There has been much discussion of late of the ethics of artificial intelligence (AI), especially regarding robot weapons development and a related but more general discussion about AI as an existential threat to humanity.
If Skynet of the Terminator movies is going to exterminate us, then it seems pretty tame — if not pointless — to start discussing regulation and liability. But, as legal philosopher John Donaher has pointed out, if these areas are promptly and thoughtfully addressed, that could help to reduce existential risk over the longer term.
In relation to AI, regulation and liability are two sides of the same safety/public welfare coin. Regulation is about ensuring that AI systems are as safe as possible; liability is about establishing who we can blame — or, more accurately, get legal redress from — when something goes wrong.
The finger of blame
Taking liability first, let’s consider tort (civil wrong) liability. Imagine the following near-future scenario. A driverless tractor is instructed to drill seed in Farmer A’s field but actually does so in Farmer B’s field.
Let’s assume that Farmer A gave proper instructions. Let’s also assume that there was nothing extra that Farmer A should have done, such as placing radio beacons at field boundaries. Now suppose Farmer B wants to sue for negligence (for ease and speed, we’ll ignore nuisance and trespass).
Is Farmer A liable? Probably not. Is the tractor manufacturer liable? Possibly, but there would be complex arguments around duty and standard of care, such as what are the relevant industry standards, and are the manufacturer’s specifications appropriate in light of those standards? There would also be issues over whether the unwanted planting represented damage to property or pure economic loss.
So far, we have implicitly assumed the tractor manufacturer developed the system software. But what if a third party developed the AI system? What if there was code from more than one developer?
Over time, the further that AI systems move away from classical algorithms and coding, the more they will display behaviours that were not just unforeseen by their creators but were wholly unforeseeable. This is significant because foreseeability is a key ingredient for liability in negligence.
To understand the foreseeability issue better, let’s take a scenario where, perhaps only a decade or two after the planting incident above, an advanced, fully autonomous AI-driven robot accidentally injures or kills a human and there have been no substantial changes to the law. In this scenario, the lack of foreseeability could result in nobody at all being liable in negligence.
Blame the AI robot
But would that approach actually make a difference here? As an old friend said to me recently:
Leaving aside whether AI systems can be sued, AI manufacturers and developers will probably have to be put back into the frame. This might involve replacing negligence with strict liability – liability applied without any need to prove fault or negligence.
Strict liability already exists for defective product claims in many places. Alternatively there could be a no fault liability scheme with a claims pool contributed to by the AI industry.
The Latest on: Ethics of artificial intelligence
via Google News
The Latest on: Ethics of artificial intelligence
- Managing ethics and privacy in the age of AIon November 25, 2020 at 3:59 pm
Many Australian organisations are experimenting with artificial intelligence and machine learning technologies to gain new insights from their information to create an advantage over their competitors ...
- Human Intelligence sought to drive future of AI in nswon November 25, 2020 at 3:06 pm
The NSW Government is searching for the brightest minds to take part in the newly established Artificial Intelligence (AI) Advisory Committee and ...
- Cuba favors ethical approach to artificial intelligence at UNESCOon November 25, 2020 at 8:30 am
Cuban Permanent Delegate at UNESCO Yahima Esquivel on Tuesday expressed her country's support for artificial intelligence development from an ethical perspective.
- Cuba supports the use of artificial intelligence from an ethical and inclusive approachon November 24, 2020 at 4:48 pm
The permanent delegate of Cuba to the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO), Yahima Esquivel, expressed Tuesday in Paris the island's support for the development of ...
- UNESCO brings experts together today to discuss the role of a global ethical framework in achieving beneficial AIon November 24, 2020 at 1:54 am
UNESCO is organizing two debates on the ethics of artificial intelligence (AI). Under the leadership of Yoshua Bengio, leading experts will exchange views on this subject. The high-level panel will be ...
- Black Friday And The Ethics Of AIon November 24, 2020 at 1:17 am
With Black Friday around the corner, many businesses have adopted artificial intelligence (AI) to identify changing consumer trends and optimise sales.
- Ethics Center Faculty Scholar Dr. Maya Ackerman Featured in Latest Episode of "Line of Sight"on November 23, 2020 at 10:03 am
In this episode Don Heider and Brigit Helms interview Dr. Maya Ackerman about AI, STEM and gender disparities in the workforce.
- UNESCO gathers leading experts to discuss role of a global ethical framework in achieving beneficial AIon November 23, 2020 at 5:51 am
Led by Yoshua Bengio, one of the world's leading experts in artificial intelligence and a pioneer in deep learning, some of the top thinkers ...
- Beijing leads in China's development of 17 artificial intelligence areason November 20, 2020 at 5:58 am
Beijing, as a leading player in the development of artificial intelligence (AI) in China, is leading the country in 17 areas of AI development and is gradually forming an AI industry ecosystem with ...
- Artificial intelligence for the detection of vertebral fractures on plain spinal radiographyon November 18, 2020 at 11:17 am
Vertebral fractures (VFs) cause serious problems, such as substantial functional loss and a high mortality rate, and a delayed diagnosis may further worsen the prognosis. Plain thoracolumbar ...
via Bing News