
via University of Pennsylvania
When organizations turn a blind eye to sexual harassment in the workplace, how many people need to take a stand before the behavior is no longer seen as normal?
According to a new paper published to be published tomorrow in Science(, there is a quantifiable answer: roughly 25% of people need to take a stand before large-scale social change occurs. This idea of a social tipping point applies to standards in the workplace, and any type of movement or initiative.
Online, people develop norms about everything from what type of content is acceptable to post on social media, to how civil or uncivil to be in their language. We have recently seen how public attitudes can and do shift on issues like gay marriage, gun laws, or race and gender equality, as well as what beliefs are or aren’t publicly acceptable to voice.
Over the past 50 years, many studies of organizations and community change have attempted to identify the critical size needed for a tipping point, purely based on observation. These studies have speculated that tipping points can range anywhere between 10% and 40%.
The problem for scientists has been that real world social dynamics are complicated, and it isn’t possible to replay history in precisely the same way to accurately measure how outcomes would have been different if an activist group had been larger or smaller.
“What we were able to do in this study was to develop a theoretical model that would predict the size of the critical mass needed to shift group norms, and then test it experimentally,” says lead author Damon Centola, Ph.D., associate professor at the University of Pennsylvania’s Annenberg School for Communication and the School of Engineering and Applied Science.
Drawing on more than a decade of experimental work, Centola has developed an online method to test how large scale social dynamics can be changed.
In this study, “Experimental Evidence for Tipping Points in Social Convention,” coauthored by Joshua Becker, Ph.D., Devon Brackbill, Ph.D., and Andrea Baronchelli, Ph.D., 10 groups of 20 participants each were given a financial incentive to agree on a linguistic norm. Once a norm had been established, a group of confederates — a coalition of activists that varied in size — then pushed for a change to the norm.
When a minority group pushing change was below 25% of the total group, its efforts failed. But when the committed minority reached 25%, there was an abrupt change in the group dynamic, and very quickly the majority of the population adopted the new norm. In one trial, a single person accounted for the difference between success and failure.
The researchers also tested the strength of their results by increasing the payments people got for adhering to the prevailing norm. Despite doubling and tripling the amount of money for sticking with the established behavior, Centola and his colleagues found that a minority group could still overturn the group norm.
“When a community is close to a tipping point to cause large-scale social change, there’s no way they would know this,” says Centola, who directs the Network Dynamics Group at the Annenberg School. “And if they’re just below a tipping point, their efforts will fail. But, remarkably, just by adding one more person, and getting above the 25% tipping point, their efforts can have rapid success in changing the entire population’s opinion.”
Acknowledging that real-life situations can be much more complicated, the authors’ model allows for the exact 25% tipping point number to change based on circumstances. Memory length is a key variable, and relates to how entrenched a belief or behavior is.
For example, someone whose beliefs are based on hundreds of past interactions may be less influenced by one change agent. Whereas someone who considers only their more recent interactions would be more easily swayed.
“Our findings present a stark contrast to centuries of thinking about social change in classical economics, in which economists typically think a majority of activists is needed to change a population’s norms,” says Centola. “The classical model, called equilibrium stability analysis, would dictate that 51% or more is needed to initiate real social change. We found, both theoretically and experimentally, that a much smaller fraction of the population can effectively do this.”
Centola believes environments can be engineered to push people in pro-social directions, particularly in contexts such as in organizations, where people’s personal rewards are tied directly to their ability to coordinate on behaviors that their peers will find acceptable.
Centola also suggests that this work has direct implications for political activism on the Internet, offering new insight into how the Chinese government’s use of pro-government propaganda on social networks like Weibo, for example, can effectively shift conversational norms away from negative stories that might foment social unrest.
While shifting people’s underlying beliefs can be challenging, Centola’s results offer new evidence that a committed minority can change what behaviors are seen as socially acceptable, potentially leading to pro-social outcomes like reduced energy consumption, less sexual harassment in the workplace, and improved exercise habits. Conversely, it can also prompt large-scale anti-social behaviors such as internet trolling, internet bullying, and public outbursts of racism.
The implications for large-scale behavior change are also the subject of Centola’s new book, How Behavior Spreads: The Science of Complex Contagion(link is external), which will be published next week by Princeton University Press.
Learn more: Research Finds Tipping Point for Large-scale Social Change
Receive an email update when we add a new SOCIAL TIPPING POINT article.
The Latest on: Social tipping point
via Google News
The Latest on: Social tipping point
- SPASH football player Jackson Kelly takes to Twitter to explain disappearance on February 21, 2019 at 7:53 am
Kelly, who goes by Jack, said he was not completing the "48 hours challenge" nor was he "looking for attention" or "laid up in a hotel," as some people wondered in social media posts ... All of the fa... […]
- Gigi returns with a bang after social media bashing on February 20, 2019 at 12:55 am
Social media was detrimental to Gigi Lamayne in the lead ... which had her fans in a frenzy. “I think that was the tipping point for me. I think my actions, subconsciously, felt there needed to be a c... […]
- 2019 will be a tipping point for credit union culture change on February 20, 2019 at 12:15 am
The seamless, convenient and often social ways they allow people to make and manage transactions is driven by their mastery of data and deployment of modeling and learning technologies they see ahead ... […]
- The Chase fans stunned as Bradley Walsh issues scathing swipe at rivals Pointless and Tipping Point on February 19, 2019 at 11:53 am
Some shocked viewers took to social media to have their say after Bradley's cruel ... And then he told those watching: "And that's why we do this show, Pointless hello have that, Tipping Point have th... […]
- Good Morning Britain and Tipping Point star Ben Shephard's house is super-stylish: see photos on February 18, 2019 at 4:46 am
It's not often we get to see what it's really like to live like a royal, but thanks to social media, we have been able to get a rare... Mary-Kate Olsen's former New York homes are for sale for £12.3mi... […]
- Facial Recognition Surveillance Now at a Privacy Tipping Point on February 15, 2019 at 2:07 pm
And they are used by social networks. It’s now just as common for someone to login to their digital device with their face as it is with their fingerprint. So we really are at a tipping point when it ... […]
- Social care sector at ‘tipping point’, says charity boss on February 15, 2019 at 4:38 am
The social care sector has reached a “tipping point” after increasing financial pressures in recent years, the chief executive of learning disability charity Hft has said. Speaking to Civil Society Ne... […]
- Care Workers and the Sleep-in Crisis at Tipping Point on February 14, 2019 at 1:07 pm
HMRC also launched the Social Care Compliance Scheme so that providers could ... and the sleep-in case has now pushed it to the tipping point, where care workers have said; “Enough! We are prepared to ... […]
- Kitces: Finding the tax-rate tipping point for retirees on February 12, 2019 at 8:29 am
projecting future tax rates is not really so blind. The starting point is to count known future income streams first, including most notably Social Security benefits and whether the maximum 85% of ben... […]
via Bing News