From Apple’s Siri to Honda’s robot Asimo, machines seem to be getting better and better at communicating with humans.
But some neuroscientists caution that today’s computers will never truly understand what we’re saying because they do not take into account the context of a conversation the way people do.
Specifically, say University of California, Berkeley, postdoctoral fellow Arjen Stolk and his Dutch colleagues, machines don’t develop a shared understanding of the people, place and situation – often including a long social history – that is key to human communication. Without such common ground, a computer cannot help but be confused.
“People tend to think of communication as an exchange of linguistic signs or gestures, forgetting that much of communication is about the social context, about who you are communicating with,” Stolk said.
The word “bank,” for example, would be interpreted one way if you’re holding a credit card but a different way if you’re holding a fishing pole. Without context, making a “V” with two fingers could mean victory, the number two, or “these are the two fingers I broke.”
“All these subtleties are quite crucial to understanding one another,” Stolk said, perhaps more so than the words and signals that computers and many neuroscientists focus on as the key to communication. “In fact, we can understand one another without language, without words and signs that already have a shared meaning.”
Babies and parents, not to mention strangers lacking a common language, communicate effectively all the time, based solely on gestures and a shared context they build up over even a short time.
Stolk argues that scientists and engineers should focus more on the contextual aspects of mutual understanding, basing his argument on experimental evidence from brain scans that humans achieve nonverbal mutual understanding using unique computational and neural mechanisms. Some of the studies Stolk has conducted suggest that a breakdown in mutual understanding is behind social disorders such as autism.
“This shift in understanding how people communicate without any need for language provides a new theoretical and empirical foundation for understanding normal social communication, and provides a new window into understanding and treating disorders of social communication in neurological and neurodevelopmental disorders,” said Dr. Robert Knight, a UC Berkeley professor of psychology in the campus’s Helen Wills Neuroscience Institute and a professor of neurology and neurosurgery at UCSF.
Stolk and his colleagues discuss the importance of conceptual alignment for mutual understanding in an opinion piece appearing Jan. 11 in the journal Trends in Cognitive Sciences.
Brain scans pinpoint site for ‘meeting of minds’
To explore how brains achieve mutual understanding, Stolk created a game that requires two players to communicate the rules to each other solely by game movements, without talking or even seeing one another, eliminating the influence of language or gesture. He then placed both players in an fMRI (functional magnetic resonance imager) and scanned their brains as they nonverbally communicated with one another via computer.
He found that the same regions of the brain – located in the poorly understood right temporal lobe, just above the ear – became active in both players during attempts to communicate the rules of the game. Critically, the superior temporal gyrus of the right temporal lobe maintained a steady, baseline activity throughout the game but became more active when one player suddenly understood what the other player was trying to communicate. The brain’s right hemisphere is more involved in abstract thought and social interactions than the left hemisphere.
“These regions in the right temporal lobe increase in activity the moment you establish a shared meaning for something, but not when you communicate a signal,” Stolk said. “The better the players got at understanding each other, the more active this region became.”
This means that both players are building a similar conceptual framework in the same area of the brain, constantly testing one another to make sure their concepts align, and updating only when new information changes that mutual understanding. The results were reported in 2014 in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.
“It is surprising,” said Stolk, “that for both the communicator, who has static input while she is planning her move, and the addressee, who is observing dynamic visual input during the game, the same region of the brain becomes more active over the course of the experiment as they improve their mutual understanding.”
Robots’ statistical reasoning
Robots and computers, on the other hand, converse based on a statistical analysis of a word’s meaning, Stolk said. If you usually use the word “bank” to mean a place to cash a check, then that will be the assumed meaning in a conversation, even when the conversation is about fishing.
The Latest on: Human computer understanding
via Google News
The Latest on: Human computer understanding
- Scientists pursue new genetic insights for health: Inside the world of ‘deep mutational scanning’on January 10, 2020 at 10:46 am
Is it because of advances in computer processing or is it ... to go from just getting these sequences to understanding what the mutations that you observe in these sequences actually will mean for ...
- How do fruit flies see in color? Columbia study uncovers human-like brain circuit at workon January 9, 2020 at 8:01 am
A deeper understanding of the brain promises to transform human health and society. From effective treatments for disorders like Alzheimer's, Parkinson's, depression and autism to advances in fields ...
- Scientists Have Discovered A New Kind Of Signal In The Human Brainon January 3, 2020 at 9:38 am
Demonstrable differences in human compared to other mammal brains helps us pin down why human brains may be unique, which can lead to a better understanding, and even better modeling ... They studied ...
- NEC Personal Computers Makes Three Flagship Devices Available in the US Marketon January 3, 2020 at 9:11 am
NEC Personal Computers, Ltd., a joint venture company of Lenovo and NEC Corporation, announces that its newest LAVIE devices are available in the United States, ahead of CES 2020. The three products a ...
- Neuroscientists Discover New Kind Of Signal In The Human Brainon January 2, 2020 at 11:29 am
Our brains are computers that work using a system of connected brain cells ... This process might be important to better understanding our unique brains and to improving programs that are based on a ...
- Human art evades understanding so how will we ever ‘get’ machinic art?on December 25, 2019 at 6:05 am
And how can we form an understanding of the art that it makes ... far of ‘art made by machines’ are actually just straightforward examples of human art made with computers, with the artists being the ...
- Understanding a Human Interface Guidelines for Developmenton November 24, 2018 at 4:00 pm
Policies, sometimes policies are based on the HCI-Human Computer Interaction, but mostly it will part of the platform developers preferences and user experience designer. The scope of the HIG, ...
- Cross-Cultural Differences in Understanding Human-Computer Interfaceson May 1, 2018 at 10:54 pm
This PhD research performed at the Open University investigates cross-cultural understanding of human-computer interface design. The main research will involve observation sessions with users from ...
- The Long History of Computer Science and Psychology Comes Into Viewon March 18, 2018 at 1:33 pm
The work has taken place almost entirely in the domain of computer science, with little input from clinical psychologists, ethicists, or other academic fields interested in the messy details of human ...
- Vivo and Qualcomm signed a memorandum of understanding worth 4 billion U.S. dollarson November 10, 2017 at 1:10 am
The signing of this memorandum of understanding signifies Vivo and Qualcomm's technical ... With the advent of 5G, Vivo understands the importance of human-computer interaction and has planned a ...
via Bing News