When Apollo astronauts on the moon spoke with Mission Control on Earth, there was a noticeable time gap between a statement from Tranquility Base and its immediate acknowledgment from Houston. The gap lasted almost three seconds, or 10 times longer than human reaction times would account for.
What was happening? The answer is simple: space. The moon orbits far enough from Earth that light (and radio) take 1.3 seconds each way to travel the distance. At exploration targets farther away, the delay increases; for exploring Mars, signals take between 5 and 40 minutes, depending on the varying distance between the two planets.
“During the Apollo missions, the astronauts were making scientific observations and relaying what they saw back to scientists on Earth. Both were collaborating on decisions about observations and which samples to collect and bring back to Earth to yield the most scientific value,” said Kip Hodges, Foundation Professor in ASU’s School of Earth and Space Exploration.
“This worked reasonably well for lunar explorations, but the time delay is likely to dramatically reduce the quality and scientific value of such collaborations in exploring faraway places like Mars.”
So far, Hodges notes, fieldwork is being done remotely on Mars by scientists on Earth using robotic tools such as the Curiosity rover. But it’s slow.
“Even though signals commanding observations and measurements take only minutes or tens of minutes to reach Mars, a single research activity on Mars, from command to data return, can take a day or more,” he said.
In the June 21 issue of the journal Science Robotics, Hodges and collaborators Dan Lester at Exinetics and Robert Anderson of NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory suggest a new approach to scientific exploration that they call exploration telepresence.
“To the extent that much scientific research is a process where awareness drives action,” the authors say, “the communications delay between humans on Earth and planetary exploration sites is limiting.”
The ideal is to keep these delays, or “latencies,” within the length of human reaction times. One approach is to have the astronaut scientists working directly on the surface of a planet. But landing humans and keeping them safe is an expensive and dangerous strategy.
A safer and less expensive approach, according to the authors, may be exploration science using telepresence, a strategy widely used on Earth now for activities as delicate and demanding as surgery.
“Telepresence means humans operating robotic systems from a distance close enough where the delay between human action and the robotic response is a fraction of a second,” Hodges explained.
For Mars research, astronauts might go to Mars orbit, but not to the surface. From orbit, the communications travel time would be such that an astronaut/scientist could work with a robotic surrogate, experiencing the surface environment virtually, and doing scientific investigations as if she or he were on the ground.
Moreover, humans in Mars orbit could control instruments in real time at many different sites across the planet. And by preventing contamination of Mars with terrestrial biology, exploration telepresence from orbit also offers advantages over in situ human explorers.
While the authors add that scientific research by humans working directly on the other planetary surfaces is the ultimate goal, exploration telepresence could be an important next step.
“Today we do good science on Mars using long time-delay telerobotics, but we could do much better science much more quickly with humans on the surface,” Hodges said. “Exploration telepresence would be a reasonable compromise until that day comes.”
Moreover, he said, “There are important targets for scientific exploration for which we currently don’t have the technology to land humans safely. Exploration telepresence could greatly expand the number of destinations where humans can do great science.”
Learn more: New virtual approach to science in space
The Latest on: Exploration telepresence
- AI Is Kicking Space Exploration into Hyperdrive—Here’s How on October 7, 2018 at 8:00 am
Artificial intelligence in space exploration is gathering momentum ... Why not send an AI-driven robot to Mars and use it as a telepresence for scientists on Earth? It could be argued that we are alre... […]
- Teachers Bring Deep-Sea Exploration to Classrooms Through Nautilus Exploration Program CITGO STEM Academy on September 27, 2018 at 5:00 pm
In addition to conducting scientific exploration, the Nautilus Exploration Program offers telepresence to explorers on shore and the public via live video, audio and data feeds. The program also inclu... […]
- JAXA Wants Telepresence Robots for In-Space Construction and Exploration on September 17, 2018 at 1:33 pm
Last Monday, we covered the new, updated, and way way better guidelines for the ANA Avatar XPRIZE. Since we were mostly talking with the folks over at XPRIZE, we didn’t realize that ANA (All Nippon Ai... […]
- ANA Holdings partners with Japan’s space agency on ‘Avatar X’ telepresence program on September 8, 2018 at 7:48 am
Telepresence robots on the moon and Mars? That’s the vision laid out for the partnership between ANA Holdings, the parent company of Japan’s All Nippon Airways, and the Japan Aerospace Exploration Age... […]
- ARHT Media : Holographic Telepresence Technology used at TED2018 on January 4, 2018 at 6:01 pm
Professor Harari’s talk will post on TED.com May 18, 2018. ARHT’s patented Augmented Reality Holographic Telepresence technology is the world’s first complete end-to-end solution for the creation, tra... […]
- Nautilus Live: Deep-Sea Exploration with Amy Fleischer on October 31, 2017 at 10:42 pm
We will also interact live with members of the Corps of Exploration currently on board the ship through the magic of telepresence. Equipped with the Remotely Operated Vehicles Hercules and Argus, a pr... […]
- Virtual exploration could be the future of space science on June 22, 2017 at 10:16 am
Scientists say humans in orbit could operate robotic systems down at the surface by relying on telepresence, enabling virtual exploration – and, some even say artificially intelligent probes could lea... […]
- Are Telepresence Robots the Best Way to Explore Other Worlds? on June 22, 2017 at 10:01 am
The idea is using robotic telepresence for planetary exploration. From orbit, the authors argue, a small team of humans would remote operate rovers and other robotic systems and as a result they could ... […]
- Astronauts in Orbit Around Alien Planets Should Explore Surfaces With Robots and VR on June 21, 2017 at 3:38 pm
"Exploration telepresence is about putting human presence and activity where it's really hard to put humans," Lester told me over the phone. "I would certainly never say to do it instead of landing," ... […]
- A new virtual approach to science in space on June 21, 2017 at 11:00 am
... Anderson of NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory suggest a new approach to scientific exploration that they call exploration telepresence. "To the extent that much scientific research is a process whe... […]
via Google News and Bing News