They point to the past decade’s massive investments in cognitive neuroscience as a potential bubble
Fashions in research funding, reward structures in universities and streamlining of scientific agendas undermine traditional academic norms and may result in science bubbles. Research from the University of Copenhagen, which has just been published in the journal Philosophy and Technology, shows how the mechanisms that set off the financial crisis might be replicating in the field of science.
“In finance, the first condition for a bubble occurs when too much liquidity is concentrated on too few assets. The second is the presence of speculators. In science, similarly, if too much research funding is focused on too few research topics, and all researchers speculate in the same fashionable scientific templates to attract funding, a potential science bubble may be forming,” explains professor of Formal Philosophy Vincent F. Hendricks from University of Copenhagen.
In the article “Science Bubbles” just published in Philosophy and Technology, professor Vincent F. Hendricks and postdoc David Budtz Pedersen trace the mechanisms that can result in science bubbles. They point to the past decade’s massive investments in cognitive neuroscience as a potential bubble – culminating with President Obama’s recent endorsement of the one billion dollar Brain Activity Map Project and the European Commission’s 500 million euro Human Brain Project.
“These investments have been preceded by a dramatic rise in fields that attach ‘neuro’ to some human behaviour or trait with promises that the techniques of neuroscience will explain it – and into game-changing explanations of the human mind,” Budtz Pedersen says and adds that studies have shown that peer reviewers and lay citizens are more likely to find explanations of e.g. psychological phenomena more convincing when they contain neuroscientific information, even when it is not relevant to the explanation.
Incentive structures pull researchers in the same direction
Budtz Pedersen and Hendricks show how the ‘breakthroughs’ and’ turning points’ promised by many neuroscience projects – when combined with the fact that recent studies indicate a number of neuroscience publications seem to lack the statistical power to back their findings – have the potential to become a fully-fledged science bubble. In other words: the value of the neuroscientific promises and the investments made in them may turn out to bear no relation to the actual value of the scientific results.
A central cause of this is, according to Budtz Pedersen and Hendricks, the institutional design and incentive structures within science funding and research management, where traditional scientific incentives such as academic capital and reputation are being replaced by monetary incentives and competition.
“Numerous international studies of research management document how many Western universities have set up financial incentives and reward systems to encourage researchers to publish in high-impact journals on popular topics that generate research funding. This means that researchers often will have very little interest in spending time on problems that break away from mainstream or do not lead to publishable results, and they will tend to they dress their research claims up in ways that appeal to policy makers and external evaluators,” Professor Hendricks points out.
The Latest Google Headlines on:
World Wide Web
The Latest Bing News on:
World Wide Web
- Infrastructure as a Service Market to See Huge Growth by 2025 : Amazon Web Services, Google, Microsofton November 27, 2020 at 12:12 pm
This press release was orginally distributed by SBWire Edison, NJ -- ( SBWIRE) -- 11/27/2020 -- Global Infrastructure as a service Market Report 2020 is latest research study released by AMA ...
- Tracing the growth of the World Wide Webon November 20, 2020 at 12:20 pm
Now entering its third decade of existence, the Web has grown from simply a way to find and edit information to something beyond what its inventor Tim Berners-Lee had intended.
- NewsFeed – 30 years of the world wide web, what will the next 30 years bring?on November 19, 2020 at 6:03 am
TRT World’s original documentaries feature stories of culture, history, politics, and lifestyle. Various perspectives of a story are presented to enrich the narrative. Here are captivating digital ...
- Invisible Web Search Engines to access the Deep Webon November 19, 2020 at 4:36 am
Google can't find everything. To access the Invisible Web, you need some special search engines. Here are 5 Search Engines to access the Dark and Deep Web.
- Back To When It All Started: 3 Decades Of The World Wide Webon November 12, 2020 at 2:12 am
GREENE: That's British computer scientist Tim Berners-Lee describing his biggest invention, the World Wide Web. NOEL KING, HOST: On this day in 1990, Berners-Lee submitted a proposal for this ...
- Back To When It All Started: 3 Decades Of The World Wide Webon November 12, 2020 at 2:11 am
Back To When It All Started: 3 Decades Of The World Wide Web Thursday marks 30 years since computer scientist Tim Berners-Lee submitted his formal proposal for a new idea: the World Wide Web. At ...
