Before the digital age, neuroscientists got their information in the library like the rest of us.
But the field’s explosion has created nearly 2 million papers — more data than any researcher can read and absorb in a lifetime.
That’s why a UCLA team has invented research maps. Equipped with an online app, the maps help neuroscientists quickly scan what is already known and plan their next study. The Aug. 8 edition of Neuron describes the findings.
“Information overload is the elephant in the room that most neuroscientists pretend to ignore,” explained principal investigator Alcino Silva, a professor of neurobiology at the David Geffen School of Medicine at UCLA and of psychiatry at the Semel Institute for Neuroscience and Human Behavior. “Without a way to organize the literature, we risk missing key discoveries and duplicating earlier experiments. Research maps will enable neuroscientists to quickly clarify what ground has already been covered and to fully grasp its meaning for future studies.”
Silva collaborated with Anthony Landreth, a former UCLA postdoctoral fellow, to create maps offering simplified, interactive and unbiased summaries of findings designed to help neuroscientists in choosing what to study next. As a testing ground for their maps, the team focused on findings in molecular and cellular cognition.
UCLA programmer Darin Gilbert Nee also created a web-based app to help scientists expand and interact with their field’s map.
“We founded research maps on a crowd-sourcing strategy in which individual scientists add papers that interest them to a growing map of their fields,” explained Silva, who started working on the problem nearly 30 years ago as a graduate student, and coauthored with Landreth an upcoming Oxford Press book on the subject. “Each map is interactive and searchable; scientists see as much of the map as they query, much like an online search.”
According to Silva, the map allows scientists to zero in and out of areas that interest them. By tracking published findings, researchers can determine what’s missing and pinpoint worthwhile experiments to pursue.
“Just as a GPS map offers different levels of zoom, a research map would allow a scientist to survey a specific research area at different levels of resolution –from coarse summaries to fine-grained accounts of experimental results,” said Silva. “The map would display no more and no less detail than is necessary for the researcher’s purposes.”
Each map encodes information by classifying it into categories and scoring the weight of its evidence based on key criteria, such as reproducibility and convergence, when different experiments point to a single conclusion.
The team’s next step will be to automate the map creation process. As scientists publish papers, their findings will automatically be added to the research map representing their field.
According to Silva, automation could be achieved by using journals’ existing publication process to divide an article’s findings into smaller chapters to build nano-publications. Publishers would use a software plug-in to render future papers machine-readable.
A more direct approach would add special fields into the templates for journal article submission. The data resulting from these fields could be published to a public database, which would provide the foundation for research maps.
“Western societies invest an enormous amount into science, and research maps will optimize that investment,” observed Silva. “One day, we will look back on the pre-map era of experiment planning with the same incredulity we now reserve for research conducted prior to statistics.”
The Latest on: Science information overload
- How ‘mindful AI’ is about designing for human behaviour and aspirations - Ovetta Sampson, Principal Creative Director, Microsofton November 2, 2019 at 1:39 am
YourStory: In a world of information overload and unending distractions ... understand their motivations and behaviour. The art and science of design research is where this lives.
- 5 Steps for Bringing Mindfulness to Your Classroomon October 30, 2019 at 1:16 pm
In a world of digital distraction and information overload, we are constantly pulled away from the ... And I think it should be included in every teacher’s toolbox. As a public school science teacher ...
- AI2’s Semantic Scholar search engine now takes in the full sweep of scientific paperson October 23, 2019 at 3:00 pm
The database not only covers the time-honored physical sciences, but also political science and sociology, art and philosophy. “That’s enabled us to take the research that we’ve done in making AI a ...
- The brain may actively forget during dream sleepon September 20, 2019 at 5:55 am
said Thomas Kilduff, Ph.D., director of the Center for Neuroscience at SRI International, Menlo Park, California, and a senior author of the study published in Science ... REM sleep may prevent ...
- Information overloadon July 8, 2019 at 2:57 am
PUNE: Technology sure has changed our lives. What do you do when you want some information? Surf the net. What do you do when you are simply hanging l Open in app + English ...
- Why Science Says Boredom Is Good for the Brainon June 25, 2019 at 2:38 pm
At the ISTE 2019 conference in Philadelphia, Zomorodi spoke about the Bored and Brilliant challenge, as well as information overload, how her listeners responded and why science says boredom is ...
- Information overload and the science of procrastinationon March 1, 2019 at 2:42 pm
The sheer volume of options that we face in this age of information overload nearly guarantees that we won’t finish everything. But when the December break comes, we may find that we’ve at least ...
- AI effective to tackle information overload: Zhihu CTOon February 25, 2019 at 2:46 am
Li Dahai told Xinhua on the sidelines of the Oxford China Forum that he believes information overload makes the real valuable information ... as technological innovation ability and fundamental ...
- AI effective to tackle information overload: Zhihu CTOon February 25, 2019 at 1:37 am
Artificial Intelligence (AI) could be the most effective way to deal with the challenge of information overload, the chief technology officer ... as technological innovation ability and fundamental ...
- Information overload study we covered has been retractedon January 10, 2019 at 8:15 am
January 10, 2019: In 2017, we covered a study that suggested information overload may be responsible for the viral spread of faulty information. The study was based on a mix of modeling of artificial ...
via Google News and Bing News