A Case Western Reserve University professor wondered why some types of research were more apt to secure federal grants, while others—especially exploratory science—often didn’t.
Using the National Institutes of Health (NIH) as a case study, Assistant Philosophy Professor Chris Haufe concluded that hypothesis-based research has the edge over discovery research for several reasons that he explains in a new paper.
Haufe discusses the NIH’s peer-reviewed grant process in his Studies in History and Philosophy of Science journal article, “Why do funding agencies favor hypothesis testing?”
Hypothesis-driven research is based on scientific theories, while exploration is based on a search for discovery backed by few theories or none at all.
While looking into the types of research most often funded, Haufe shows that instructions to reviewers and applicants strongly favor hypothesis-based inquiries that are related to and relevant to current science issues.
For example, Haufe reports that the NIH guidelines for RO1 grants (described by the NIH as investigator-initiated or a response to a program announcement or request for application) to researchers advise applicants, “A strong grant application is driven by a strong, solid hypothesis with clear research objectives. The specific aims are a formal statement of objectives and milestones of the research project towards testing the hypothesis.”
The article offers two explanations why the NIH prefers hypothesis testing: The research is driven by best practices (how to do and test science), and it’s easy for peer reviewers to separate good from bad science based on the research methods.
Those with a realistic chance to prove what they set out to find and have the biggest impact for the public’s benefit tend to receive the federal research dollars, Haufe concludes.
With hypothesis testing, researchers present what the study hopes to accomplish, how it will be done and possible outcomes. Many researchers also conduct pilot studies or draw from findings by other researchers to build a strong case for future success.
Exploratory research, however, is driven more by hope and chance of discovery, Haufe writes.
Funding success also tends to take the path of least risk, Haufe explains.
Hypothesis testing takes the next step in scientific theory, having already stood the rigors of examination. Meanwhile, exploratory research examines unknown areas with no or little-known theories to back them—perceived as a riskier bet.
Haufe said the federal government, with limited funding, wants to support research where there’s a chance of success that serves both public and science interests. The closer the research is to what’s already known also improves chances of funding, he reports.
The science community has long accepted hypothesis testing.
The Latest on: Exploratory funding
- The end of an era in the exploration of Europa on November 12, 2018 at 1:43 pm
NASA had not requested any funds for a Europa mission, though the agency was funding studies on what such a mission might look like. The following year, Culberson included $100 million in the FY 2015 ... […]
- A different trajectory for funding space science missions on November 12, 2018 at 1:43 pm
That’s included a particular emphasis on missions to Jupiter’s moon Europa (see “The end of an era in the exploration of Europa”, The Space Review, this issue.) That rising tide, though, has lifted ot... […]
- Total and ADNOC join forces to launch Unconventional Gas Exploration in Abu Dhabi on November 12, 2018 at 3:12 am
Total will operate the exploration phase of this new concession with a 40% ... Amazing Energy Oil & Gas Co. (AMAZ:OTCQX) closed on a funding transaction in which Joint Venture Working Interest Partner... […]
- Kebotix Raises $5m in Seed Funding on November 8, 2018 at 8:57 am
based AI and robotics tech company, came out of stealth mode with a $5m seed funding. The round was led by One Way ... technology developed at Harvard University to accelerate the exploration, discove... […]
- Core Exploration adds lithium to name amid transition to battery metal producer on November 8, 2018 at 12:18 am
Core Exploration Ltd’s (ASX:CXO ... English added: “We are confident that once all permits are granted and funding is secured … we will be able to successfully develop the Finniss project and successf... […]
- SpaceX Seeks $750M In Debt Funding on November 7, 2018 at 9:36 am
Hawthorne, California-based SpaceX, the commercial space exploration firm run by Elon Musk, is looking to raised $750M in a leveraged loan offering, according to a report on Tuesday. The loan effort i... […]
- Tamino Minerals Starts Exploration Program and Financing Update on November 7, 2018 at 7:23 am
Tamino Minerals, Inc. ( OTC PINK : TINO ) is pleased to update its shareholders and followers on the exploration program and direct investment funding initiatives. Tamino Minerals is actively working ... […]
- Laramide Completes Acquisition of Murphy Project in Northern Territory from Rio Tinto Exploration on November 6, 2018 at 4:39 am
The Westmoreland exploration model involves targeting mineralisation ... The Northern Territory government has awarded Laramide a AUD $100,000 co-funding grant towards the completion of the ... […]
- Kefi's Ethiopian exploration tenements to be expanded on November 6, 2018 at 2:06 am
Exploration funding will likely be covered from the planned development funding and operational cash flows of TKGM, which will have pre-emptive rights to any additional ore on arms-length terms and su... […]
- Karlawinda announces exploration update on November 6, 2018 at 1:01 am
Highly encouraging results received from ongoing first-pass regional exploration programs over the 100%-owned Karlawinda Gold Project, which are being undertaken in parallel with project funding ... […]
via Google News and Bing News