Since we face outsized problems from burning fossil fuels, an atomic-sized solution, with few emissions and well understood risks, can seem attractive
A believer in solar power rarely has a good word to say about nuclear, though the sun generates light in a nuclear way via fusion. Of course, the zealotry works in the other direction as well. Almost any energy source boasts a cadre of ardent adherents: burning coal (it alleviates poverty!). Fracking for natural gas (we’re better than coal!) Wind turbines(the fuel is always free!) Even fusion here on Earth. If you don’t believe me,check the comments on this piece.
So it’s no surprise that energy has proven a wedge issue among those who strive to save the world. Now along comes a new, intriguing documentary entitled Pandora’s Promise that hits movie theaters on June 12 and promises to drive that wedge even deeper.
The story of the film is your basic conversion narrative, minus the conversion onscreen and geared to produce a hoped-for one in the audience. A band of five self-professed converts to the benefits of nuclear power—iconoclast Stewart Brand, author Gwyneth Cravens, climate activist Mark Lynas, nuclear weapons expert Richard Rhodes, and environmental thinker Michael Shellenberger—lay out their individual reasons for their newfound belief.
That newfound belief runs counter to that of the majority of environmentalists and environmental organizations from the beginnings of the movement in the 1970s. Much of that opposition stems from the original sin of nuclear power: it was used as a weapon first. Nuclear became synonymous with mushroom clouds at Hiroshima and Nagasaki and many other testing grounds and skies, mutually assured destruction, even nuclear winter and some kind of Armageddon, in the words of Whole Earth Catalog founder Brand.
What has cracked that catholic opposition for Brand and others is the invisible and invidious challenge of climate change. Simply put: nuclear power is one of the few technologies available today that can produce a lot of electricity, a lot of the time without a lot of greenhouse gases entering the atmosphere. To be anti-nuclear at this point means being for burning fossil fuels because energy sources such as solar and wind are too fickle and small to play a big role in providing clean electricity to the 7 billion people on the planet, according to this belief.
The film, through interviews with engineers and others, also notes that another original sin of nuclear power may have been the technology chosen by U.S. Admiral Hyman Rickover in the 1950s. The light water reactors the “Father of the Nuclear Navy” selected for commercial development may be simpler in design but they produce nuclear waste fairly rapidly and in quantity that still has no place to go. Safety is not an inherent feature of such reactors but instead has to be engineered around them with the cloak of containment vessels, redundant systems and other support and safety systems that add to the expense of nuclear power today. In fact, light water reactors are one of the few technologies to see little or no reduction in cost as more and more of them were built over the past several decades. Each one was, in essence, custom-designed to deal with the specific issues for a particular site and the specific version of the technology deployed.
That has left each reactor with its own unique flaws, as witnessed in the three nuclear catastrophes in Three Mile Island, Pennsylvania; Chernobyl, Ukraine; and Fukushima, Japan. Each reactor may be flawed in its own way, but the three milestone accidents did share one critical failing in common: the human factor. In all three, human oversight, omission, and/or flat-our error played a pivotal role in allowing the nuclear accidents to occur—so much so that engineers of new reactor systems have emphasized the removal of humans from their oversight in an accident entirely. So-called passive safety designs—such as the two new AP-1000 reactors being built at the Vogtle nuclear power plant in Georgia—require no human intervention to work. These systems intend to provide some insurance against human error leading to catastrophic meltdown.
And the world needs more and more power. Lifting hundreds of millions of Chinese people out of poverty in the last few decades required the construction of hundreds ofcoal-fired power plants, which has lead to China disappearing beneath a sulfurous haze of choking smog as well as surpassing the U.S. as the world leader in greenhouse gas pollution. Energy efficiency can’t save us from that, according to the Breakthrough Institute’s Shellenberger. As the global population heads toward 9 billion or even more potentially, energy use may double by 2050 and continue to increase. To stop adding yet more greenhouse gases to the atmosphere, all of that energy would have to be clean energy. And the only clean energy available is nuclear, according to Shellenberger and the other true believers of this film—in the absence of CO2 capture and storage for fossil fuel burners or some form of inexpensive electricity storage in the case of renewables like the wind and sun.
Size is an enduring totem for the proponents of nuclear power: the poster for the film above shows the actual size of the tiny cube of enriched uranium that could provide enough electricity for your entire life. And the filmmaker’s own conversion experience came when he visited the single room in France, the size of a basketball court, beneath which much of that nation’s nuclear waste is stored. Here is another size comparison: a pound of uranium contains as much energy as more than 2 million pounds of coal. Size matters and, since we face outsized problems from burning fossil fuels, an atomic-sized solution, with few emissions and well understood risks, can seem attractive.
That means we have to get over our overblown fears of radiation.
The Latest Bing News on:
- Iran's supreme leader vows revenge after top nuclear scientist apparently assassinatedon November 28, 2020 at 7:15 am
Iran's Supreme Leader Ayatollah Seyyed Ali Khamenei has vowed revenge and to continue the country's "scientific" activities after the killing of the country's chief nuclear scientist, as top Iranian ...
- Iran’s Top Nuclear Scientist Killed in Ambush, State Media Sayon November 28, 2020 at 6:04 am
U.S. and Israeli intelligence described the scientist, Mohsen Fakhrizadeh, as the force behind what they call Iran’s covert push for nuclear weapons.
