A new experiment, launching today online, aims to help ‘inoculate’ against disinformation by providing a small dose of perspective from a “fake news tycoon”. A pilot study has shown some early success in building resistance to fake news among teenagers.
We try to let players experience what it is like to create a filter bubble so they are more likely to realise they may be living in one
Sander van der Linden
A new online game puts players in the shoes of an aspiring propagandist to give the public a taste of the techniques and motivations behind the spread of disinformation – potentially “inoculating” them against the influence of so-called fake news in the process.
Researchers at the University of Cambridge have already shown that briefly exposing people to tactics used by fake news producers can act as a “psychological vaccine” against bogus anti-science campaigns.
While the previous study focused on disinformation about climate science, the new online game is an experiment in providing “general immunity” against the wide range of fake news that has infected public debate.
The game encourages players to stoke anger, mistrust and fear in the public by manipulating digital news and social media within the simulation.
Players build audiences for their fake news sites by publishing polarising falsehoods, deploying twitter bots, photo-shopping evidence, and inciting conspiracy theories in the wake of public tragedy – all while maintaining a “credibility score” to remain as persuasive as possible.
A pilot study conducted with teenagers in a Dutch high school used an early paper-and-pen trial of the game, and showed the perceived “reliability” of fake news to be diminished in those that played compared to a control group.
The psychological theory behind the research is called “inoculation”:
“A biological vaccine administers a small dose of the disease to build immunity. Similarly, inoculation theory suggests that exposure to a weak or demystified version of an argument makes it easier to refute when confronted with more persuasive claims,” says Dr Sander van der Linden, Director of Cambridge University’s Social Decision-Making Lab.
“If you know what it is like to walk in the shoes of someone who is actively trying to deceive you, it should increase your ability to spot and resist the techniques of deceit. We want to help grow ‘mental antibodies’ that can provide some immunity against the rapid spread of misinformation.”
Based in part on existing studies of online propaganda, and taking cues from actual conspiracy theories about organisations such as the United Nations, the game is set to be translated for countries such as Ukraine, where disinformation casts a heavy shadow.
There are also plans to adapt the framework of the game for anti-radicalisation purposes, as many of the same manipulation techniques – using false information to provoke intense emotions, for example – are commonly deployed by recruiters for religious extremist groups.
“You don’t have to be a master spin doctor to create effective disinformation. Anyone can start a site and artificially amplify it through twitter bots, for example. But recognising and resisting fake news doesn’t require a PhD in media studies either,” says Jon Roozenbeek, a researcher from Cambridge’s Department of Slavonic Studies and one of the game’s designers.
“We aren’t trying to drastically change behavior, but instead trigger a simple thought process to help foster critical and informed news
Roozenbeek points out that some efforts to combat fake news are seen as ideologically charged. “The framework of our game allows players to lean towards the left or right of the political spectrum. It’s the experience of misleading through news that counts,” he says.
The pilot study in the Netherlands using a paper version of the game involved 95 students with an average age of 16, randomly divided into treatment and control.
This version of the game focused on the refugee crisis, and all participants were randomly presented with fabricated news articles on the topic at the end of the experiment.
The treatment group were assigned roles – alarmist, denier, conspiracy theorist or clickbait monger – and tasked with distorting a government fact sheet on asylum seekers using a set of cards outlining common propaganda tactics consistent with their role.
They found fake news to be significantly less reliable than the control group, who had not produced their own fake article. Researchers describe the results of this small study as limited but promising. The study has been accepted for publication in the Journal of Risk Research.
The team are aiming to take their “fake news vaccine” trials to the next level with today’s launch of the online game.
With content written mostly by the Cambridge researchers along with Ruurd Oosterwoud, founder of DROG, the game only takes a few minutes to complete. The hope is that players will then share it to help create a large anonymous dataset of journeys through the game.
The researchers can then use this data to refine techniques for increasing media literacy and fake news resilience in a ‘post-truth’ world. “We try to let players experience what it is like to create a filter bubble so they are more likely to realise they may be living in one,” adds van der Linden.
The Latest on: Fake news
- Poor media literacy ‘making Turks vulnerable to fake news’ on December 9, 2018 at 10:59 pm
The low level of media literacy in Turkey has been making its people vulnerable to fake news, according to Şükrü Oktay Kılıç, a digital content strategist at verification platform teyit.org. “One in t... […]
- ACCC goes after Google, Facebook in the name of fake news and data transparency on December 9, 2018 at 8:03 pm
The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) has put its spotlight on Google and Facebook, determining that the substantial market power of the two companies calls into question the valid... […]
- Trump Yells at ‘Fake News Media’ in Sunday Night Tweet: ‘Enemy of the People’ on December 9, 2018 at 6:20 pm
President Donald Trump is yelling at the fake news media again. On Sunday, Trump tweeted out this: “The Trump Administration has accomplished more than any other U.S. Administration in its first two ( ... […]
- Trump Touts Accomplishments, Attacks ‘Fake News Media’ Amid Indictment Talks: ‘We Are Having a Great Time' on December 9, 2018 at 6:18 pm
Donald Trump touted his administration’s accomplishments and attacked the “fake news media” in a tweet on Sunday night after morning talk shows discussed the possibility that the president could face ... […]
- Northland Christmas tree farm keeping it real while many families opt for fake on December 9, 2018 at 5:40 pm
PLATTE COUNTY, Mo. — Real or fake, what do you choose? According to the American Christmas Tree Association, a growing number of families are going fake. However, one Platte County Christmas ... […]
- Federal Agents Told This Silk Road Moderator to Fake His Own Death on December 9, 2018 at 4:54 pm
A former administrator from the now-defunct Silk Road marketplace is recounting his story in a tell-all book and movie deal. After being arrested in 2013, darknet moderator Curtis Green was ... […]
- Fake and Bad News Is Depressing Market, JPM’s Kolanovic Says on December 9, 2018 at 4:50 pm
Biased news outlets, political opportunists and publicity-hungry analysts are whipping the stock market into a frenzy that goes beyond anything justified by economic or earnings fundamentals, accordin... […]
- Justice Department investigates millions of fake net neutrality comments for potential crimes on December 9, 2018 at 11:09 am
The Justice Department is probing whether crimes were committed when potentially millions of people's identities were posted to the Federal Communications Commission's website — without their permissi... […]
- Fake 'SNL' TV show from the 'Empire' team asks: What if Donald Trump was black? on December 9, 2018 at 7:08 am
Them Trumps is a Saturday Night Live-conceived TV series from the producers of Empire. (No, it's not real, it's just a fake ad that aired during the latest SNL episode.) This alternate universe ... […]
- Philippines Seeks China's Help in Countering Fake Cigarettes on December 8, 2018 at 11:13 pm
The Philippines will seek China’s help in halting the proliferation of counterfeit cigarettes, its Department of Finance said. Finance Secretary Carlos Dominguez ordered the Bureaus of Internal Revenu... […]
via Google News and Bing News