An anonymous stranger you encounter on websites like Yelp or Amazon may seem to be just like you, and a potential friend. But a stranger on a site like eBay is a whole different story.
A new study finds that on websites where people compete against each other, assumptions about strangers change.
Previous research has shown that people have a bias toward thinking that strangers they encounter online are probably just like them.
But when they are competitors, strangers are seen as different, and not sharing your traits and values — and that changes how people act, said Rebecca Walker Naylor, co-author of the study and assistant professor of marketing at The Ohio State University‘s Fisher College of Business.
“When you’re competing against people you don’t know, you actually bid much more aggressively than you might normally, because you assume that these strangers aren’t similar to you,” she said.
“You feel you have the license to bid aggressively because the other bidders aren’t like you and you don’t have to be nice to them.”
Naylor said the results should serve as a caution for people who shop on auction sites like eBay.
“You need to be aware that, whether you mean to or not, you will naturally see other anonymous bidders as different from you. That will get the competitive juices flowing and you might end up paying more than you really want,” she said.
Their findings appear in the August 2013 issue of the Journal of Consumer Research.
In several related experiments, the researchers conducted simulated online auctions in which people thought they were bidding for products like a popular energy drink. In some cases, the study participants knew they were similar — or dissimilar — from the people they were bidding against, while other times they didn’t know anything about their competitors.
In one study, college students were told they would be bidding on a bottle of Five Hour Energy Drink. They were then shown one of three profiles of a “representative” bidder they were competing against. In one profile, the bidder was demographically similar to the participant. A second profile featured a profile that was demographically different. The third profile was ambiguous, so these participants couldn’t tell how similar they were to their competition.
Before the bidding, the researchers primed some participants for competition by having them complete a word search involving words describing competition, such as “battle,” “challenge” and “contend.”
As expected, the participants’ bid was lowest — 75 cents — when they competed against someone similar to themselves. When they were bidding against people who were not like them, their high bid went up to $1.22.
But the bid was highest when the participant competed against an anonymous person — all the way to $1.28.
“They automatically assumed that if they didn’t know anything about this person they were bidding against, it must be someone who is not like them,” Naylor said. “That’s different from how people approach strangers on other websites.”
The results were confirmed in another study involving students from the University of South Carolina. Half the students were told they would be bidding on a site called “eBay Auctions,” while the other half were told they were bidding on the site “Gamecock Auctions.” The mascot of South Carolina is the Gamecocks, so participants were given the impression that other bidders on that site were also likely affiliated with their university.
They were then given profiles of a competing bidder who was similar, dissimilar or ambiguous.
Results showed that participants were least aggressive in their bidding against similar competitors and most aggressive against dissimilar competitors, regardless of which website they were on.
When it came to the ambiguous competitors whom they didn’t know much about, participants competed aggressively against their rival on eBay, but not so much if the bidding occurred on Gamecock Auctions.
In fact, the researchers asked participants to rate how similar they were to their competing bidder. When they didn’t have much information on their competitor, they still rated themselves as similar when they competed on Gamecock Auctions. But they rated these ambiguous competitors as dissimilar when they were on eBay.
The Latest on: How People View Strangers Online
- Puzzling Design: How to Make an Escape Roomon September 9, 2019 at 8:40 am
Escape rooms have become one of the most sought-after activities to do with a group of friends, family or even strangers. There’s a lot of mystery ... It also helps with making people believe that ...
- The online privacy checklist your kids need you to haveon September 9, 2019 at 8:39 am
Here’s a checklist to help you better manage your child’s online presence. Tell friends and family about your privacy wishes. Most of the people in our lives won ... you can be the first to see when ...
- After ‘It Chapter Two’ and ‘Stranger Things,’ Finn Wolfhard is an accidental horror staron September 9, 2019 at 8:15 am
Since the 16-year-old Canadian actor broke out in Netflix's sleeper hit "Stranger Things," he's been heavily in demand ... A: We watched a lot of YouTube videos of Russian politicians and different ...
- Slack, the chat app competing with Microsoft, is launching 'Slack 101,' an online classroom to teach newcomers how to use its appon September 9, 2019 at 8:04 am
From pinning messages to creating reminders, Slack 101 is an online course for users who are new to Slack. Here's why Slack is launching it.
- Video: Kind stranger named, 'Moses' returns wallet found in Tampa drivewayon September 9, 2019 at 7:54 am
(FOX 13) - A Tampa homeowner is grateful for a stranger who found a wallet in the driveway ... “Thank you, Moses. Not many people out there are like you, buddy.” Easterly said he hopes to track down ...
- Malcolm Gladwell on Talking to Strangers and how podcasting changed his approach to writingon September 9, 2019 at 6:13 am
With five New York Times best-sellers to his credit, one might assume Malcolm Gladwell would see no reason to ... I would like people to be a little more cautious and humble in the conclusions they ...
- Jesy Nelson 'starved' herself because of online bullieson September 9, 2019 at 1:00 am
The Little Mix singer has revealed the impact online bullies had on how she saw herself ... Then I'd binge eat, then hate myself... "I could see that I was losing weight and sometimes I'd see a few ...
- How To Prevent Online Car Insurance Scams With The Help Of Quoteson September 8, 2019 at 5:04 pm
LOS ANGELES, CA / ACCESSWIRE / September 8, 2019 / Compare-autoinsurance.org has launched a new blog post that explains how online quotes ... the most common scams. View photos Fake insurance ...
- How To Watch The Emmys 2019 Streamingon September 8, 2019 at 10:11 am
Either way, I can't wait to see what happens. If you do have cable ... In previous years, however, People and EW have had a pre-show streaming for free online via People TV ahead of the big event. Yes ...
- How Top-Valued Microsoft Has Avoided the Big Tech Backlashon September 8, 2019 at 7:13 am
The software giant, valued at more than $1 trillion by investors, is no stranger to government scrutiny and ... The law, which took effect last year, lets people request their online data and ...
via Google News and Bing News