- How world wide web inventor Tim Berners-Lee plans to break Big Tech's chokehold on your personal dataon November 9, 2020 at 1:03 pm
Sir Tim Berners-Lee, who invented the World Wide Web, is on a mission to redesign it. On Monday, Inrupt, cofounded by Berners-Lee, announced it was a step closer to realizing his ambition of ...
- Inventor of the World Wide Web wants to ensure you have total control over your dataon November 9, 2020 at 11:22 am
After launching his new startup three years ago, World Wide Web founder Sir Tim Berners-Lee has announced that the enterprise version of Inrupt's Solid Server is now available. Inrupt was created ...
- World wide web inventor launches privacy platform for enterprises; NHS and BBC sign upon November 9, 2020 at 8:55 am
Lee, known as the inventor of the world wide web, has revealed that his start-up Inrupt has launched a privacy platform for enterprises.
- How the world worked before the World Wide Webon October 29, 2020 at 2:42 pm
The World Wide Web has indeed brought us many benefits, but there was a time when humans survived without it and its perks. So how did people carry out tasks like research information or paying ...
The Latest Google Headlines on:
Contract for the Web
The Latest Bing News on:
Contract for the Web
- The best Black Friday broadband deals: Free £110 MasterCard w/ BT's 67Mb for £31.99/m (3 months free)on November 27, 2020 at 4:31 am
Searching the web for a good broadband deal, ahead of Black Friday? Perhaps with more speed at a better price, now that you're working from home? Then let us help you out as we round up the top ...
- NBA rumors: Real Madrid's Gabriel Deck leaving for the NBA?on November 27, 2020 at 3:23 am
Real Madrid lost star guard Facu Campazzo to the NBA (the Denver Nuggets to be specific) and there is a reported possibility that this may also happen with another player of the team. According to ...
- UFCW ignores strike vote by West Virginia Kroger workers, pushes through sellout agreementon November 26, 2020 at 5:07 pm
The contract rammed through by the United Food and Commercial Workers would impose lower wages and higher health care costs onto essential workers in the middle of the COVID-19 pandemic.
- General Dynamics Information Technology Awarded $241 Million Multi-Cloud Contract by Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Serviceson November 25, 2020 at 8:05 am
PRNewswire/ -- General Dynamics Information Technology (GDIT), a business unit of General Dynamics (NYSE:GD), announced today it has been awarded a ...
- Comodo and Multi-Visions (Canada) Enter into Distribution Agreement for North Americaon November 24, 2020 at 8:50 am
News Direct--Comodo, the world’s leader of next-generation cybersecurity announced a distribution partnership with Multi-Visions (Canada) for North America. Together Comodo an ...
- Industry Pro Newsletter: A SAG-AFTRA/AEA Agreement, the Long Road to Recovery, and Introducing Stage Mag from BroadwayWorld!on November 23, 2020 at 8:13 am
Happy Thanksgiving week to our readers in the United States! With continued news about the development of an effective vaccine and the conversation turning to how the vaccine will be deployed globally ...
- Orange Business Services Forms Global Strategic Collaboration Agreement with Amazon Web Services to Accelerate Customers’ Innovation in the Cloudon November 23, 2020 at 6:01 am
Orange Business Services has announced a global strategic collaboration agreement with Amazon Web Services (AWS) to help enterprises accelerate their digital transformation and leverage the benefits ...
- The significance of the Regional Economic Partnership Agreementon November 20, 2020 at 1:24 pm
Massimiliano Calì examines the significance of the Regional Economic Partnership Agreement, the world's largest trading bloc.
- CIA makes awards for intelligence community's next massive cloud contracton November 20, 2020 at 12:02 pm
The CIA takes the next step in its own and the intelligence community’s commercial cloud computing journey with the award of its so-called C2E contract that could be worth billions in totality.
- Accenture Federal Services Wins Federal Retirement Thrift Investment Board Contract to Improve Retirement Outcomes for Civil Service and Military 401Kon November 19, 2020 at 1:59 pm
Accenture was awarded the Recordkeeping Services Acquisition contract by the Federal Retirement Thrift Investment Board.