The diversity of the world’s life forms — from corals to carnivores — is under assault.
Decades of scientific studies document the fraying of ecosystems and a grim tally of species extinctions due to destroyed habitat, pollution, climate change, invasives and overharvesting.
Which makes Nick Gotelli’s new report in the journal Science rather surprising.
Gotelli, a professor in UVM’s biology department, with colleagues from Saint Andrews University, Scotland, and the University of Maine, re-examined data from one hundred long-term monitoring studies done around the world — polar regions to the tropics, in the oceans and on land. They discovered that the number of species in many of these places has not changed much — or has actually increased.
Now wait a minute. A global extinction crisis should show up in declining levels of local biodiversity, right? That’s not what the scientists found. Instead they discovered that, on average, the number of species recorded remained the same over time. Fifty-nine of the one hundred biological communities showed an increase in species richness and 41 a decrease. In all the studies, the rate of change was modest.
But the researchers did discover something changing rapidly: which species were living in the places being studied. Almost 80 percent of the communities the team examined showed substantial changes in species composition, averaging about 10 percent change per decade — significantly higher than the rate of change predicted by models.
In other words, this new report shows that a huge turnover of species in habitats around the globe is under way, resulting in the creation of novel biological communities. “Right under our noses, in the same place that a team might have looked a decade earlier, or even just a year earlier, a new assemblage of plants and animals may be taking hold,” Gotelli says.
The causes of this shift are not yet fully clear, but the implications for conservation and policy could be significant. Historically, conservation science and planning has focused on protecting endangered species more than on shifts in which plants and animals are assembled together. “A main policy application of this work is that we’re going to need to focus as much on the identity of species as on the number of species,” Gotelli says. “The number of species in a place may not be our best scorecard for environmental change.”
For example, the scientists write that disturbed coral reefs can be replaced by a group of species dominated by algae. This replacement might keep the species count the same, but not necessarily provide the fisheries, tourism (“algae diving” doesn’t have quite the same appeal as “reef diving”) or coastal protections that the original coral reef did.
“In the oceans we no longer have many anchovies, but we seem to have an awful lot of jellyfish,” says Gotelli. “Those kinds of changes are not going to be seen by just counting the number of species that are present.”
The new research, led by Maria Dornelas at Saint Andrews University in Scotland, carefully looked for previous studies that had tracked and tallied species over many years. The team selected 100 that contained six million observations of more than 35,000 different species — including datasets that go back to 1874 and many over the last 40 years. Given widespread observation of habitat change and individual species declines — and knowing that extinction rates are many times higher than normal — the scientists predicted a drop, over time, in the number of species observed in most of these studies.
Why they didn’t find this drop could be driven by many forces. One is related to what science writer David Quammen semi-famously termed our “planet of weeds.” In other words, invasive species or successful colonists or weedy generalists — think kudzu and rats — may be spreading into new places, keeping the local species tally up, even as the planet’s overall biodiversity is degraded.
“We move species around,” Gotelli says. “There is a huge ant diversity in Florida, and about 30 percent of the ant species are non-natives. They have been accidentally introduced, mostly from the Old World tropics, and they are now a part of the local assemblage. So you can have increased diversity in local communities because of global homogenization.”
And sampling issues may conceal important realities: some species may have become so rare — think white rhinos — that they’re highly unlikely to be found in a general species survey and so don’t show in the initial results nor disappear in later ones.
Range shifts associated with climate change could be at work, too, quickly pushing species into new terrain. On May 6, the White House released its National Climate Assessment noting that, as a result of human-caused warming, “species, including many iconic species, may disappear from regions where they have been prevalent or become extinct, altering some regions so much that their mix of plant and animal life will become almost unrecognizable.”
The Latest on: Diversity of the world’s life forms
via Google News
The Latest on: Diversity of the world’s life forms
- Finding the Sweet, Stinging Salt in Plays of Confinementon May 31, 2020 at 11:24 am
For stuck-at-homes feeling like submerging into the existential depths of no-exit theater, here’s a list of works to read and to watch.
- Sports world reacts to George Floyd protests in Untied Stateson May 31, 2020 at 10:49 am
Over a dozen major cities across the United States have continued to protest police brutality and racial injustice following the killing of George Floyd by a Minneapolis police officer earlier this ...
- Broncos Hall of Fame running back Floyd Little diagnosed with 'treatable but aggressive' canceron May 31, 2020 at 10:35 am
Floyd Little is known throughout the the Denver Broncos organization, and the football world as a whole, for his contributions to the sport. The 77-year-old received terrible news recently when biopsy ...
- The Neuroscience of Craving Less Monotony in Your Daily Lifeon May 31, 2020 at 7:50 am
Does the daily grind of COVID stay-at-home orders make you feel like Bill Murray in Groundhog Day? Do you feel like you're living out a Twilight Zone episode in which every humdrum day on your ...
- Vision: Observing the world during childhood affects the rest of lifeon May 29, 2020 at 11:03 am
Development to adulthood depends on observing the surroundings and not only on explicit teaching. This also applies to the development of the visual system. This is the conclusion reached by two ...
- Searching for Life in the Outer Solar Systemon May 29, 2020 at 3:30 am
Perhaps the origin of life is hard, and life is rare. Or perhaps we live in a universe teeming with life — a biological universe of incredible diversity across planets, moons, stars, and galaxies.
- If Hong Kong burns, the world gets burned tooon May 28, 2020 at 12:55 pm
HONG KONG — Just as Hong Kong begins to see some hard-won respite from the coronavirus, a potentially more deadly political virus from Beijing has barged in with full force. The National People's ...
- Op-Ed: Hong Kong is the front line of a new cold war. If it burns, the world gets burned tooon May 28, 2020 at 12:14 pm
Beijing is using the coronavirus crisis to crush Hong Kong's demands for more freedom, thinking the world is too busy to care.
- The importance of diversity and inclusion in Omahaon May 26, 2020 at 9:34 am
What does it mean to be an inclusive city? A handful of Omaha leaders sit down to discuss diversity and ways to keep young people actively involved in their community.
- New research reveals the odds of life evolving on alien worldson May 21, 2020 at 5:30 pm
Scientists have used a statistical method known as Bayesian inference to determine the odds of complex extraterrestrial life evolving on alien planets, according to new research published this ...
via Bing News