Intellectual property: After being blamed for stymying innovation in America, vague and overly broad patents on software and business processes could get the chop
AT LAST, it seems, something is to be done about the dysfunctional way America’s patent system operates. Two recent developments suggest calls for patent reform are finally being heard at the highest levels. First, in 2013, defying expectations, the House of Representatives passed (by an overwhelming majority) the Innovation Act, a bill aimed squarely at neutralising so-called patent trolls. These are individuals or companies who buy up lots of patents and then use them to extract payments from unsuspecting victims. Second, the US Supreme Court agreed to rule on what is the most contentious issue of all: which inventions are actually eligible for patent protection.
Frivolous lawsuits filed by trolls cost American companies $29 billion in 2011 alone. Trolls (known in the legal world as “patent assertion entities” or “non-practising entities”) do not make anything, but send out thousands of “demand letters” to companies that allegedly infringe what are often vague and overly broad business-process and software patents. In recent years their targets have spread from high-tech firms to universities, retailers, hospitals, charities and even consumers. The trolls demand a settlement fee, which many of the victims pay rather than face the punitive cost of litigation—$2m or more these days.
Concern that the flood of frivolous patent suits in America is hobbling innovation and competition has caught Congress’s attention. Startups threatened by such actions frequently have to withdraw from the business or go bust. Bigger companies that choose to fight spend tens of millions of dollars on litigation that could otherwise go on research and development.
In a sense, the legal bullying by trolls is a symptom of a wider complaint: the poor quality of many patents granted by the US Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) in the past decade—especially those covering computer software and business transactions (themselves often based on software algorithms). One such patent covers simply upgrading computer software over the internet. That is admittedly useful, but hardly novel or non-obvious—the three fundamental requirements for eligibility adopted by patent jurisdictions everywhere.
Numerous corporations have started using their portfolios of poorly defined software patents to prevent rivals from entering the market. Witness the series of lengthy legal disputes between Apple and Samsung. Too often, it seems, software patents operate not as an incentive for innovation, but as a barrier to entry and a tax on new-product development. This is not what patent law was intended to do. Although the USPTO has been mainly at fault, America’s courts have not helped.
One of the worst offenders has been the US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, the appellate court that rules on patent disputes, among countless other things. Unlike its specialised counterparts in Europe and Japan, the Federal Circuit, with its grab-bag remit, has never acquired expertise in patent jurisprudence. As a consequence, it has issued some bizarre software rulings.
The Latest on: Patent trolls
via Google News
The Latest on: Patent trolls
- Justin Bieber claims photo of him with friends ‘proves he did not rape a fan’on June 28, 2020 at 6:54 am
Two women took to Twitter last weekend to say that Justin Bieber sexually assaulted and raped them in 2014 and 2015 - the star, who has denied the allegations, now claims a photo proves his innocence ...
- California Judge May Dismiss Apple-Intel Antitrust Suit Targeting Patent Trollon June 22, 2020 at 9:11 pm
The DOJ recently joined the lawsuit on the side of Fortress, a patent aggregator sued by Apple and Intel on antitrust grounds.
- Ask Hackaday: SawStop — Bastion Of Safety Or Patent Trollon June 21, 2020 at 5:01 pm
This has earned some bad press for SawStop in forums and on websites like Reddit, where users have gone as far as to call SawStop a patent troll. Is that true or just Internet puffery? Read on and ...
- Be Wary of Patent Trolls in European Medtechon June 17, 2020 at 5:00 pm
Patent trolls aren't only a U.S. phenomenon. Two legal experts discuss why nonpracticing entities have impacted medical device companies doing business in Europe and ways to defend against such ...
- Slide-to-unlock patent battles continue – this time Apple on the other sideon June 15, 2020 at 5:02 am
The Slide-to-unlock patent battles continue, long after the company ceased using the original UI, perhaps given new life by a variation on the theme ...
- Apple is Requesting that the Court Invalidate two Patents being used against them in a Long-Standing Patent Disputeon June 14, 2020 at 6:11 am
Patently Apple posted a report titled " One of the Most Compelling Legal Cases Filed against Apple in Years was filed in California Yesterday." Since that time Apple had the patents invalidated but ...
- AI Patent Trolls Now On The Job For Drug Companieson June 12, 2020 at 5:00 pm
Patent applications are meticulously crafted to keep the competition at bay for as long as possible, which is why it often takes ages for cheaper generic versions of blockbuster medications to hit ...
- Startups Can Now Buy Insurance Against Patent Trollson June 9, 2020 at 6:30 am
Probably the worst thing about America's very broken patent system is the existence of patent trolls: companies that own intellectual property for the sole purpose of using it to sue other ...
- White House proposals to fight patent trolls called laughably inadequateon June 4, 2020 at 5:00 pm
Much like spammers, Satanists and mimes, patent trolls are one of the rare groups around that Americans of all political stripes can unite in opposing. But although the White House on Tuesday ...
- How Carbonite, EMC Beat a Patent Troll Tied to Intellectual Ventureson June 2, 2020 at 5:00 pm
Those companies are known as “patent trolls” because of their singular money-harvesting goal. In its latest report, This American Life follows up on a company called Oasis Research ...
via Bing News