Research-funding agencies that require scientists to declare at the proposal stage how their projects will be “transformative” may actually be hindering discovery, according to a study by Oregon State University ecologists.
The requirement can result in decreased funding for the “incremental” research that often paves the way for paradigm-shifting breakthroughs, the OSU scientists assert.
Their findings, as well as their recommendation for how to best foster transformative research, were published recently in Trends in Ecology and Evolution.
Sarah Gravem, postdoctoral scholar in integrative biology in Oregon State’s College of Science, was the lead author on the paper, titled “Transformative Research is Not Easily Predicted.”
Gravem, integrative biology professor Bruce Menge and the other collaborators note that the National Science Foundation, which funds roughly one-quarter of the federally supported research at U.S. colleges and universities, “has made the pursuit of transformative research a top priority by asking for a transformative research statement in every major research proposal solicited.”
The NSF defines transformative research as being “driven by ideas that have the potential to radically change our understanding of an important existing scientific or engineering concept or leading to the creation of a new paradigm … . Such research is also characterized by its challenge to current understanding or its pathway to new frontiers.”
Gravem says asking scientists to attempt to create new paradigms or fields in every proposal is unrealistic and potentially harmful.
The OSU scientists argue that a better approach, and one that was suggested more than a decade ago by the board that oversees the National Science Foundation, would be to create a funding subset: a separate NSF-wide program to solicit and support transformational research proposals.
“The board had been concerned that the U.S. was lagging behind other countries in scientific advances, concerned that creative and risky research was not getting funding,” Menge said. “It concluded that what the NSF should do is set aside some funds for risky research proposals, those defined by reviewers as they may or may not work, the chances are sort of slim, but they could turn out to be pretty cool.”
What the NSF did instead, Menge said, was require all proposals to show how the research being proposed would be transformative.
“Instructions to reviewers include the expectation that the reviewer will comment on how transformative the proposed research is,” Menge added.
The problem, the Oregon State collaborators say, is that it’s rarely possible to know at the proposal stage whether a project will turn out to be transformative; their assertion follows interviews and surveys of 78 highly cited ecologists who began with incremental goals and only later realized the transformative potential of their work.
“To start out with that transformative question is a backward way of thinking,” Gravem said. “Surely you have to think big to come up with big answers, and everyone is striving for that, but truly transformative research is an unobtainable standard to place on people at the proposal stage. Trying to make every project paradigm shifting can mean ignoring the incremental and basic science that eventually goes into shifting paradigms. It’s a detriment to ignore the building blocks in favor of the building.”
Gravem said the necessity of incremental research was also explained recently on Freakonomics Radio.
“Economist Ed Glaeser noted that Nobel Prizes are not typically given for single transformative research papers but are often given for a body of incremental research,” she said. “If transformations arise from incremental research, then the transformative criterion is redundant with the solicitation of incremental research. This is reflected by mixed evidence that soliciting transformative research led to increases in transformative outcomes compared with the typical model.”
Expanding fields of knowledge, adding to bodies of evidence, and comparing two fields that haven’t been compared before are the types of gains researchers can reasonably predict, Gravem added. Being asked to forecast how a project will turn out to be transformative puts “researchers in an awkward position that nobody likes.”
“We’re being forced to hype our work at the beginning of a proposal, which doesn’t do anything to help science or to help build trust in science,” Gravem said. “And it turns the funding process into an essay competition that favors people who take more liberty in predicting what their research might show.”
Menge notes that NSF’s plan all along was to reassess the transformative research statement requirement at some point, “and now is the time.”
“Research funding is effectively decreasing, but the demand for funding is increasing, so they look for ways to prune the field of who gets funded – I recognize that as a problem,” he said. “But making artificial hurdles is just wrong. Funding agencies should concentrate on the goals of the research rather than the unknowable outcome.”
The Latest on: Transformative research
- Singapore Institutes Collaborate with Samsung Medical Center to Improve Treatment of Liver Cancer on December 16, 2017 at 10:56 am
which offers a global approach to education and research, with a focus on Asian perspectives and expertise. NUS has 17 faculties and schools across three campuses. Its transformative education includes a broad-based curriculum underscored by ... […]
- Top 10 Most Transformative Technologies For Marketing In 2018: 350 CMOs, CEOs, Experts Speak on December 16, 2017 at 4:27 am
And 63.5% believe that big data will (finally) be transformative for marketers in 2018 ... says Irena Cronin, who leads research at Transformation Group. One of the key reseaons? Silicon Valley, of course. “I believe it’s not the technology but ... […]
- Transformative Gift Allows U of A to Expand Local Art and Design District on December 14, 2017 at 10:32 pm
William Fulbright College of Arts and Sciences is the largest and most academically diverse unit on campus with 19 departments and 43 academic programs and research centers. The college provides the core curriculum for all University of Arkansas students ... […]
- ABI Research Identifies Three Big Trends Impacting Each of the 20 Most Compelling Transformative Technologies on December 14, 2017 at 8:05 am
ABI Research, a market-foresight advisory firm providing strategic guidance on the most compelling transformative technologies. WHAT: ABI has researched 20 of the most compelling transformative technologies and has identified the top three big trends ... […]
- 1-Minute Transformative Technology Reads on December 13, 2017 at 2:19 pm
While other technology advisory firms have issued their predictions for 2018, ABI Research has taken a different approach. We have researched 20 of the most compelling transformative technologies and have identified the top three BIG trends — that go ... […]
- Brain & Behavior Research Foundation Awards Distinguished Invest - KAIT Jonesboro, AR - Region 8 News, weather, sports on December 13, 2017 at 7:56 am
"By funding creative research that explores new ways to prevent ... We were impressed by the variety of new approaches, which could prove helpful or even transformative, and will be supported by this seed capital," he added. "These include studies focusing ... […]
- Public Voices Fellows Say Program Is ‘Transformative’ on December 12, 2017 at 11:13 am
“Now I’m seriously working on the history of fake news, and it’s probably going to end up in another research project ... She calls the program “profoundly transformative.” “Doing this fellowship in conjunction with my administrative ... […]
- University of Oregon Uses Supercomputer to Power New Research Advanced Computing Facility on December 6, 2017 at 12:36 pm
UO’s vice president for research and innovation. “It goes a long way toward our goal of advancing transformative excellence in research, innovation and graduate education, and it’s exciting to think about all of the new discoveries and new ... […]
- Details revealed of transformative life sciences deal on December 5, 2017 at 11:58 pm
A transformative deal between the UK life sciences sector and the government, which is designed to ensure that the next wave of breakthrough treatments, medical research and technologies, and jobs are created in Britain, has been struck. The Life Sciences ... […]
- Biology Major Wins Award For Sustainable River Research on December 4, 2017 at 8:42 pm
“I was not the only student from [USD] to attend this conference,” Seidel said. “Students shared transformative research concepts across disciplines and represented the University of South Dakota very well. I am thankful for the opportunity to be at ... […]
via Google News and Bing News