Manufacturing — that is, the business of making stuff — has changed significantly over the past half-century. Perhaps you’ve noticed. While America’s share of industry has constricted, with fewer people needed to perform the same amount of work as in the past, it’s not quite time to start eulogizing.
But the way the presidential candidates have been talking about reviving manufacturing jobs has not been very enlightening, and in some cases they have been willfully obtuse. Their statements are meant to appeal to disaffected workers, but they both oversimplify the problems and ignore the real source of trouble.
Donald J. Trump, the Republican front-runner, has promised to bring manufacturing jobs back to American workers from abroad. “They can’t get jobs, because there are no jobs, because China has our jobs and Mexico has our jobs,” Mr. Trump said in his campaign announcement speech in June. (He neglected to mention that his own line of neckties is fabricated in China.)
Mike Huckabee, the former Arkansas governor, seems to regularly misconstrue the state of American manufacturing — more than any other candidate. At the undercard debate in Milwaukee on Nov. 10, Mr. Huckabee explained that the United States has lost five million manufacturing jobs since 2000: “The reason they don’t have jobs is because their jobs are in Mexico, they’re in China, they’re in Indonesia,” he said, referring to American workers. While that is certainly true for some of the jobs lost, outsourcing is not the main driver of domestic job loss.
Republicans aren’t the only ones obsessing over reclaiming these factory jobs. Last month, Hillary Clinton mentioned factory closings when she released her own plan to restore manufacturing jobs through a network of tax credits and federal funding for research. Senator Bernie Sanders, meanwhile, in criticizing the Trans-Pacific Partnership, has argued that such international trade deals are to blame for the loss of manufacturing jobs in this country.
The problem with this sort of rhetoric is that a lot of the manufacturing jobs the United States lost over the past 50 years didn’t go overseas; they simply disappeared with the advent of new technology.
James Sherk, a research fellow in labor economics at the Heritage Foundation, said the trend in machines taking over factory work that was previously done by humans has been going on since the 1950s. But for presidential candidates, it’s a lot easier to blame other countries rather than robots.
“It’s those basically rote, repetitive tasks where you’re fixing the same thing,” he said. “It’s very hard to imagine any of those positions coming back. Basically, a robot is a lot more affordable than a human employee.”
The skills needed to work on a factory floor today are quite different than they were 20, 10 or even five years ago. Don’t blame stingy companies or over-regulation by the government; blame the rapid progress of technology.
Mark Muro, the policy director of the Brookings Institution’s Metropolitan Policy Program, said candidates should recognize that because of advances in technology, manufacturing simply does not employ as many people as it once did. Then again, that level of honesty doesn’t make for as much of a feel-good message.
“My fear is that the Republicans to date may not fully understand what modern advanced manufacturing is,” he said. “It’s not necessarily thousands of people pouring into the plant as in the old days.”
Instead of talking down to blue-collar workers, candidates should admit that trying to restore manufacturing to what it once was in this country is not an attainable, or even a desirable, goal. This is not to say the government should not work to bring jobs back to the United States, or that manufacturing as an industry is not valuable to the American economy. But many of the jobs politicians want to restore aren’t on the table anymore.
Read more: Time to Talk Robots
The Latest on: Advanced manufacturing
via Google News
The Latest on: Advanced manufacturing
- Intel committed to advanced manufacturing in USAon December 2, 2020 at 10:32 pm
Intel CEO Bob Swan (pictured) committed the company to having advanced manufacturing in the USA. That would have gone without saying three years ...
- Diversified Plastics, Inc. wins coveted Tekne Award for advanced manufacturingon December 2, 2020 at 3:41 pm
MINNEAPOLIS – Diversified Plastics, Inc. (DPI) received the Minnesota Technology Association’s award for advanced manufacturing at the presentation of the 23rd ...
- Diversified Plastics Wins Advanced Manufacturing Awardon December 2, 2020 at 1:57 pm
The custom injection molder received a Tekne Award, which recognizes innovative technology developed by Minnesota-based companies.
- Despite Renewed Labor Shortages, November Sustains Growth in Manufacturingon December 2, 2020 at 5:22 am
ISM report says the surge in COVID-19 cases is leading to labor shortages. Manufacturing activity remained on the up in November despite headwinds, according to the Institute for Supply Management.
- A New Partnership in the Horizon: UK Aerospace Giant and an Australian Defence Broker & Advanced Manufacturing Companyon December 2, 2020 at 4:39 am
Glaive International Defence Pty. Ltd. and Marques Aviation Ltd. aerospace and defence companies announce an R&D, manufacturing and commercial partnership ...
- WLS leaders cut the ribbon on new Advanced Manufacturing Labon November 30, 2020 at 10:36 am
A new Advanced Manufacturing Lab was unveiled Monday. The new state-of-the-art facility will help give students hands-on training to get manufacturing jobs in Northwest Ohio. “What Toledo needs, what ...
- Sheffield’s advanced manufacturing is a levelling up success story – Sky Newson November 30, 2020 at 4:50 am
Sky News reported on how the manufacturing industry could help level up the country, featuring the AMRC and Advanced Manufacturing (Sheffield) Ltd.
- Dyson to set up new advanced manufacturing hub in S'pore, in $4.9b investment across 3 countrieson November 26, 2020 at 6:51 pm
British technology company Dyson is planning for a new advanced manufacturing hub in Singapore, as part of a £2.75 billion (S$4.93 billion) investment which will include the United Kingdom and the ...
- Critical Manufacturing launches its new, ‘most advanced’ manufacturing execution systemon November 26, 2020 at 1:50 am
Critical Manufacturing has relased what it describes as its “most advanced” Industry 4.0 Manufacturing Execution System (MES). Critical Manufacturing MES V8 reveals a revolutionary new IoT Data ...
- Mason to lead regional hub for national cybersecurity advanced manufacturing innovation partnershipon November 23, 2020 at 9:21 am
George Mason University is poised to be named a managing member in the Cybersecurity Manufacturing Innovation Institute (CyManII), a $111 million public-private partnership led by the University of ...
via Bing News