“While drones still have a ‘human in the loop’ who takes the decision to use lethal force, LARs have on-board computers that decide who should be targeted”
The United Nations Special Rapporteur on extrajudicial, summary or arbitrary executions, Christof Heyns, today called for a global pause in the development and deployment of lethal autonomous robots (LARs), to allow “serious and meaningful international engagement on this issue before we proceed to a world where machines are given the power to kill humans.”
“While drones still have a ‘human in the loop’ who takes the decision to use lethal force, LARs have on-board computers that decide who should be targeted,” he stressed.
“The possible introduction of LARs raises far-reaching concerns about the protection of life during war and peace,” Mr. Heyns noted during the presentation of his latest report* to the UN Human Rights Council. “If this is done, machines and not humans, will take the decision on who is alive or dies,” he said.
“This may make it easier for States to go to war; and raises the question whether they can be programmed to comply with the requirements of international humanitarian law, especially the distinction between combatant and civilians and collateral damage,” he explained.
“Beyond this, their deployment may be unacceptable because no adequate system of legal accountability can be devised for the actions of machines,” the independent human rights expert noted, based on his analysis of potential violations of the rights to life and human dignity should the use of LARs materialize.
In his report, Mr. Heyns urges the UN Human Rights Council to call on all States “to declare and implement national moratoria on the production, assembly, transfer, acquisition, deployment and use of LARs, until a framework on the future of LARs has been established.” He also invites the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights to convene or to work with other UN bodies to convene a High Level Panel on LARs to articulate this framework.
“War without reflection is mechanical slaughter,” the UN expert on summary executions said. “In the same way that the taking of any human life deserves as a minimum some deliberation, a decision to allow machines to be deployed to kill human beings deserves a collective pause worldwide.”
For the Special Rapporteur, the time is ripe for a thorough and cool-headed global reflection in order “to ensure that not only life itself but also the value of life and human dignity is protected in the long run.”
“If deployed, LARs will take humans ‘out of the loop,’” Mr. Heyns warned. In his view, “States find this technology attractive because human decision-making is often much slower than that of robots, and human thinking can be clouded by emotion.”
“At the same time, humans may in some cases, unlike robots, be able to act out of compassion or grace and can, based on their understanding of the bigger picture, know that a more lenient approach is called for in a specific situation,” he underscored.
The Special Rapporteur stressed that there is now an opportunity to pause collectively, and to engage with the risks posed by LARs in a proactive way, in contrast to other revolutions in military affairs, where serious reflection mostly began after the emergence of new methods of warfare. “The current moment may be the best we will have to address these concerns,” he said.
The Latest on: Lethal autonomous robots
- OPINION: Autonomous lethal drones a legal challenge on April 12, 2019 at 6:31 am
Are they lethal autonomous weapons systems, with the tidy acronym “LAWS” – or killer robots? Either way, politicians, soldiers, society and the aerospace industry that serves them must grapple with ... […]
- Is there room for ethics and the law in military AI? on April 10, 2019 at 8:46 pm
commentators like Stop Killer Robots have expressed fears that the lack of a ban against lethal autonomous weapons would leave room for the world to enter into a destabilising robotics arms race. ... […]
- The rise of the killer robots – and the two women fighting back on April 7, 2019 at 9:00 pm
“There are not only legal and ethical concerns about lethal autonomy, but practical ones as well,” says Paul Scharre, a former US army ranger who wrote the Pentagon’s earliest policy statement on ... […]
- UK, US & Russia among those opposing ban on killer robots, reports say on April 6, 2019 at 11:28 pm
The UK government is among a group of countries that are attempting to thwart plans to formulate and impose a preemptive ban on killer robots, a report reveals ... under international law to so-called ... […]
- Robots to autocomplete Soldier tasks, new study suggests on April 5, 2019 at 2:00 pm
The Army envisions a future battlefield wrought with teams of Soldiers and autonomous systems ... of the technology-based capabilities required to make Soldiers more lethal to win our Nation's wars ... […]
- UK, US and Russia among those opposing killer robot ban on March 29, 2019 at 7:45 am
We believe a preemptive ban is premature as there is still no international agreement on the characteristics of lethal autonomous weapons systems.” The issue of human control is at the heart of ... […]
- Killer robots: ‘do something’ or ‘do nothing’? on March 29, 2019 at 5:35 am
Countries are split over whether to agree strict rules on killer robots – lethal autonomous weapons (LAWs) – and campaigners have serious doubts that the United Nations in Geneva is the best place to ... […]
- Statement to the Convention on Conventional Weapons Group of Governmental Experts on lethal autonomous weapons systems, Geneva on March 27, 2019 at 7:16 am
For the Campaign to Stop Killer Robots, our preferred option for addressing the humanitarian and international security challenges posed by fully autonomous weapons—or “LAWS”—is for states to ... […]
- Calls to ban ‘autonomous killer robots’ after Nobel prize winners warn they could ‘go rogue’ on March 26, 2019 at 9:33 am
Campaigners think the robots will be lethal if they fall into the wrong hands ... "By nature of being cheap and easy to mass produce, lethal autonomous weapons can fall into the hands of terrorists ... […]
- In ‘Killer Robots’ debate, Japan shuns fully automated arms on March 25, 2019 at 10:06 am
Nobushige Takamizawa spoke at Monday’s opening of the latest weeklong meeting of government experts in Geneva on the future of “Lethal Autonomous Weapons Systems,” also known as “Killer Robots.” ... […]
via Google News and Bing News