Study shows that in the face of an epidemic, even moderate government-mandated travel restrictions would slow contagion.
In an epidemic or a bioterrorist attack, the response of government officials could range from a drastic restriction of mobility — imposed isolation or total lockdown of a city — to moderate travel restrictions in some areas or simple suggestions that people remain at home. Deciding to institute any measure would require officials to weigh the costs and benefits of action, but at present there’s little data to guide them on the question of how disease spreads through transportation networks.
However, a new MIT study comparing contagion rates in two scenarios — with and without travel restrictions — shows that even moderate measures of mobility restriction would be effective in controlling contagion in densely populated areas with highly interconnected road and transit networks. The researchers called the difference between infection rates in the two scenarios the “price of anarchy,” a concept from game theory that’s frequently used as a metric in studies of the controlled use of transportation networks.
The study, published online July 31 in the Journal of the Royal Society Interface, is the first to link the concept of price of anarchy to the spread of contagion. It assumes that transmission of the news of the epidemic (which influences how people select travel routes) and the epidemic itself follow the same mobility network, and uses standard epidemiological models to simulate the flow of contagion.
The researchers — Ruben Juanes, the ARCO Associate Professor in Energy Studies in MIT’s Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, graduate student Christos Nicolaides and research associate Luis Cueto-Felgueroso — used data from the 2000 U.S. census to establish the aggregate daily flux of people commuting between counties.
Previous research had shown that when individuals become aware of an epidemic, they travel not by taking the shortest route, but by taking the shortest route that avoids infected areas — even if they’re already infected — a strategy that exposes people in uninfected areas to disease. Such “selfish behavior,” as it’s called in game theory, is in direct opposition to the strategy of policymakers, who presumably would act in the benefit of the greater social good by routing infected individuals through areas where infection rates were already high.
The MIT study shows that the price of anarchy in some regions of the United States, such as along Interstate 95 in the Northeast, would be considerable. For a moderately contagious disease — one in which every infected person infects, on average, two others — restricting individuals to specific travel routes would decrease infection rates by as much as 50 percent.
“In an area with high connectivity, the outcome of action coordinated by officials is going to be better than selfish action, but the economic and social costs of disruption could sometimes be too high,” Juanes says. “In other cases, there would be an enormous benefit to having authorities impose travel restrictions. The price of anarchy is a quantitative measure that identifies areas where intervention might pay off.”
“Although the study is an idealized scenario, it does give insight to authorities about when and where it would be important to impose route restrictions on human mobility in the case of an emergent outbreak or in the extreme case of bioterrorism,” says Nicolaides, the paper’s first author, who was funded by a Vergottis Fellowship from the MIT School of Engineering. “But you have to take into account the structure of the underlying mobility network and its traffic properties. Imposing policy-initiated action in areas with low traffic would not render substantial benefits for the containment of an epidemic.”
The Latest Bing News on:
- Scientists have a powerful new tool for controlling the coronavirus: Its own genetic code.on October 13, 2020 at 10:05 am
Just as with testing, the nation has failed to lead when it comes to using genome sequencing to track the coronavirus.
- ‘Totally Under Control’ Director Alex Gibney on How NDAs and Political Posturing Devastated America’s Pandemic Responseon October 13, 2020 at 6:34 am
Donald Trump’s recent COVID-19 diagnosis brought all the chaos and contradictions of the pandemic into sharp focus. Between his refusal to protect himself and the people surrounding him and the ...
- Admetsys Secures CE Mark Approval for PrecisionOne™ Automated Glycemic Control and Continuous Diagnostics Systemon October 13, 2020 at 6:00 am
Admetsys Corporation, a biomedical technology company specializing in critical care automation, announced today that it received European regulatory approval (CE Mark) for its flagship PrecisionOne™ ...
- ‘Totally Under Control’: a title, definitely not a description of the White House COVID responseon October 12, 2020 at 10:11 am
From documentarian Alex Gibney and collaborators comes this enraging, necessary, and, above all, useful recap of the US coronavirus disaster.
- ‘Totally Under Control’: A no-nonsense look at how COVID-19 ran amok in the U.S.on October 12, 2020 at 3:32 am
Timely documentary contrasts government’s inaction with the responses of other countries in a crisis that continues to evolve.