- Vanderbilt's Fuller could become 1st woman to play in Power 5 football gameon November 28, 2020 at 5:48 am
Sarah Fuller, a goalkeeper for Vanderbilt women's soccer team, is suiting up for the Commodore football Saturday. If she sees game action as a kicker during Vanderbilt's SEC showdown with Missouri, ...
- Iran scientist linked to military nuclear program killedon November 28, 2020 at 5:03 am
The killing risks further raising tensions across the Mideast, nearly a year after Iran and the U.S. stood on the brink of war when an American drone strike killed a top Iranian general in Baghdad.
- Iran scientist's assassination appears intended to undermine nuclear dealon November 27, 2020 at 11:52 am
Analysis: shooting of Mohsen Fakhrizadeh will do more harm to diplomacy than it does to Iran’s nuclear programme ...
- MPs attack ‘lack of knowledge’ over UK nuclear power clean-upon November 26, 2020 at 4:04 pm
MPs have warned there is a “perpetual” lack of knowledge in government about the state of Britain’s 17 earliest nuclear power sites, which are expected to cost taxpayers about £130bn to clean up over ...
- United States Nuclear Power Plant Equipment Report 2020-2025 - ResearchAndMarkets.comon November 24, 2020 at 8:58 am
Growth, Trends, and Forecasts (2020 - 2025)” report has been added to ResearchAndMarkets.com’s offering. The United States nuclear power plant equipment market is expected to grow at a CAGR of more ...
- Nuclear to Cost U.K. $900 Million a Year More Than Flexi Poweron November 23, 2020 at 2:23 pm
Building a new large nuclear plant alongside renewable power would cost the U.K. as much as 660 million pounds ($877 million) more a year compared with installing flexible energy technologies.
- Nuclear power: what the ‘green industrial revolution’ means for the next three waves of reactorson November 23, 2020 at 3:20 am
The UK government has just announced its “Ten Point Plan for a Green Industrial Revolution”, in which it lays out a vision for the future of energy, transport and nature in the UK. As researchers into ...
- United States Nuclear Power Reactor Decommissioning Report 2020 - ResearchAndMarkets.comon November 20, 2020 at 9:36 am
The “United States Nuclear Power Reactor Decommissioning Market - Growth, Trends, and Forecasts (2020 - 2025)” report has been added to ResearchAndMarkets.com’s offering. The United States nuclear ...
The Latest Google Headlines on:
The Latest Bing News on:
- Are Smaller Aircraft Carriers A Waste of Time?on November 28, 2020 at 1:28 am
Smaller carriers are certainly doable. However, they can fly fewer missions and come with fewer defenses. The bottom line of a new study on U.S. aircraft carriers: you can't get something for nothing.
- China's First Domestically Made Nuclear Reactor Goes Onlineon November 28, 2020 at 12:50 am
China has powered up its first domestically developed nuclear reactor -- the Hualong One -- a significant step in Beijing's attempts to become less dependent on Western allies for energy security and ...
- Main emissions stack at Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station set to come downon November 27, 2020 at 5:22 pm
Reactor vessel, outbuildings and wind tower dismantled, radioactive spent fuel stored as decommissioning continues at Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station.
- Finland’s Spent Fuel Repository a "Game Changer" for the Nuclear Industry, Director General Grossi Sayson November 27, 2020 at 1:07 am
Finland's Onkalo, the world’s first ever deep geological repository for spent fuel, is a "game changer" in the words of IAEA Director General Grossi, who visited the place today, 26 November 2020.
- Nuclear a source of clean energy, waste still a problem to be solvedon November 26, 2020 at 6:11 pm
Ontario needs clean energy and while nuclear power is a source of clean energy, it remains a divisive issue. Currently, nuclear provides 60 percent ...
- Nuclear waste’s £130bn billon November 26, 2020 at 4:01 pm
The bill for cleaning up Britain’s civil nuclear waste has risen to more than £130 billion as MPs warned that “incompetence and failures of the past” would cost future generations dear.Decommissioning ...
- Contractors sought to design, oversee Lewiston nuclear waste removalon November 25, 2020 at 11:30 am
Contracts will apply to the of 278,000 cubic yards of nuclear waste from the 10-acre storage site and the planned cleanup of the surrounding land and groundwater.
- Global Nuclear Waste Management Market 2020 By Covid-19 Impact Analysis, with Future Prospects, Trends, Growth, Key Player SWOT Analysis by 2026on November 23, 2020 at 4:05 am
The report referring to the Nuclear Waste Management market is one of the most widespread and with key impactful additions designed for the buyers Market Growth Insight has delivered detailed analysis ...
- What will be the CAGR Value for Nuclear Waste Management Market in 2026? Fortune Business Insightson November 19, 2020 at 5:12 pm
Nuclear waste" is the material that nuclear fuel turns into, after being used in a reactor. The use of nuclear energy ...
- Nuclear Waste Startup Gets Backing for Underground Storage Holeson November 18, 2020 at 5:00 am
Deep Isolation Inc. raised $20 million from backers including NAC International Inc. to develop its system for storing deadly nuclear waste miles below the surface of the earth.