Understanding obstacles to change key to timely adoption of technologies needed to address global problems; How the history of margarine and tractors can inform policy making
Disruptive, transformative technologies are being introduced at an accelerating pace, fuelling opposition that impedes forms of innovation needed to meet profound challenges such as climate change, poverty and world hunger, says a new study from Harvard University.
Innovation and Its Enemies: Why People Resist New Technology, by Prof. Calestous Juma of the Harvard Kennedy School’s Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs, chronicles the history of opposition to change — from tractors and certain uses of the printing press to coffee and margarine — and its underlying reasons.
Such understanding is critical, he argues, to the successful introduction and adoption of technological innovations needed to cope with humanity’s most serious economic and environmental challenges.
Published as a book by Oxford University Press, the 16-year study says fear and perceptions of lost employment, identity, and power drive impediment to innovation, and describes the widening gap between the pace of technological advancement and slow rate at which society adjusts.
Says Dr. Juma:”To meet the needs of a growing world population on a warming planet, humanity’s hopes are pinned on the introduction of transformative technologies but progress can be impeded by unreasonable obstruction to change.”
The study acknowledges the need to address legitimate health and environmental concerns related to new products and technologies and underlines that transparency, inclusiveness and caution in the handling of scientific uncertainty as critical elements of public trust.
The study chronicles the extraordinary measures taken by opponents to change, and the tenacity of entrepreneurs and technologists who overcame it.
Drawing on nearly 600 years of controversies, the study presents in-depth case studies of opposition to innovation, including printing of the Koran by the Ottomans, alternating current, refrigeration, recorded music, and, more recently, robotics, artificial intelligence and agricultural biotechnology.
Both coffee and tractors, for instance, were the targets of smear campaigns. Other tactics included demonization, rumours, slander, efforts to restrict use through legislation, and outright bans.
Parallels through history are striking. Transgenic crops have been dubbed “Frankenfoods.” In 17th century Italy, coffee was called “Satan’s Drink” and “Junior Alcohol” in 20th century southern India. In England, France, and Germany, coffee was said to cause sterility.
Calling refrigerated products “Embalmed Foods” had a chilling effect on consumers. Swedes dubbed the early telephone the “Devil’s Instrument.” Margarine was derided as “Bull Butter” in America and accused of causing sterility, male baldness, and stunting.
“Common to all these cases is fear and opponents excluded from the benefits of new technology,” says Dr. Juma.
Launch of the study takes place Wednesday July 6 at the 16th International Joseph A. Schumpeter Society Conference in Montreal. Dr. Schumpeter, an early 20th Century Austrian economist introduced the idea of “creative destruction” and was equally concerned about resistance to change.
The study says that in many cases objections and social responses to innovation fall into in one or more of four categories: intuition, vested interests, intellectual arguments, and psychological factors.
- Intuitive responses, often expressed as disgust, reflect patterns of behaviour that rely on deeper evolutionary roots of our fears and phobias. New foods, for example, may be seen as a threat to human health.
- Vested interests are illustrated with a well-known example of Luddites, early 19th century British textile workers, popularly portrayed as machine breakers who were simply opposed to change. But the reality was a clash of competing economic world views and moral values.
- Intellectual challenges to new technologies include philosophical objections to the manipulation of nature or the use of robotics in manufacturing, considered by some as “dehumanizing” and changing how we see ourselves as humans.
- Finally, business models that aim to alter the psychology of health and nutrition choices face strong opposition.
Innovation and Its Enemies advocates more timely scientific assessments of the benefits and risks of new technologies, swift adjustment of social institutions to keep pace with technological advancement, and greater public awareness and citizen engagement.
Inclusive innovation is critical for acceptance of new controversial technologies, Dr. Juma says.
This entails greater involvement of public institutions to provide training in the emerging fields, creation of joint ventures, equitable management of intellectual property rights, segmentation of markets to enable a technology to be used for noncompetitive products, and improvement of the policy environment to support long-term technology partnerships.
