New management is needed for the planet’s most important common resource
IN 1968 an American ecologist, Garrett Hardin, published an article entitled “The Tragedy of the Commons”. He argued that when a resource is held jointly, it is in individuals’ self-interest to deplete it, so people will tend to undermine their collective long-term interest by over-exploiting rather than protecting that asset. Such a tragedy is now unfolding, causing serious damage to a resource that covers almost half the surface of the Earth.
The high seas—the bit of the oceans that lies beyond coastal states’ 200-mile exclusive economic zones—are a commons. Fishing there is open to all. Countries have declared minerals on the seabed “the common heritage of mankind”. The high seas are of great economic importance to everyone—fish is a more important source of protein than beef—and getting more so. The number of patents using DNA from sea-creatures is rocketing, and one study suggests that marine life is a hundred times more likely to contain material useful for anti-cancer drugs than is terrestrial life.
Yet the state of the high seas is deteriorating (see article). Arctic ice now melts away in summer. Dead zones are spreading. Two-thirds of the fish stocks in the high seas are over-exploited, even more than in the parts of the oceans under national control. And strange things are happening at a microbiological level. The oceans produce half the planet’s supply of oxygen, mostly thanks to chlorophyll in aquatic algae. Concentrations of that chlorophyll are falling. That does not mean life will suffocate. But it could further damage the climate, since less oxygen means more carbon dioxide.
For tragedies of the commons to be averted, rules and institutions are needed to balance the short-term interests of individuals against the long-term interests of all users. That is why the dysfunctional policies and institutions governing the high seas need radical reform.
The first target should be fishing subsidies. Fishermen, who often occupy an important place in a country’s self-image, have succeeded in persuading governments to spend other people’s money subsidising an industry that loses billions and does huge environmental damage. Rich nations hand the people who are depleting the high seas $35 billion a year in cheap fuel, insurance and so on. The sum is over a third of the value of the catch. That should stop.
Second, there should be a global register of fishing vessels. These have long been exempt from an international scheme that requires passenger and cargo ships to carry a unique ID number. Last December maritime nations lifted the exemption—a good first step. But it is still up to individual countries to require fishing boats flying their flag to sign up to the ID scheme. Governments should make it mandatory, creating a global record of vessels to help crack down on illegal high-seas fishing. Somalis are not the only pirates out there.
The Latest on: Tragedy of the high seas
via Google News
The Latest on: Tragedy of the high seas
- Netherlands mourns as bodies of five surfers recoveredon May 12, 2020 at 10:37 am
The Netherlands is in shock after the bodies of five surfers, all believed to have been in their 20s or 30s, were recovered from the North Sea following a two-day search-and-rescue operation that ...
- NTSB blames captain, bad safety culture for loss of El Faroon May 6, 2020 at 5:00 pm
“I hope that this tragedy at sea can serve as a lighthouse ... Whether the crew could have survived Joaquin’s punishing winds and high seas had the El Faro been equipped with the closed ...
- UN voices concern following Caribbean boat tragedyon May 4, 2020 at 5:00 pm
we have seen increasing numbers of desperate people fleeing dire levels of economic deprivation or escaping political turmoil and violence by taking to the high seas in search of safety or a ...
- Summer books: the best fictionon May 2, 2020 at 5:00 pm
You know how it ends, but it’s like watching a glass shatter in slow motion — Mantel handles the tragedy with brilliance and the dark shadows at the end point to where the blade will fall ...
- Melbourne survivor Stephanie Browitt describes White Island volcano tragedyon April 28, 2020 at 6:20 am
A Melbourne survivor of last year’s New Zealand volcano tragedy has described the agonising ... Cruise ship Ovation of the Seas in Sydney after the tragic events on White Island, New Zealand.
- Bangladesh urged to open ports to allow in Rohingya refugee boatson April 27, 2020 at 12:34 am
More than 500 stranded on trawlers in what UN calls ‘human tragedy of terrible proportions’ ...
- Victims' families to sue Royal Caribbean cruises over New Zealand White Island volcano tragedyon April 26, 2020 at 5:45 pm
Victims of the White Island volcano tragedy are suing Royal Caribbean in ... 19 had been on-board the Ovations of the Seas cruise ship and booked to tour the island with Royal Caribbean.
- Tragedy at seaon April 25, 2020 at 5:00 pm
The captain of the ship, having called for coffee, and noticing unusually calm seas, ordered the mess steward who brought the coffee to stand watch on the bridge while the captain retired to his cabin ...
- Death on the high seas; the mysterious death of a humble fishing observeron April 11, 2020 at 5:00 pm
The father-of-four is the tenth Pacific fisheries observer to die on the lawless high seas in the last decade. The tragedy has sparked a call for more protection for this vulnerable workforce ...
- Tragedy in high season September 24, 2015 at 10:16 pm
The number of immigrants who lost their lives trying to cross the Mediterranean is staggeringly high. According to the ... this human tragedy will remain with us for decades to come, unless ...
via Bing News