- Twitter Flags Trump Tweet That He’s Immune To Covid-19 Coronavirus, Not Contagiouson October 12, 2020 at 1:17 am
Presumably, Trump was referring to the Covid-19 coronavirus infection that he’s had over the past week or so and not something like cat scratch fever or Bieber fever. The tweet sounds like positive ...
- Trump says he’s not contagious. Health experts say that’s not certain.on October 11, 2020 at 7:32 pm
President Trump tweeted on Sunday that he is “immune” to the novel coronavirus and “can’t give it,” even though the White House has not released any negative test results and immunity to the virus ...
- Trump flagged by Twitter after tweeting false claim that he's not contagious and is now immune to COVID-19on October 11, 2020 at 1:21 pm
Twitter has once again flagged one of President Trump's tweets for violating their rules on spreading misinformation about COVID-19. This time it was because of his false and dangerous claim that he ...
- Twitter slapped a warning label on Trump's tweet claiming he's immune from coronavirus and no longer contagiouson October 11, 2020 at 11:58 am
Twitter flagged Trump's tweet for violating its rules about "spreading misleading and potentially harmful information related to COVID-19." ...
- Your Sunday 6: The fly on 'SNL,' Trump's not contagious, Louisiana hit by hurricane — againon October 11, 2020 at 5:54 am
People are also talking about the winner of the French Open, hearings starting for the Supreme Court nominee, and today is National Coming Out Day.
The Latest Google Headlines on:
The Latest Bing News on:
- ‘Race against time’: France scrambles to slow Covid hospital admissionson October 13, 2020 at 4:56 am
With countries from Spain to Ukraine posting record increases in recent days, authorities are struggling to devise restrictions that slow the spread while not ... was fuelled by younger people, the ...
- The Latest: Germany's Merkel discusses virus surge in citieson October 9, 2020 at 6:35 am
Chancellor Angela Merkel is meeting with the mayors of Germany's largest cities as coronavirus cases rise in metropolitan areas.
- Trump still contagious? Experts say it’s impossible to knowon October 8, 2020 at 2:47 pm
President Donald Trump said Thursday he doesn’t think he’s contagious anymore, but medical experts say that’s impossible to know a week after his diagnosis with ...
- Rapid COVID-19 Tests Offer New Tools To Slow Pandemicon October 6, 2020 at 11:23 pm
As the COVID-19 pandemic marches on, new, rapid tests offer hope for pumping the brakes on the virus’ spread. The United States is falling far short in its testing efforts. More than 4 million tests ...
- Biden signals next debate may not happen if Trump remains contagiouson October 6, 2020 at 7:00 pm
CDC guidelines say people should isolate for 10 days from the point of showing symptoms, and 20 days in severe cases.
- White House blocks updated FDA guidelines on vaccine approvalon October 6, 2020 at 1:05 am
The White House has blocked new Food and Drug Administration guidelines on bringing potential vaccines for COVID-19 to market that would almost certainly have prevented their approval before the Nov.
- President Trump, Still Contagious, Downplays COVID-19 as He Returns to White House – Then Takes Off His Maskon October 5, 2020 at 10:18 pm
The President left the hospital where he was being treated for COVID-19 and declared that Americans should not fear the virus ...
- Stephen Jones on the Cowboys' defensive struggles, concern for La’el Collins and moreon October 5, 2020 at 9:48 pm
Cowboys executive vice president Stephen Jones joined the K&C Masterpiece on 105.3 The Fan [KRLD-FM] recently to talk about the team’s ...
- Trump, still infectious, back at White House — without maskon October 4, 2020 at 8:57 pm
President Donald Trump staged a dramatic return to the White House Monday night after leaving the military hospital where he was receiving an unprecedented level of care for COVID-19. Trump's message ...
- Nobel Prizes and COVID-19: Slow, basic science may pay offon October 3, 2020 at 12:31 am
While the world wants flashy quick fixes for everything, especially massive threats like the coronavirus and global warming, next week’s Nobel Prizes remind us that in science, slow and ...