Good teachers have a surprisingly big impact on their pupils’ future income
THERE are few policy questions to which improving the quality of education is not a reasonable answer. Yet assessing teachers is far from straightforward. Pupils’ grades or test scores may reflect any of a host of influences, not just the standard of instruction. Neither can one take for granted that good teaching, however it is measured, will translate into better lives for its recipients. In two new working papers , Raj Chetty and John Friedman of Harvard University and Jonah Rockoff of Columbia University deploy some statistical wizardry to tease out the value of teaching (see sources below). Good teachers, they find, are worth their weight in gold.
School systems often try to assess the quality of their teachers by measuring “value added”: the effect a given teacher has on pupils’ test scores. Research is divided on whether this makes sense. Critics reckon that pupils with particular backgrounds—from richer families, for instance, or with more attentive parents—wind up in classrooms with better teachers. If so, the teachers who excel in assessments of value added may simply be teaching more privileged pupils. Messrs Chetty, Friedman and Rockoff try first to settle this debate.
To do so, the economists draw on a substantial data-set from a large, urban American school district, which they do not name. It covers 20 years of results and takes in more than 2.5m pupils. The data include teacher assignments and their pupils’ test scores from third to eighth grade (ages eight to 14, roughly speaking). The authors dig into the mountain of numbers to calculate the effect each teacher has on their pupils’ performance, after adjusting for demography and previous test scores. Previous scores, they reckon, do a good job of capturing the various external influences pupils bring to the classroom, from how well-nourished they are to how good their former teachers were. The authors also control for “drift”, or the fact that more recent test scores are better reflections of a teacher’s effectiveness than older ones, perhaps because the quality of an individual’s teaching tends to change a bit over time. In the end they produce a value-added score for every teacher in their sample.
The researchers then go hunting for bias: the possibility that good teacher scores actually reflect the lucky circumstances of their pupils. Using data from income-tax records, the authors show that the characteristics of pupils’ parents, such as family income, do not generally predict how teachers perform. They also use changes in the average quality of a school’s teaching staff from year to year (from the movement of a particularly good teacher to a different school, for instance) to check their findings. When the average quality of teachers in fourth grade falls from one year to the next, for example, the performance of the fourth-graders also drops as expected.
A bias-free measure of teacher quality allows the economists to wring fascinating conclusions from their data-set. They find, for instance, that the quality of teachers varies much more within schools than among them: a typical school has teachers spanning 85% of the spectrum for the school system as a whole. Not only do teachers matter, in other words, but the best teachers are not generally clumped within particular schools.
Go deeper with Bing News on:
- Seaford High School Teachers, Admins Hold Car Parade: PHOTOSon May 13, 2020 at 4:03 pm
Seaford High School students lined up along Waverly Avenue on May 8 to see their teachers, who drove around the district in a car parade. (Photos courtesy of the Seaford School District.) SEAFORD, NY ...
- Hillsborough Schools to slash 129 jobs. Teachers, for now, are sparedon May 13, 2020 at 2:34 pm
Superintendent Addison Davis said the job cuts include some supervisors, management positions, technicians and engineers.
- Guest opinion: Should we scrap standardized testing? This former teacher thinks soon May 13, 2020 at 11:00 am
School closures curbed standardized tests for Utah schools this spring. But the temporary pause could lead a transition to more effective ways to gauge student progress.
- I'm a Puppy Trainer, and These Are My Top Tips For Teaching Your Puppy Good Behavioron May 13, 2020 at 10:25 am
When my parents first moved my sister and me to Seattle, they finally caved on the one thing she had wanted for years: a dog. Their worry over whether we would ...
- Our two new Facebook groups, newsletters bring you school news, good newson May 13, 2020 at 10:10 am
Join our two new Facebook groups, Suburban Teachers and Good News from the Suburbs, and sign up for our two new corresponding newsletters.
Go deeper with Google Headlines on:
Go deeper with Bing News on:
- University Learning, Teaching and Assessment Strategy 2018-2023on May 13, 2020 at 2:47 pm
A De Montfort University (DMU) degree is a degree for life. We aim to equip all students, whatever their level and mode of study, with the knowledge required for successful transition to their next ...
- Gavin Williamson’s Scientific Adviser Says He Didn't Make Assessment Of School Reopening Planson May 13, 2020 at 10:35 am
The Department for Education’s own chief scientific adviser stunned MPs by revealing he had not made an assessment of plans to reopen English schools amid the Covid-19 crisis. Osama Rahman suggested ...
- Would Leaving Cert students' estimates of their own grades help teachers?on May 13, 2020 at 10:26 am
The idea is democratic and would show we trust young adults to be responsibly involved in a process that will have a major impact on their futures ...
- Changes to student, teacher requirements for 2019-2020 school year approvedon May 13, 2020 at 9:39 am
The West Virginia State Board of Education approved changes relating to the 2019-2020 school year and COVID-19.
- Teacher unions upset over Motshekga's 'rush to announce school dates'on May 12, 2020 at 1:00 pm
With Angie Motshekga expected to announce on Thursday when schools will officially reopen, five teacher unions are still at loggerheads with the Basic Education minister.