Students Learn Six Times More With CMU’s Simon Initiative Approach Than With MOOCs
Free — or very inexpensive — online courses have become quite a trend in education. Massive Open Online Course (MOOC) providers currently offer thousands of courses and have enticed millions of students to enroll. The emphasis in MOOCs is often on lecture videos that students watch and learn from.
However, a study published in the Proceedings of the Second (2015) ACM Conference on Learning @ Scale shows that this central approach of MOOCs — having students watch to learn — is ineffective. Instead, the emphasis on interactive activities as advocated by Carnegie Mellon University’s Simon Initiative helps students learn about six times more.
CMU’s Simon Initiative, named for the late Nobel and Turning laureate Herbert Simon, aims to measurably improve student learning outcomes by harnessing a learning engineering ecosystem that has developed over several decades at CMU. The Simon Initiative approach uses CMU’s Open Learning Initiative (OLI) courses, which are built to mimic intelligent tutors in order to provide adaptive feedback and hints during learning by doing.
“Learning by doing gives students deliberative practice opportunities to address a course’s objectives,” said Ken Koedinger, professor of human-computer interaction and psychology and co-coordinator of the Simon Initiative. “With OLI, students get immediate feedback. If they do not master a concept, they have to go back to re-watch or re-read and then demonstrate they have learned before they are able to move on.”
Koedinger and his team set out to understand the difference between MOOCs and OLI courses, specifically whether OLI features help students learn more than MOOC lecture videos. They compared two uses of an Introduction to Psychology as a Science class: 18,645 students took it as a MOOC only, while 9,075 enrolled in it as a combined MOOC and OLI course. Eleven weekly quizzes and a final exam were given to all students.
First, the researchers compared how each group’s students performed on the final exam. MOOC-only students had an average score of 57 percent, and the MOOC and OLI students averaged 66 percent. This significant difference remains after adjusting for other contributors to student success including their prior educational background and their incoming psychology knowledge.
“Do students learn more with OLI? The answer is a clear and resounding ‘yes,’” Koedinger said.
Then, the team investigated how different patterns of student use corresponded with different student learning outcomes. They found that while more watching, reading and doing all predict better learning outcomes, the amount of learning associated with each activity done was six times greater than for each video watched or page read.
“Most of MOOCs’ attention has been on scaling teaching — making lectures available to more people,” said Norman Bier, director of OLI and executive director of the Simon Initiative. “This study shows that students can be better served if educators and course creators focus on what we can scale — learning. More attention needs to be placed on designing, developing and improving the learning experience in online courses — with a focus on learning by doing that is well-aligned with outcomes and assessments.”
Because MOOCs have a history of retention problems, the researchers also compared course dropout and completion rates. They found that MOOC and OLI students were 30% more likely to finish the course and take the final exam than those in the MOOC-only class. Also, participation in the weekly quizzes — meaning students stayed in the courses longer — was always higher for the MOOC and OLI students.
Read more: LEARNING IS NOT A SPECTATOR SPORT
The Latest on: Open Learning Initiative
via Google News
The Latest on: Open Learning Initiative
- Qatar’s first learning festival openson November 15, 2019 at 12:43 am
The Festival organised by World Innovation Summit (WISE), an initiative of Qatar Foundation ... sustainable lifestyles. ‘Doha Learning Days,’ being held at Ceremonial Court and Green Spine in ...
- Qatar’s First Experiential Learning Festival Set to Openon November 14, 2019 at 3:22 am
Organized by WISE – an initiative of Qatar Foundation – Doha Learning Days is taking place at the Ceremonial Court and Green Spine in Education City from November 14-19, and is open to the whole ...
- ‘Doha Learning Days’ festival gets underway from todayon November 13, 2019 at 2:15 pm
Qatar’s first experiential learning festival, will take place from today at Ceremonial Court and Green Spine in Education City. The six-day festival, which runs until November 19, has been organised ...
- Cooperation Is The Key Initiative For Advancing AI Technologyon November 7, 2019 at 4:21 am
After all, we designed them to do the same things we do and to be capable of learning, just like us. The visceral drive for humans to automate ... Through building systems based on open architecture ...
- MIT's CLIx Nabs UNESCO Prize for Open Learning Initiativeon March 19, 2018 at 9:32 am
MIT's Connected Learning Initiative (CLIx) has won the King Hamad bin Isa Al ... gratifying and energizing to receive this award from UNESCO," said Vijay Kumar, associate dean for open learning and ...
- Open Learning Initiative at CMUon November 27, 2016 at 3:30 am
The Open Learning Initiative (OLI) at Carnegie Mellon is a nonprofit research organization that offers openly licensed, adaptive online courses and materials that can be used by instructors or ...
- Carnegie Mellon’s Open Learning Initiative Draws 50,000on August 5, 2016 at 7:20 am
Each year, 50,000 students participate in Carnegie Mellon University’s online academic courses as part of the institution’s Open Learning Initiative (OLI). OLI, which began in the early 2000s, is an ...
- How Can Carnegie Mellon's Open Learning Initiative Help You?on July 23, 2016 at 1:54 am
The open learning community has been abuzz following Web developer Mozilla's recent announcement of its open badges infrastructure. And while there doesn't yet seem to be any official talk concerning ...
- Stanford’s Open Learning Initiative receives Gates Foundation granton October 27, 2014 at 2:30 am
Stanford’s Open Learning Initiative (OLI) program is one of seven educational technology programs to split a $20 million fund from the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation. OLI is an online educational ...
- Sharing Made Easier—Autodesk Implements Creative Commons Open Learning Initiativeon July 23, 2013 at 3:06 am
The company established the Autodesk Open Learning Initiative in response to a request from Paul Duguay, a 3D and multimedia studies instructor at the Collège Communautaire du Nouveau-Brunswick, ...
via Bing News