Economic modelling shows that the possible methane emissions caused by shrinking sea ice from just one area of the Arctic could come with a global price tag of 60 trillion dollars – the size of the world economy in 2012.
As the Arctic warms and sea ice melts at an unprecedented rate, hitting a record low last summer, the thawing of offshore ‘permafrost’ – frozen soil – in the region is releasing methane, a powerful greenhouse gas.
Scientists have previously warned that there are vast reservoirs of methane in the Arctic, hundreds of billions of tonnes of a gas many times worse than carbon dioxide for global warming – of which only a fraction needs releasing into the atmosphere to trigger possibly catastrophic climate change.
Now, researchers from Cambridge and Rotterdam have for the first time calculated the potential economic impact of a scenario some scientists consider increasingly likely: that the methane below the East Siberian Sea will be emitted, either steadily over the next 30 years or in one giant “burp”.
Writing in the journal Nature, the academics say that just this area’s methane alone – some 50 billion tonnes, or 50 gigatonnes – would have a mean global impact of 60 trillion dollars, an amount very similar to the size of the entire global economy last year. Current US national debt stands at a mere 16 trillion dollars in comparison.
The economic impact modelled was only for the methane existing on the East Siberian Arctic Shelf, and “the total price of Arctic change will be much higher,” they warn.
“Arctic science is a strategic asset for human economies because the region drives critical effects in our biophysical, political and economic systems,” write the academics, who say that world leaders will “miss the bigger picture” without factoring in Arctic methane projections – as neither the World Economic Forum or the International Monetary Fund currently recognise the economic danger of Arctic change.
The new results were achieved using PAGE09, the latest version of the PAGE integrated assessment model developed by Dr Chris Hope from Cambridge Judge Business School. PAGE09 is currently used by the US Environmental Protection Agency, and an earlier version was used for the UK Government’s Stern Review in 2006 – the major report on climate change economics on which Hope was a specialist advisor.
For the latest research, Hope worked with Gail Whiteman, Professor of Sustainability at Erasmus University, and Cambridge’s Peter Wadhams, Professor of Ocean Physics, who has been studying the disappearance of Arctic ice for 40 years.
The three academics, who co-authored today’s Nature Comment article, built the projections on previous fieldwork in the region by Dr Natalia Shakhova and colleagues from the International Arctic Research Center at the University of Alaska, described by Wadhams as “the only people with the geological knowledge to make estimates about methane emission in this area”.
The PAGE09 model was then employed to translate the extra methane emissions from the East Siberian Sea into global impacts by considering the huge range of environmental changes they might cause – from increasing global temperature and sea levels to consequent flooding, public health and extreme weather.
The model was run 10,000 times to assess the range of risks and provide robust results. The team insist that both the scientific predictions and economic modelling are far from worst-case scenarios, and that the figures represent the mean result from “the whole range of available science and economics”.
“That’s how the model works, how it was used for Stern and by the EPA, it’s the only way I’ll allow it to be used,” said Hope. “The model has to be run with broad ranges for the inputs, it’s not justifiable otherwise.”
“This is the first calculation of its kind that we know of,” he adds, “and we welcome anyone who wants to take this forward and build on it so we can have a discussion – but we don’t have long to discuss it! This is so big and if it happens it could happen fast; people need to wake up to the possible reality we face”.
“This is a warning to the world borne out of many decades of research on all our parts, including forty years of ice thinning measurements from UK submarines,” said Wadhams, “it is a considered statement with enormous implications”.
The Latest Bing News on:
Arctic methane release
- Thawing permafrost releases organic compounds into airon October 13, 2020 at 5:05 am
When permafrost thaws due to global warming, not only the greenhouse gases known to all, but also organic compounds are released from the soil. They ...
- U.S. Senator Dianne Feinstein Calls on Chevron to Support Strong Methane Emissions Regulations and Oppose Drilling in the Arcticon October 10, 2020 at 5:35 am
U.S. Senator Dianne Feinstein Calls on Chevron to Support Strong Methane Emissions Regulations and Oppose Drilling in the Arctic ...
- This World Is Burningon October 4, 2020 at 11:04 am
Although the worst threats from catastrophic climate change lie in the long-term future, we are starting to see the effects of climate change today.
