Every year 40,000 women die from breast cancer in the U.S. alone. When cancers are found early, they can often be cured. Mammograms are the best test available, but they’re still imperfect and often result in false positive results that can lead to unnecessary biopsies and surgeries.
One common cause of false positives are so-called “high-risk” lesions that appear suspicious on mammograms and have abnormal cells when tested by needle biopsy. In this case, the patient typically undergoes surgery to have the lesion removed; however, the lesions turn out to be benign at surgery 90 percent of the time. This means that every year thousands of women go through painful, expensive, scar-inducing surgeries that weren’t even necessary.
How, then, can unnecessary surgeries be eliminated while still maintaining the important role of mammography in cancer detection? Researchers at MIT’s Computer Science and Artificial Intelligence Laboratory (CSAIL), Massachusetts General Hospital, and Harvard Medical School believe that the answer is to turn to artificial intelligence (AI).
As a first project to apply AI to improving detection and diagnosis, the teams collaborated to develop an AI system that uses machine learning to predict if a high-risk lesion identified on needle biopsy after a mammogram will upgrade to cancer at surgery.
When tested on 335 high-risk lesions, the model correctly diagnosed 97 percent of the breast cancers as malignant and reduced the number of benign surgeries by more than 30 percent compared to existing approaches.
“Because diagnostic tools are so inexact, there is an understandable tendency for doctors to over-screen for breast cancer,” says Regina Barzilay, MIT’s Delta Electronics Professor of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science and a breast cancer survivor herself. “When there’s this much uncertainty in data, machine learning is exactly the tool that we need to improve detection and prevent over-treatment.”
Trained on information about more than 600 existing high-risk lesions, the model looks for patterns among many different data elements that include demographics, family history, past biopsies, and pathology reports.
“To our knowledge, this is the first study to apply machine learning to the task of distinguishing high-risk lesions that need surgery from those that don’t,” says collaborator Constance Lehman, professor at Harvard Medical School and chief of the Breast Imaging Division at MGH’s Department of Radiology. “We believe this could support women to make more informed decisions about their treatment, and that we could provide more targeted approaches to health care in general.”
A recent MacArthur “genius grant” recipient, Barzilay is a co-author of a new journal article describing the results, co-written with Lehman and Manisha Bahl of MGH, as well as CSAIL graduate students Nicholas Locascio, Adam Yedidia, and Lili Yu. The article was published today in the medical journal Radiology.
How it works
When a mammogram detects a suspicious lesion, a needle biopsy is performed to determine if it is cancer. Roughly 70 percent of the lesions are benign, 20 percent are malignant, and 10 percent are high-risk lesions.
Doctors manage high-risk lesions in different ways. Some do surgery in all cases, while others perform surgery only for lesions that have higher cancer rates, such as “atypical ductal hyperplasia” (ADH) or a “lobular carcinoma in situ” (LCIS).
The first approach requires that the patient undergo a painful, time-consuming, and expensive surgery that is usually unnecessary; the second approach is imprecise and could result in missing cancers in high-risk lesions other than ADH and LCIS.
“The vast majority of patients with high-risk lesions do not have cancer, and we’re trying to find the few that do,” says Bahl, a fellow doctor at MGH’s Department of Radiology. “In a scenario like this there’s always a risk that when you try to increase the number of cancers you can identify, you’ll also increase the number of false positives you find.”
Using a method known as a “random-forest classifier,” the team’s model resulted in fewer unnecessary surgeries compared to the strategy of always doing surgery, while also being able to diagnose more cancerous lesions than the strategy of only doing surgery on traditional “high-risk lesions.” (Specifically, the new model diagnosed 97 percent of cancers compared to 79 percent.)
“This work highlights an example of using cutting-edge machine learning technology to avoid unnecessary surgery,” says Marc Kohli, director of clinical informatics in the Department of Radiology and Biomedical Imaging at the University of California at San Francisco. “This is the first step toward the medical community embracing machine learning as a way to identify patterns and trends that are otherwise invisible to humans.”
Lehman says that MGH radiologists will begin incorporating the model into their clinical practice over the next year.
“In the past we might have recommended that all high-risk lesions be surgically excised,” Lehman says. “But now, if the model determines that the lesion has a very low chance of being cancerous in a specific patient, we can have a more informed discussion with our patient about her options. It may be reasonable for some patients to have their lesions followed with imaging rather than surgically excised.”
The team says that they are still working to further hone the model.
“In future work we hope to incorporate the actual images from the mammograms and images of the pathology slides, as well as more extensive patient information from medical records,” says Bahl.
Moving forward, the model could also easily be tweaked to be applied to other kinds of cancer and even other diseases entirely.
“A model like this will work anytime you have lots of different factors that correlate with a specific outcome,” says Barzilay. “It hopefully will enable us to start to go beyond a one-size-fits-all approach to medical diagnosis.”
The Latest on: Early breast cancer detection
- Pin-A-Sister raises awareness for breast cancer and early detection on September 16, 2018 at 12:46 pm
TYLER — Breast cancer can be fatal especially for African-American women. "Just like our favorite pair of go to shoes will eventually wear out we all know these earthly bodies will only last us for a ... […]
- Secret Sisters Luncheon, Style Show supports early breast cancer detection on September 12, 2018 at 3:47 pm
Our nice weather pattern is going to continue over the next few days. We'll see a few clouds at times, but no rain is expected through the weekend. UPDATE: Three suspicious vehicle fires reported in M... […]
- Secret Sisters supports early breast cancer detection with 17th annual luncheon on September 12, 2018 at 3:47 pm
SOUTH BEND, Ind. (WNDU) - The Century Center was a sea of pink Wednesday, and for good reason. It was the 17th annual Secret Sisters Society Luncheon and Style Show. Hundreds of women, many wearing cr... […]
- Is Early Cancer Detection on the Horizon? on August 30, 2018 at 3:11 am
Cancer is made up of a wide and complex set of many disease types, each with its own set of cellular and molecular markers. Early detection of breast cancer through screening protocols and public awar... […]
- Breast milk may help early detection of cancer on June 21, 2018 at 5:27 am
Protein markers in breast milk can help detect breast cancer at an early stage and even predict if a woman is at risk of the deadly disease, a new study has found. Objective detection of breast cancer ... […]
- Early breast cancer detection is in your hands on March 26, 2018 at 4:52 pm
Breast cancer is the leading cancer affecting women in Malaysia and studies show one in 19 women will develop this dreaded disease in their lifetime. The good news however, is that advanced screening ... […]
- ‘Early detection is best chance for survival in breast cancer’ on November 8, 2017 at 9:42 am
edition of its Think Pink campaign. High prevalence and incident of breast cancer around the world has been a cause of concern. Efforts are being made to raise awareness among women about the disease, ... […]
- Early detection, treatment of breast cancer important – MPs on October 22, 2017 at 9:06 am
Parliament on Friday called for the need to care for the breast, with emphasis on early detection of breast cancer to save lives. “Babies need their mothers’ breasts, the mothers themselves need their ... […]
- Rwanda: Breast Cancer - Early Detection Saves Life on October 15, 2017 at 11:37 pm
Haston Charlotte talks with a calm and confident endearing voice, sharing her story of how she survived one of the deadliest diseases, cancer. The 50-year old mother of one from Kagugu in Gasabo Distr... […]
- Dr. Samadi: 3 steps for the early detection of breast cancer on October 6, 2017 at 12:10 pm
October is typically associated with fall colors of orange, yellow and red, but pink is another color you may be noticing quite a bit during this time of year. That is because October is Breast Cancer ... […]
via Google News and Bing News