Marcus Ranum wrote “Information security’s response to bitter failure, in any area of endeavour, is to try the same thing that didn’t work — only harder.”
It seems that this often applies to the entire security field, not just IT. Here’s a timely example.
There have been calls, in the wake of April’s bombing at the Boston Marathon, for increased surveillance of Americans — already, arguably, the most-surveilled and most spied-on citizens on the planet, to such an extent that ex-Stasi staff are likely envious. In particular, there have been calls for mass (camera) surveillance from police department officials in Boston and New York City.
These recommendations clearly raise serious issues about privacy and the Constitution and the values we hold as a society. Others have written about those issues more eloquently than I can. But let me break from their approach and point out something on a much more pragmatic level:
It didn’t work.
Let me ask you to consider for a moment the Boston Marathon and all the video/still cameras that were focused on it, the ones whose images were in front of the nation nonstop for days. Anyone who’s run in or been to a major distance running event knows that there are cameras everywhere. There are race operation cameras at the start and finish. There are TV news cameras, all over the course — some fixed, some mobile. There are family/friends of runners and other spectators, concentrated at the start and finish, but scattered everywhere along the course, and nearly all of them have cameras. There are official and unofficial race photographers in multiple locations who try to grab still shots of every runner and then offer them for sale afterwards. There are even some runners wearing cameras from time to time. And then of course there are all the now-ubiquitous cameras on stores, banks, parking garages, traffic signs, and on all kinds of other structures along the way.
We don’t know why the those responsible for the attack in Boston did it; but what we do know is that the attack required a modicum of planning and intelligence: they weren’t entirely stupid. I submit that there is no possible way that they did not know that the finish area of a major marathon is one of the most heavily-photographed areas of the planet on the day of the event. Yet they not only selected it as their target, they made no attempt at all to evade the massive number of lenses focused on it.
Thousands of cameras equated to zero deterrent value.
Yes, those cameras certainly helped identify and locate the suspects: but that is cold consolation to those who lost life and limb, because they didn’t actually prevent the attack. The upcoming prosecution of Dzhokhar Tsarnaev, while it might yield some answers to troubling questions, is not going to help local runner Carol Downing’s daughters (Nicole Gross suffered two broken legs; Erika Brannock lost part of one of hers) recover and rehab and go on with their lives.
A thousand more, ten thousand more, a hundred thousand more cameras would not help: cameras have no deterrent value to people who are prepared to die and/or don’t care if they’re identified.
There also remains the distinct, disturbing possibility that the attackers chose the locationbecause they knew it was so thoroughly covered with cameras. An attack like this is clearly directed at those present, but if its real purpose is, as Bruce Schneier observes, to attack the minds of hundreds of millions elsewhere, then it can only reach its targets if the event is heavily documented and widely disseminated.
To put that point another way: it’s entirely possible that adding cameras to a particular location will decrease public safety — because it may make that location more attractive to those who want to make certain their attacks are captured on video and of course, dutifully replayed in slow-motion thousands of times by 24×7 news networks with many hours of airtime to fill.
Go deeper with Bing News on:
Spying on the public
- The Paladin: A Spy Novelon May 31, 2020 at 6:06 am
In addition to the writing process itself, an aspiring espionage author needs to stay abreast of a dynamic geopolitical landscape, evolving technological spectrum, and the appetites of a fickle ...
- Feds Used a Military Surveillance Predator Drone to Spy on Minneapolis BLM Protestorson May 30, 2020 at 7:12 am
U.S. Customs and Border Patrol (CBP) flew an unarmed Predator surveillance drone over Minneapolis to help police monitor protestors around the city. Essentially, the federal government used ...
- This is How the CIA Shark-Proofed their U-2 and A-12 Spy Pilotson May 28, 2020 at 9:14 am
The CIA’s shark net was essentially a large bag with a rubberized hose around the edge that could be inflated. Once buoyant, downed spies jumped inside and filled the bad to the brim with water and ...
- The SPY Finally Makes A Move Above The 200-Day EMA (Technically Speaking For 5/26)on May 26, 2020 at 3:38 pm
The California economy has cratered from the lockdown. Cities are closing off streets, allowing restaurants to put tables in formally public thoroughfares. The ...
- When U-2 Spy Planes Landed on an Aircraft Carrieron May 26, 2020 at 8:20 am
The venerable U-2 spy plane is an old bird. The first U-2s entered service with the United States in 1955 and are still flown today, due to extensive modifications. The large spy planes are easily ...
Go deeper with Google Headlines on:
Spying on the public
Go deeper with Bing News on:
- Debate on surveillance and privacy intensifies as US protests rageon June 1, 2020 at 11:13 pm
Chaotic demonstrations over race and policing that swept through the United States over the past week have fuelled a debate over the growing use of surveillance technology by security forces in ...
- ‘Financial Surveillance’ or ‘Blockchain Analysis’? Human Rights Foundation Debates Ellipticon June 1, 2020 at 6:58 pm
Blockchain analysis is "a euphemism" for surveillance, HRF Director Alex Gladstein told Elliptic's Tom Robinson during a debate on crypto tracing Monday.
- Surveillance Video Shows B Fresh Store At 55th And Wenworth Looted, Cleaned Outon June 1, 2020 at 12:35 pm
Surveillance video shared with CBS 2 shows dozens of people looting inside the B Fresh clothing store at 55th and Wentworth on Sunday.
- Debate on surveillance and privacy heats up as U.S. protests rageon June 1, 2020 at 11:29 am
Chaotic protests over race have fueled a debate over growing use of surveillance technology by security forces ...
- BCA investigators in George Floyd killing sought access to police training and medical records, surveillance footageon June 1, 2020 at 11:28 am
State investigators looking into the killing of George Floyd have requested the training records of all the former Minneapolis officers who were present, as well as access to surveillance footage that ...