- Our World Is Burningon October 3, 2020 at 5:55 am
Two time scales The central problem which the world faces in its attempts to avoid catastrophic climate change is a contrast of time scales. In order to save human civilization and the biosphere from ...
- Discharges from western North America disrupted climate during last ice ageon October 2, 2020 at 11:23 am
New research suggests ancient ice discharges from western North America into the Pacific triggered dramatic, hemispheric-scale shifts in the climate.
- Colossal crater found in Siberia. What made it?on September 26, 2020 at 10:24 am
The Arctic craters are not easy to study ... As microbes feast on organic matter in the talik, they release carbon dioxide or methane. Gases trapped deep under the permafrost can migrate up ...
- Arctic Sea Ice Loss: World Leaders Must Arrest Arctic Climate Change Impactson September 22, 2020 at 5:00 pm
The International Cryosphere Climate Initiative’s Iceblog reports that “fires in the Arctic in June released more carbon ... emissions of carbon dioxide, methane and black carbon coming ...
- The Unusual Connection Between Beavers, Permafrost And Climate Changeon September 22, 2020 at 8:54 am
When thawed, permafrost can release dangerous greenhouse gasses such as carbon and methane. University of ... creating dangerous oases around the Arctic. He's one of the authors of a recent ...
- Letter: New York is trying to save environment for generationson September 21, 2020 at 7:10 pm
6 Buffalo News that fit together: “Subterranean gases in Russia’s Arctic are exploding ... to a global emergency – including methane release in Russia – to save the planet for all ...
- Another Giant Crater Appears on Siberia's Arctic Tundraon September 18, 2020 at 5:21 am
In many Arctic regions, this permafrost is rich ... that more craters that are formed through the explosive release of methane will appear in the future. These craters—the latest of which ...
The Latest Google Headlines on:
Arctic methane release
The Latest Bing News on:
- Nitrogen fertilizer, N2O, farming, and a ‘worst case’ climate scenario; studyon October 13, 2020 at 12:23 pm
While most have heard about the great concern from carbon dioxide resulting from burning of fossil fuels, methane gas has become another concern, being released from thawing permafrost and from ...
- Start-up wants to do carbon capture on stale indoor air, turn it into fuelon October 13, 2020 at 9:42 am
Something like… carbon capture for an office HVAC system. Finnish start-up Soletair Power recently showed off a unit operating in its office over a video call. It had been built for the 2020 World ...
- Investors Face ESG Risk from Oil and Gas Facilities Operated by Third Partieson October 13, 2020 at 5:02 am
Global investors face significant environmental, social and governance risk stemming from a vast network of commercial oil and gas projects owned by the companies they hold shares in but which are ...
- Chevron Allies With Brightmark for Dairy Biomethane Projecton October 12, 2020 at 8:19 am
A unit of Chevron CVX announced a partnership with the waste management firm, Brightmark Energy, to manufacture and market dairy biomethane, which is a type of a renewable natural gas (“RNG”), ...
- Sick livestock up emissions and vice versaon October 12, 2020 at 7:52 am
The relationship between sick livestock with parasite diseases and climate change may be a "vicious cycle," say researchers.
- Duke Energy’s New ESG Plans Target Coal, Methane & Higher Dividendson October 10, 2020 at 10:15 am
The movement into environment, social and governance (ESG) is attracting billions and billions of investment dollars away from certain companies ...
- Duke Energy seeks net-zero methane by 2030on October 9, 2020 at 2:26 pm
A major energy company is seeking to reach net-zero methane emissions by 2030 in its gas business. Duke Energy, which provides energy in the South and Midwest, hopes that methane emissions from its ...
- Court strikes down Obama-era rule targeting methane leaks from public lands drillingon October 8, 2020 at 4:41 pm
A federal court on Thursday struck down an Obama-era regulation targeting methane leaks from drilling on public lands, arguing that it went beyond the scope of the Bureau of Land Management (BLM), ...
- GHGSat lauds performance of methane-monitoring satelliteon October 8, 2020 at 11:02 am
GHGSat, the Canadian firm preparing to launch a constellation of methane-monitoring satellites, announced Oct. 8 that the sensor on its Iris satellite launched in early September detects methane ...
- Smallest Methane Emission Ever Detected by Satelliteon October 8, 2020 at 6:20 am
GHGSat, the global leader in high resolution greenhouse gas monitoring from space, today announced the first results from its latest ...