An economy based on zero growth could be more stable – experiencing fewer crashes – and bring higher wages, suggests a new University of Sussex study.
Running counter to dominant economic thinking, the new research shows that economies can be stable with or without growth and are in fact likely to be less volatile if we stop chasing ever-increasing GDP.
The idea of a no-growth economy is not new – British economist John Maynard Keynes in 1936 predicted an end to growth – but it has gained traction in the past few years as people have increasingly come to view infinite growth as environmentally unsustainable.
Dr Adam Barrett, a mathematician at the School of Engineering and Informatics at the University of Sussex, says: “Our economic system relies on growth but, because we live on a finite planet, most people agree there is a limit to how long this can continue.
“Slowing down economic activity therefore makes a lot of sense in theory but the charge has always been that this leaves you vulnerable to financial crises.
“My research suggests that not only is this not necessarily true but that, if anything, zero-growth scenarios are more likely to remain stable. An end to growth did not trigger instability in my tests.”
Instead, financial crises have much more to do with erratic debt behaviour than whether or not the economy is growing, Dr Barrett says: “The more rapidly businesses try to change their level of debt in response to changing conditions, the more likely there is to be an economic crisis.”
Dr Barrett’s paper is the first to assess the relative likelihood of a crisis emerging from a period of zero growth versus a period of positive growth.
The study found that, in contrast to the alarming conclusions of French economist Thomas Piketty, an end to growth would not cause rising inequality: the share of profit going to workers would actually increase. However, the study does concede that this would be accompanied by more frequent substantial drops in levels of employment.
Interestingly, all the scenarios modelled by Dr Barrett included a positive interest rate for loans, a key feature of a capitalist economy. This could be seen as a sign that a move to a stable no-growth economy could be achieved without dismantling our entire banking system. Indeed, the research modelled gradual and sudden transitions to a post-growth economy and found that neither would trigger a crisis; although, again, there would be some fluctuations in the level of employment in the absence of an active government.
Unlike other studies, which search for an elusive sweet spot where an economy is steady and robust to all shocks, Dr Barrett accepted that all real economies are subject to fluctuations and cycles. He says: “None of the studies so far really take account of the fact that capitalism is unstable and prone to crisis even during a period of strong and stable growth.” Instead, he characterised crises as “run-away explosive behaviour” and paid less attention to small bumps in the road.
Using a new mathematical model based on American economist Hyman Minsky’s theory of financial instability – work that was much overlooked prior to the financial crash of 2008 but which has been receiving increasing attention in recent years – Dr Barrett ran a series of scenarios in which productivity is forever growing (at two per cent per year) and some scenarios in which productivity stops growing.
He allowed the models to play out for a period of 250 years, after which the patterns began to repeat.
The Latest on: No-growth economy
- The EU needs a stability and wellbeing pact, not more growth on September 16, 2018 at 8:26 am
If current trends continue, there may be no growth at all in Europe within a decade ... This aggressive pursuit of growth at all costs divides society, creates economic instability, and undermines dem... […]
- What happens when ideas become harder and harder to find? A long-read Q&A with Nicholas Bloom on September 14, 2018 at 4:42 pm
We also discuss his work on economic uncertainty, how to measure it and how much ... So, about half the population has seen no growth, and they turn to alternative politicians. So 2016, for some reaso... […]
- Record U.S. job openings, quits rate boost wage growth outlook on September 11, 2018 at 2:53 pm
“The economic expansion is on a collision course with a lack of workers to man the shop floors, work the restaurants and stores at the shopping malls across America,” said Chris Rupkey, chief economis... […]
- Argentine government announces “emergency” measures to face deepening recession and growing unrest on September 4, 2018 at 10:07 pm
... that it expects a 42 percent inflation rate—the highest since 1990—and a 2.4 percent economic decline for 2018, along with 25 percent inflation and no growth next year. Meanwhile, the government h... […]
- The suddenly dreadful Aussie dollar on September 3, 2018 at 9:57 pm
No growth. That’s the sort of number that gives economists ... So falling retail sales is a concern for the Aussie economy. It could punch a hole in the economic growth we need to keep unemployment fa... […]
- Jamaica's last 41 years of economic walk on September 1, 2018 at 11:38 pm
economy continues to remain tepid or anemic resulting in low or no growth or in contraction mode the attendant social deluge that will be visited on this country will cause the pain of the 1970s and 8... […]
- The Economy Is Collapsing Under The Unbearable Weight Of Debt on August 30, 2018 at 6:34 am
The U.S. economy's appearance of wealth creation and ... the rate of growth in real consumer credit outstanding is approaching zero (no growth): The chart above shows the year-over-year growth ... […]
- Peter Schiff: The Fed Is Pushing Us Toward A No-Growth, High-Inflation Economy on August 29, 2018 at 7:03 pm
As expected, the Federal Reserve nudged rates up another .25 basis points on Wednesday. Perhaps more significantly, the Fed took a more hawkish tone than expected, signaling it would likely increase r... […]
- There was zero growth in India’s job market in 2018 on August 1, 2018 at 10:46 pm
“On the flip side, we may also infer there was no growth in employment in 2017-18 ... The last two years have been tough for India, with the economy still recovering from the twin shocks of demonetisa... […]
- Jobless growth is no growth, says Pranab Mukherjee on April 16, 2018 at 4:04 pm
“Moreover, rapid economic growth has also not reflected itself fully in corresponding rise in employment. In my opinion, a jobless growth is no growth for Indian situation,” he said. Admitting that In... […]
via Google News and Bing News