal adds Cynet artificial intelligence-based malware detection ...
- Global Artificial General Intelligence Market 2020-2025 - General Purpose AI will Create a Positive Feedback Loop for the IoT Market - ResearchAndMarkets.comon June 23, 2020 at 2:45 am
The "Artificial General Intelligence Market: General Purpose Artificial Intelligence, AI Agent Platforms, and Software 2020 - 2025" report has been added to ResearchAndMarkets.com's offering. This ...
- UCF Launches New Artificial Intelligence and Big Data Initiativeon June 22, 2020 at 11:24 am
UCF Launches New Artificial Intelligence and Big Data Initiative | Read more about UCF Colleges & Campus News, Research, Orlando and Central Florida news.
- Why aren't people smarter? The dubious benefits of intelligence, real or artificialon June 22, 2020 at 8:07 am
Intelligence -- real or artificial -- is supposed to be a big advantage. But we've had millions of years to evolve real intelligence and dumbness is rampant. Which raises the question: If intelligence ...
- The Impact Of Artificial Intelligence On Influencer Marketingon June 22, 2020 at 7:05 am
Not long before, New York-based influencer marketing agency Amra & Elma had developed a platform that ingested data from Instagram, and allowed its client to use AI image classifiers to find very ...
- Artificial intelligence could revolutionize sea ice warningson June 19, 2020 at 3:28 pm
Today, large resources are used to provide vessels in the polar seas with warnings about the spread of sea ice. Artificial intelligence may make these warnings cheaper, faster, and available for ...
via Bing News