Students Learn Six Times More With CMU’s Simon Initiative Approach Than With MOOCs
Free — or very inexpensive — online courses have become quite a trend in education. Massive Open Online Course (MOOC) providers currently offer thousands of courses and have enticed millions of students to enroll. The emphasis in MOOCs is often on lecture videos that students watch and learn from.
However, a study published in the Proceedings of the Second (2015) ACM Conference on Learning @ Scale shows that this central approach of MOOCs — having students watch to learn — is ineffective. Instead, the emphasis on interactive activities as advocated by Carnegie Mellon University’s Simon Initiative helps students learn about six times more.
CMU’s Simon Initiative, named for the late Nobel and Turning laureate Herbert Simon, aims to measurably improve student learning outcomes by harnessing a learning engineering ecosystem that has developed over several decades at CMU. The Simon Initiative approach uses CMU’s Open Learning Initiative (OLI) courses, which are built to mimic intelligent tutors in order to provide adaptive feedback and hints during learning by doing.
“Learning by doing gives students deliberative practice opportunities to address a course’s objectives,” said Ken Koedinger, professor of human-computer interaction and psychology and co-coordinator of the Simon Initiative. “With OLI, students get immediate feedback. If they do not master a concept, they have to go back to re-watch or re-read and then demonstrate they have learned before they are able to move on.”
Koedinger and his team set out to understand the difference between MOOCs and OLI courses, specifically whether OLI features help students learn more than MOOC lecture videos. They compared two uses of an Introduction to Psychology as a Science class: 18,645 students took it as a MOOC only, while 9,075 enrolled in it as a combined MOOC and OLI course. Eleven weekly quizzes and a final exam were given to all students.
First, the researchers compared how each group’s students performed on the final exam. MOOC-only students had an average score of 57 percent, and the MOOC and OLI students averaged 66 percent. This significant difference remains after adjusting for other contributors to student success including their prior educational background and their incoming psychology knowledge.
“Do students learn more with OLI? The answer is a clear and resounding ‘yes,’” Koedinger said.
Then, the team investigated how different patterns of student use corresponded with different student learning outcomes. They found that while more watching, reading and doing all predict better learning outcomes, the amount of learning associated with each activity done was six times greater than for each video watched or page read.
“Most of MOOCs’ attention has been on scaling teaching — making lectures available to more people,” said Norman Bier, director of OLI and executive director of the Simon Initiative. “This study shows that students can be better served if educators and course creators focus on what we can scale — learning. More attention needs to be placed on designing, developing and improving the learning experience in online courses — with a focus on learning by doing that is well-aligned with outcomes and assessments.”
Because MOOCs have a history of retention problems, the researchers also compared course dropout and completion rates. They found that MOOC and OLI students were 30% more likely to finish the course and take the final exam than those in the MOOC-only class. Also, participation in the weekly quizzes — meaning students stayed in the courses longer — was always higher for the MOOC and OLI students.
Read more: LEARNING IS NOT A SPECTATOR SPORT
The Latest on: Open Learning Initiative
via Google News
The Latest on: Open Learning Initiative
- Art teacher turns village in southern Egypt to open-air museumon June 27, 2020 at 8:11 am
Assad paints a wall of an old house with drawings at al-Mokhada village in Qena province, Egypt on June 17, 2020. Ahmad al-Assad, a 43-year-old art teacher, decided to turn his village, located in ...
- Yandex to launch educational initiative center at North-Caucasus Federal Universityon June 26, 2020 at 4:53 am
North-Caucasus Federal University (NCFU) and Yandex will open a joint educational initiatives center in the beginning of a new school year; the venter will focus on developing e-learning in ...
- Round 2: The Fact-Checking Innovation Initiative wants to support your next big ideaon June 25, 2020 at 2:04 pm
Grantees will share funding totaling up to $450,000 for technology projects that bring fact-checkers together with developers and/or academics.
- GM Berry, Browns launch racial justice initiative for changeon June 25, 2020 at 11:40 am
Dismayed by George Floyd's tragic death in Minneapolis, yet strengthened by the nationwide wave of protests that followed, Berry, Browns vice president of football operations and one of only two Black ...
- GM Berry, Browns launch racial justice initiative for change | Raleigh News & Observeron June 25, 2020 at 10:39 am
Dismayed by George Floyd's tragic death in Minneapolis, yet strengthened by the nationwide wave of protests that followed, Berry, Browns vice president of football operations and After being ...
- OpenDP Initiative Aims To Share Data and Preserve Privacyon June 24, 2020 at 4:56 pm
Microsoft and Harvard University have been collaborating on open source tools aimed at easing data sharing while also preserving privacy, according to a Wednesday announcement.
- Botswana E-Learning Initiative Wins Prestigious UN Public Service Awardon June 22, 2020 at 5:00 pm
In some parts of Botswana, parents looking for regular updates on their children progress in school, or teachers trying to quickly get in touch with parents will no longer need to wait for the ...
- QuickLogic Announces Open Reconfigurable Computing Initiativeon June 18, 2020 at 2:29 pm
QuickLogic Open Reconfigurable Computing (QORC) initiative broadens access to company's FPGA technology and eFPGA IP for all embedded systems developers .
- Long Beach moves ahead with ‘open streets’ initiative, focusing on neighborhood roads – for nowon June 17, 2020 at 2:40 am
Neighborhood streets throughout Long Beach can soon be closed to make way for pedestrians, cyclists and businesses that want to expand beyond their storefronts. The Long Beach City Council voted ...
- Open Learning Initiative at Stanfordon June 28, 2017 at 1:15 pm
With the exception of third party images, video content, and case studies, this courseware content is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License. In-Person ...
via Bing News