Building local capabilities and fostering public engagement in technology development are critical. The absence of inclusive strategies leads to intense debates over questions of justice, equity, corporate control and challenges to intellectual property system.
Also needed: strong, entrepreneurial decision-makers and leaders who can use available knowledge to assess a situation, take informed executive action in a timely manner, and monitor technological advances and their impacts. Leaders must be able to rely on advice from both scientific academies as well as complementary advisory institutions in executive offices.
Finally, says Dr. Juma, public education is critical in determining the pace and patterns of technological adoption. Many programs alienate the public by assuming that the root cause of social concern over new technology is ignorance. To the contrary, concerns commonly come from well-informed sections of the population. Public education should aim to enhance the legitimacy and quality of risk assessment processes. Ultimately, the goal is to manage risk perception and foster trust.
“People are more likely to accept the risks of new technologies if they have been part of the process of deciding on their use,” says Dr. Juma.
The Latest on: Technological adoption
via Google News
The Latest on: Technological adoption
- New Survey Indicates Businesses Unprepared to Deploy Blockchain Technology on February 19, 2019 at 3:08 pm
The technology as such usually requires a shift in paradigm to adopt it, thus sharing core objectives for the technology is key for a successful blockchain integration." To prepare the study ... […]
- Cloud-managed databases target cost and simplify adoption on February 19, 2019 at 2:52 pm
“Cloud-managed databases, at its core, is about simplifying adoption of cloud-provided ... It’s portable in its leveraging of the Kubernetes technology itself.” Watch the complete video ... […]
- Why Freelance Workers Should Be The First To Adopt Blockchain on February 19, 2019 at 1:52 pm
If hacked, this one centralized body could jeopardize sensitive information of the entire network of consumers. Blockchain technology, by the virtue of it being decentralized, should therefore offer a ... […]
- ManpowerGroup Announced as Gold HR Partner for the Fourth Year at World-Leading Viva Technology Conference on February 19, 2019 at 1:00 pm
MILWAUKEE, Feb. 19, 2019 /PRNewswire/ -- ManpowerGroup (NYSE: MAN) joins the biggest names in tech as Gold HR partner of the world-famous Viva Technology conference ... helping accelerate tech adoptio... […]
- Spectra Logic to Sponsor and Speak at Upcoming Storage Technology Showcase Conference on February 19, 2019 at 8:48 am
The Storage Technology Showcase will equip executives ... Spectra Logic's uncompromising product and customer focus is proven by the adoption of its solutions by industry leaders in multiple vertical ... […]
- Is Sports Key to Consumer Adoption of 5G? Some Research Suggests So on February 19, 2019 at 8:29 am
Ovum also expects the 5G technology will transform the at-home viewing experience ... Amdocs’ research has revealed that major live sports events could hold the key to consumer adoption of 5G,” said G... […]
- Cleveland moving toward adopting app technology that would let motorists use smart phones to pay parking meters on February 19, 2019 at 7:32 am
Does app service have support on City Council? Councilman Kerry McCormack has long advocated for use of smart phone apps for parking and the adoption of other smart technology. McCormack believes the ... […]
- Increasing Adoption of Global Internet of Things Intelligent Irrigation System Market Owing to Technological Advancements on February 19, 2019 at 2:51 am
Qyresearchreports include new market research report "Global Internet of Things Intelligent Irrigation System Market Insights, Forecast to 2025" to its huge collection of research reports. This report ... […]
- Manila Philippines Development Agency (MMDA) to Adopt mit messenger Technology for 20 Million Manila Citizens on February 19, 2019 at 1:28 am
SEOUL, South Korea, Feb. 19, 2019 /PRNewswire/ -- mit messenger developed by Korean technology company - Stargram Global will be introduced in the administrative processing for civil affairs ... […]
- Driving technology adoption on February 18, 2019 at 4:45 pm
When bringing on a new system or new technology, the success is largely in the hands of the users. For a manager or a leader, figuring out how to drive adoption and encourage originators to go all in ... […]
via Bing News